ciraldo

[bubs]

He was just stepped and hung an arm out (although I haven't seen a replay yet)
And it was Cross he hit, so that should be a 50% reduction.
Grade 1 or 2 careless.

 

[BeenThere]

Problem with the 'just hung an arm out' defence is that he left the ground to do it.

 

[Macca]

No suspension. I called it last night right after it happened.

 

[Booyah]

Could be rest of regular season, That would mean Raper will bring Isemonger back

If he's fit.

I hope he isn't. He has a groin strain apparently.

 

[BeenThere]

"The Roosters extended their lead when Craig Fitzgibbon added a penalty following a high tackle by Cameron Ciraldo on Ryan Cross, with the Cronulla rookie lucky to stay on the field for the swinging arm." from the NRL site.

 

[Booyah]

He only belted Cross. No big drama.

That gouging wanker had it coming. If it wasn't Ciraldo it would have been someone else.

Judiciary should send him a fruit basket or something.

 

[Frenzy.]

He only belted Cross. No big drama.

That gouging wanker had it coming. If it wasn't Ciraldo it would have been someone else.

That would be a good defence Boo!! :lol:

NOT!

I'm not as confident on it today after seeing it again and from a different angle. Could be a reckless charge after all.

I will however stick with my prophecy :lol:

 

[Thomo.]

No suspension. I called it last night right after it happened.

yep thats right Macca called it. i was there when he said at the SFS!

 

[Coastal Shark]

As much as I would love to eat humble pie - I think young Cameron has a holiday coming. Looks much worse on replay.

Having said that, I hope Nostra Cap'n's prediction comes true.

 

[Macca]

yep thats right Macca called it. i was there when he said at the SFS!

I didn't say it that loud did I?

 

[Go Nulla]

What is the latest with Ciraldo has he resigned yet ?

 

[Simo]

Can somebody tell me what time of the match this happened? I havent seen it and would like to flick to it on the nrl streaming vid's.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

10 after half time

 

[Simo]

cheers reefy

 

[Simo]

Just watched it.....in my opinion nothing to bad. Yeah it copped him high but it was just a lazy arm as cross went back inside.

In my opinion those things will always happen in league but its the actions with intent that are the problem and deserve the big suspensions.

The way I had read about it I thought he must have really cleaned someone up. Not a big deal to me that tackle.