What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Curent state of the game in NZ

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,466
Over here in Australia we rarely hear how the game is going over in NZ. How is leagues current health over there ? Is the game shrinking or growing ? What can be done to get it stronger ?
 

mt.wellington

Juniors
Messages
109
Dying a slow miserable death. Some regions are completely dead like once proud league bastions West Coast. Just 5 odd years ago Wellington RL was on the verge of collapse. National comp teams like WaiCoa Bay need to pull from 6 regions to form a team that has no chance of being competitive whereas they use to have 4 teams in the Lion Red Cup days.

Auckland scene is still very strong but over 90% of that is kids grades. Players either join school rugby teams or stop playing at about the age of 15-16. The only pathway here is NRL. If you havent been picked up by a club by the age of 16-17 your dream is over.

There is a desperate need for funding from the private sector but we havent had that since BarterCard founder passed away and there is talk of restricting alcohol sponsorship so companies like Lion Nathan and DB Breweries are unlikely to be viable allies.
 
Messages
10,055
Yeah grass roots is in huge trouble

In Christchurch there were 2 Premier teams that defaulted during the season, and 1 of them had 100 put on them another week. Have heard of 100 in the Auckland comp too

Greymouth now send a team over to Christchurch that plays reserve grade

I don’t think the struggle is limited to League participation wise, seems to be a few sports heading that way
 

Matua

First Grade
Messages
5,110
The last club game I watched back in Hawkes Bay was like being at a gang function. There was no trouble or anything but it's not really inviting to players and spectators to have sidelines filled with patched guys.
 

Blair

Coach
Messages
11,204
The last club game I watched back in Hawkes Bay was like being at a gang function. There was no trouble or anything but it's not really inviting to players and spectators to have sidelines filled with patched guys.
Same, Hastings Showgrounds, circa 1997. I shared an eye-brow raise with a junior mungy*, where else would a middle-class honky from Havelock North be able to do that?

*White gumboots, black jeans, leather vest, red jersey cut off at the elbows, mullet, a tatt or two (nothing over-the-top, that came a generation or two later).
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,752
It's not necessarily just League. Team sports in general are less popular now.
I know RL is played in a lot more schools now and , of course, is now played by women.
Unfortunately the current world cup is featuring a lot of very one sided games. Making for poor TV viewing.
The good thing is the Pacific take-up. Should be an annual Pacific cup tournament to encourage it.
 

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,466
Not great reading unfortunately. I wonder if the drop off in both codes has anything to do with all this talk about head knocks ?

Any ideas how to increase participation?

Is the general support for the game falling ? For example do people watch it on TV or follow a team ?
 

Matua

First Grade
Messages
5,110
Same, Hastings Showgrounds, circa 1997. I shared an eye-brow raise with a junior mungy*, where else would a middle-class honky from Havelock North be able to do that?

*White gumboots, black jeans, leather vest, red jersey cut off at the elbows, mullet, a tatt or two (nothing over-the-top, that came a generation or two later).
You could have actually done that in Havelock North - in the Anderson Park area.

TBF, I've never had a problem with gang members on the field (especially in the Bay as I'm related to a fair few of them).
 
Messages
2,958
This still occurs in Wellington in recent years. I don't have anything against gang members or gang families personally but if you want the game to grow. Standards and strong leadership is required to bring this game in from the shadows.
The last club game I watched back in Hawkes Bay was like being at a gang function. There was no trouble or anything but it's not really inviting to players and spectators to have sidelines filled with patched guys.
 
Messages
10,055
Not great reading unfortunately. I wonder if the drop off in both codes has anything to do with all this talk about head knocks ?

Any ideas how to increase participation?

Is the general support for the game falling ? For example do people watch it on TV or follow a team ?

