Club best & fairests

[CyberKev]

I thought I'd start this thread to get people's views on who will be the champion player at each club this season. I will update this post with the actual placegetters as each club announces its awards.

==========================================================

Adelaide
1: Simon Goodwin
2: Tyson Edwards
3: Graham Johncock

Brisbane
1: Simon Black
2: Justin Sherman
3: Luke Power

Carlton
1: Lance Whitnall
2: Brendan Fevola
3: Heath Scotland

Collingwood
1: Alan Didak
2: James Clement
2: Ben Johnson

Essendon
1: Scott Lucas
2: Jobe Watson
3: Dustin Fletcher

Fremantle
1: Matthew Pavlich
2: Peter Bell
2: Michael Johnson

Geelong
1: Paul Chapman
2: Jimmy Bartel
3: Gary Ablett Jnr

Hawthorn
1: Sam Mitchell
2: Luke Hodge
3: Brad Sewell

Kangaroos
1: Brady Rawlings
2: Nathan Thompson
3: Daniel Wells

Melbourne:
1: James McDonald
2: Cameron Bruce
3: Brock McLean

Port Adelaide
1: Brendon Lade
2: Shaun Burgoyne
3: Kane Cornes

Richmond
1: Kane Johnson
2: Andrew Raines
3: Troy Simmonds

St Kilda
1: Nick Reiwoldt
2: Jason Gram
3: Sam Fisher

Sydney
1: Adam Goodes
2: Ryan O'Keefe
2: Brett Kirk

West Coast
1: Chris Judd
2: Darren Glass
3: Ben Cousins

Western Bulldogs
1: Brad Johnson
2: Scott West
3: Daniel Cross

 

[Red Bear]

Hmmmmm
Scotty Lucas will be in with a shot. Watson also, and he will be in with a shot at most improved as well. Mark Johnson through playing every game, maybe Hille? I dunno. I'd hazard a guess at Lucas

 

[Red Bear]

Crichton Medal is on next wednesday btw

 

[Cupid Stunt]

Johno, West, Gian. But the third one is all bias.

 

[Collingwood Storm]

collingwoods is wide open top 5 in any order would be Ben Johnson, Shane O'Bree, Josh Fraser, James Clement and Alan Didak

 

[CyberKev]

The quinella at Hawthorn is a monty for Sam Mitchell and Luke Hodge.

Shane Crawford and Tim Clarke will push hard for the bronze, but its Brad Sewell for mine.

 

[Twizzle]

1. Chapman
2. Ablett (Gary jnr)
3. Ling

 

[CyberKev]

1. Chapman
2. Ablett (Gary jnr)
3. Ling

I thought Ling had put in a pretty ordinary year (particularly by his standards), Twizzle?

 

[Twizzle]

he did, normaly he'd be our No 1 player

problem is he didn't have much competition

Joel Corey and perpahs even Scarlett, but they were like the rest of the team, up and down.

 

[Red Bear]

Essendon

1. Scott Lucas
2. Jobe Watson
3. Dustin Fletcher

 

[lockyno1]

Adam McFee has been good for us as well. Fletcher will go 2nd.

 

[Red Bear]

That is actually the results lockyer, the medal was presented last night

 

[meltiger]

Bowden (J)
Simmonds
Raines

Would be my top 3

 

[meltiger]

Fatnall beat out Fevola for the Carlton B & F?


Their judges are kidding themselves...

 

[AuckMel]

collingwoods is wide open top 5 in any order would be Ben Johnson, Shane O'Bree, Josh Fraser, James Clement and Alan Didak

I suspect Heath Shaw will rate well. Clement and Didak were standouts, probably Johnson 3rd as i thought he tailed off near the end of the year. Ryan Lonie for an outsider.

 

[CyberKev]

Fatnall beat out Fevola for the Carlton B & F?


Their judges are kidding themselves...

Whitnall did have a strong year for the club in defence.

All clubs have different counting methods, too.

Some do a 3-2-1, but others are more complex.

Hawthorn has a count that scores each player each round, which is a way of ensuring defenders get a fair shot at the award. 3-2-1 systems, and the like, tend to unfairly advantage midfielders or forwards who tend to have the odd day out.

 

[camsmith]

Fatnall beat out Fevola for the Carlton B & F?


Their judges are kidding themselves...

Couldn't believe that either. What does Fev have to do to win it? Sure Whitnall has had a "decent" year... but come on Fevola at 70% of clubs would have won it i reckon.

For Richmond (similar to yours)

3. Simo
2. Bowdo (J)
1. Raines

Bowden has been great for the fact he was playing way out of position, but i cant go past Simmonds.

 

[meltiger]

For Richmond (similar to yours)

3. Simo
2. Bowdo (J)
1. Raines

Bowden has been great for the fact he was playing way out of position, but i cant go past Simmonds.

With the way ours works (Similarish to Hawthorn's setup Kev mentions above) - I feel Joel will pull it off.

 

[meltiger]

Whitnall did have a strong year for the club in defence.

All clubs have different counting methods, too.

Some do a 3-2-1, but others are more complex.

Hawthorn has a count that scores each player each round, which is a way of ensuring defenders get a fair shot at the award. 3-2-1 systems, and the like, tend to unfairly advantage midfielders or forwards who tend to have the odd day out.

Mate I just can't go past a bloke who kicked 80 odd goals in a team that bad. Fevola has claims to being one of the players of the season, not just at Carlton.

 

[CyberKev]

Mate I just can't go past a bloke who kicked 80 odd goals in a team that bad. Fevola has claims to being one of the players of the season, not just at Carlton.

I don't disagree.

I was just playing Devil's advocate.

I'd like to know what scoring mechanism the Blues have in place.