I don’t think general support if falling, there are quite a lot of Warriors fans with apathy towards them these days, but the rugby league rights are a big part of the Sky TV subscribers list, and I may just be pulling this stat out of my arse, I can’t speak for Auckland, but I’d say outside of Auckland, it is probably 50/50 in terms of supporting Warriors v Aussie sides

Personally in my group of mates we have 3 Warriors, 1 Panthers, 1 Raiders, 1 Dragons and 1 Manly

The general public’s response to rugby now is falling as well, the crowds have been dwindling for years and although it still gets blanket coverage, i feel the passionate supporter base has shrunk markedly over the last decade
 
Messages
10,055
This still occurs in Wellington in recent years. I don't have anything against gang members or gang families personally but if you want the game to grow. Standards and strong leadership is required to bring this game in from the shadows.

the last couple of seasons in Christchurch they’ve actually banned the spectators from drinking alcohol on the sideline. I have come across a few though that have managed to find a takeaway coffee that’s smells a lot like bourbon
 

Matua

First Grade
Messages
5,110
I don’t think general support if falling, there are quite a lot of Warriors fans with apathy towards them these days, but the rugby league rights are a big part of the Sky TV subscribers list, and I may just be pulling this stat out of my arse, I can’t speak for Auckland, but I’d say outside of Auckland, it is probably 50/50 in terms of supporting Warriors v Aussie sides

Personally in my group of mates we have 3 Warriors, 1 Panthers, 1 Raiders, 1 Dragons and 1 Manly

The general public’s response to rugby now is falling as well, the crowds have been dwindling for years and although it still gets blanket coverage, i feel the passionate supporter base has shrunk markedly over the last decade
On the bold, I don't think it's as big a number as made out, I think there's still the legacy with Sky that the Winfield Cup saved them in the early days. Still, if they had to chose between the league and the rugby they'd bounce league without a second thought.

On the Warriors, I have one friend left who is a full in supporter. He lives in Sydney, no one based in NZ who used to go to games even bother anymore. Personally I don't see the Warriors representing me as a NZer as they're a journeyman Aussie club these days (in case anyone has missed my posting the last couple of years). But I can follow the Magpies in the rugby and whenever I'm back in the Bay I always go to games with my mates who still go frequently.
 

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,466
I'd love to know what Gus Gould did in his short time with the Warriors ? He was very postive about the new pathways and the Warriors future...so we'll see.

I wonder if having some teams in the NSW Cup and QLD Cup ( like Fiji and PNG have ) would make league a more appealing option for youngsters ?

There was an article linked in another thread about the fall in player numbers ( Auckland has lost about 10% of players in the last 5 years) There were quotes from those that run the local leagues that they are aware of the problem and are looking at ways to increase participation.
 
Messages
11,293
Firstly great thread and great responses as well.

I have been and are still involved in junior Footy here in South West Sydney for the last 3-4 years. In the Wests Tigers District. This season ive done a bit of work for the Wests Juniors (club teams not reps) so ive seen 1st hand how important it is to have good systems in place to get good development in Juniors.

With the Warriors having a SG ball side (U19s) entered is 10000000000% a step in the right direction. This is the just the start. They need to get a Harold Matthews team (U17s) over here as well. With those 2 sides as well as a Jersey Flegg side (U21s) then the Warriors will have a hardened experianced Junior system which we will see the fruits in about 4-5 years.

For an example the Tigers have the following rep sides in

Andrew Johns Cup U16s
- They play in a 10 team competition against regional NSW Rep sides. I watched all of the Tigers 16s games. The team is mostly Pacific Island/Kiwi boys with a lot of strength and Power. Most of the other sides are predominantly Aussie kids. Tall and a bit lanky but have excellent tackle techniques and line runners. The Tigers had a squad of around 25-26 players with 17 suiting up for gameday plus an 18th man and a 19th and 20th man on standby. The other members of the squad that were not required on gameday were sent out to Penrith who had a similar setup where they had an U16 emerging players team (forget what it was called) where they played some Country NSW teams and had an agreement to take the squad members from the Tigers 16s that were not named but would get them game time somewhere else. So every player played every week.

Harold Matthews U17s
- They were called the Western Suburbs Magpies as Balmain Tigers also had a Harold Matts side. This Comp is unbelievable. The talent, the footy IQ, the skill, the size, the block runners, the speed everything about these kids is unreal because they are after all just kids. They all go to School. I watched about 8 rounds of the Magpies Harold Matts team. They won the Grand Final and went through the Comp undefeated. This is the future of Wests Tigers BUT NOT FOR ANOTHER 5-6 YEARS!!!!

Laurie Daley Cup U18s
- Exactly the same as AJ U16s. They play the same teams and travel with the 16s. The only difference is they have a smaller squad and dont farm out players that dont play on Gameday. Sometimes the kids that dont get picked for Harold Matts will play for the 18s.

SG Ball U19s
- Same as Harold Matts. Again the talent in the SG Ball sides from every club is next level. This year the Magpies team struggled as they are a younger team. They only won 2 drew 2 and lost 4. The majority of that team was in the Magpies Harold Matts team last season. So the expectations were for them to get a taste for the faster and bigger opponants they would face then push for top 4 next season.

Jersey Flegg U21s

- Struggled as well as they were the young after playing U19s last season

So with all of these teams they had trials on the 8th October. Teams were picked a week later on the 14th with training starting 2 days later on the 16th. I went to the trials last year and to a couple of the trainings and they are high intensity, skill focused where they held accountable for the littlest indiscretions. From now till the new year its fitness and skills with no contact. They will get tested after the Xmas break and the expectations are they will have to have maintained a good level of fitness and strength. After that its maintaining the fitness then ripping into the contact and getting the moves right for the 1st game in February. This year i seen a young kid who was a Prop. Probably the best prop in the U16s Grade for club footy. Would always make great metres and just folded kids in defence but couldnt meet the fitness standards required. Great kid to. The only fault id give the Tigers is that i didnt see any kind of mentors around for those side of things. A young Polynesian Kid from a big family who kills it on the field but eats big meals at home, no time to do extras as he has to look after younger siblings etc. Those mentors are critical for our young Polynesian players close to being in the frame for a professional career. But on game days i seen Benji, Kimmorley, Madge McGuire, Tamou down there watching and talking to the young boys. Keeping them composed but reminding them of their jobs that they had to do. When i watched them play Balmain, Paul Sironan was the Mentor for them. Sheesh he is massive but he had such an aura around the Balmain kids. 2 of them were laughing a little to loud and he just went over and said make sure you maintain your fluid levels and keep going to the toilet lol. And they did. Just kept drinking their water and started focusing again.

All my life in Christchurch and now in Sydney ive seen 100s and 100s of juniors running around. But in the last 12 months ive seen so many in the Tigers set up that going to go all the way. The kids out here are unbelievable. Ive watched a bit of junior footy in the Bulldogs District where they have lost a lot of juniors for whatever reasons and seem to be rebuilding their Junior resources. Parramatta Juniors last year only had 3 teams in their U15 Gold comp. (instead of having A and B grades NSWRL have Gold Silver and Bronze) So they came and played out here in the Tigers Comp for a couple of weeks before Covid shut down everything and their teams were really really good. However only having 3 Gold teams is a concern. Dragons Juniors system seems to be a step below as well but they have the advantage like Wests that they amalgamate with Illawarra for Senior Footy.

Penrith District are just on a whole different level. They are the cream of the crop. Watched their SG Ball team play a couple of games. WOW. I read an article a couple of seasons ago where they had 72 Girls only teams across their Juniors.

The last couple of years Wests have really invested in their Juniors and are relying on local juniors to develop and keep on developing. I think there was only 1 from the Harold Matts team that wasnt a local. It showed to when he played a couple of games.

The Warriors could use the Tigers blue print as a set up of where they need to be going forward. But the Warriors need some huge mentors. Some big name figures that can keep the kids grounded and focused

The down side to this is Footy is not fun anymore for these kids.

Training 3 days a week in the middle of summer. Having to turn up no matter what. If you have an injury to your arm or shoulder then you are racking up the kms on the bike, if you have a sore leg then you are doing upper body workouts. Most of the Harold Matts team are contracted. I know 3 or 4 from the U16s had contracts to the tigers as well. Most are for 5k. The top kids in Harold Matts maybe around 12-15k. That is mostly to cover MRIs or Physio visits etc. The top kids taste a huge amount of footy for the year, for example and ill name 2 of the best in Wests Harold Matts team from 2022 Kit Laualiili and Jordan Miller.

They came back from Xmas and New Year in 2022 and straight into training for the Harold Matts 2022 campaign. Their first game was 5th Feb. Their Grand Final was 30th April. They then have to be medically cleared to be released back to their clubs which have already started their seasons. Their Grand Final was 4th September. During the year they played for their School teams in the NSW Combined Schools Comp which is a midweek comp consisting of about 6 games. Then semi and Final. Also during the year they have the NSW zoned comp for Schools so there is another 4-5 games. At the end of that they were facing selection for the Australian Schoolboys tour of Fiji but i dont think they made it. On the 2nd of October Kit played for NSW Fiji U18s against NSW Maori U18. a week after that he had trials for Wests SG Ball team which he sat out as he is already contracted. From there he has been training for the 2023 campaign.

Thats 52 weeks of footy. Im sure he had a week off here and there but hes just turned 17 and he has footy every week of the year. Can the Warriors drum these work ethics into our kids in Auckland????

Thats the 64 million dollar question
 
Messages
11,293
Sorry for the ramble guys but thats the blue print to have a junior structure setup in the NRL. And thats just for kids. The Warriors must have this mentality to be successful but they have to be patient
 
Messages
10,055
On the bold, I don't think it's as big a number as made out, I think there's still the legacy with Sky that the Winfield Cup saved them in the early days. Still, if they had to chose between the league and the rugby they'd bounce league without a second thought.

On the Warriors, I have one friend left who is a full in supporter. He lives in Sydney, no one based in NZ who used to go to games even bother anymore. Personally I don't see the Warriors representing me as a NZer as they're a journeyman Aussie club these days (in case anyone has missed my posting the last couple of years). But I can follow the Magpies in the rugby and whenever I'm back in the Bay I always go to games with my mates who still go frequently.

Rugby will always be their number 1 and bread and butter but the NRL i think is still a huge selling point for them

I have a mate who used to organise his entire weekend around watching the Warriors, since they announced the signing of Matt Lodge he barely bothers to watch now
 
Messages
10,055
Sorry for the ramble guys but thats the blue print to have a junior structure setup in the NRL. And thats just for kids. The Warriors must have this mentality to be successful but they have to be patient
No ramble, one of the best posts in years

Interesting the quantity of work getting pushed onto these young kids, the concern about the workload being pushed so hard comes when they reach the point the clubs decide they won’t make it and cut them loose and suddenly they’ve been footy footy footy for years and the dream is gone and the mental side of things can come into play. That sort of system as well is why we will just continue to see robots produced and the natural footy players in the mould of Cliffy Lyons are pretty much extinct

always enjoyed reading your lower grade wraps, can remember the first time you saw Olakau’atu, he certainly has lived up to your billing
 

Blair

Coach
Messages
11,204
Sorry for the ramble guys but thats the blue print to have a junior structure setup in the NRL. And thats just for kids. The Warriors must have this mentality to be successful but they have to be patient
Melbourne's blueprint is to just scout and poach the best young talent from that whole Tigers set-up you told us about.

Tell me this won't be the case!
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,752
Excellent post R&S.

I have long thought that until the Warriors get a handle on developing local talent we are going to be struggling.
The best years for the Warriors was when our junior teams were strong. (The John Ackland era.)
I really doubt that our current ownership and management have the willingness or skills to take this to the level required.
I think, for it's own good, the NRL may need to make it a condition of a club joining that they can field a certain number of Junior teams. But then we get the problem of where they are going to play each week.

Anyone with any ideas about this please joinin.
 

Latest posts

Top