Denan Kemp or David Williams

[Stizyler]

And Kemp last season?

Thats a pretty stupid thing to say really, seeing he only played last season in the origin period and was only a regular starter this season, also remembering 3 years ago he hadn't played a game of league in his life.

 

[Lungfish]

Williams by a short half head ...

 

[Hanscholo]

Williams from an all round perspective. I do think though that Kemp will provide better long term return as Williams is injury prone.

 

[Lungfish]

Just like Ben Kenedy ....

 

[Inferno]

Luke Covell. Highest pointscorer in the league

 

[Everlovin' Antichrist]

Yeah, Joel Caine was once too....

 

[badav]

And Kemp last season?

Kemp went very well last season actually. And the one before that too.

Inu fell flat as soon as he copped his big contract upgrade, and then came out mid season and starting talking about the salary cap and how players are going to leave because of it. On his form this season he won't have to worry about that.

 

[cb4]

wolfman but only just......

 

[Deacon]

Boyd.

 

[tiger_nick]

kemp, williams is just a good finisher imo. kemp scored many great individual tries and has speed to burn.

 

[miccle]

Both!

1. Hunt
2. Kemp
3. Folau
4. Hodges
5. Williams
6. Lockyer
7. Wallace

:crazypity we'd have to play u14's in the forwards once that lot takes their paycheques)

 

[cb4]

lol

 

[Brutus]

Tony Kemp

 

[Where Eagles Dare]

I'll never forget that try Kemp scored for the Baby Broncos against us at Brookie, great individual effort. That said, as a Manly supporter the Wolfman has grown on me immensely so (probably due to bias) I wouldn't swap him. I just love how much he enjoys his footy, you can tell he's just loving being out there in first grade. We should watch him when he gets a run for the Kangaroos, he may need a change of pants.

 

[Talanexor]

Wait until the 2009 season - then everyone will realise the Cowboys got the better of the Williams brothers (John, not Ty, I know someone was thinking it)

But out of those two I'd pick Kemp, he looks a bit fragile, but then again, he doesn't get tackled that often.

 

[watatank]

Kemp

 

[Kiki]

talan yeh john is an awesome player, i feel a bit sorry for him being stuck in an underperforming team this year. hope he gets a better chance next year.

am i sensing people are turning against davey since he's been all over the papers? such a fickle bunch you are!

 

[Tommax25]

Kemp, Williams is good but Kemp is younger and has more potential and I believe is just generally better. TBH I don't think Williams is that great, he had a beard, the wolfman idea caught on, more novelty value then anything. I reckon Robertson is alot better

kemps only a few months younger, its not like the wolfmans 25 and hes 21....and the wolfman.

plus why are people saying inu, boyd ect? the thread is about these two speific players, far out

 

[shiznit]

how the hell the warriors got Kemp is beyond me... they signed him up and then a couple of days later he scored 4 tries V parra... talk about lucky.... if he had held out another week i reckon the broncos would have offered him abit more...

 

[kingdamo]

how the hell the warriors got Kemp is beyond me... they signed him up and then a couple of days later he scored 4 tries V parra... talk about lucky.... if he had held out another week i reckon the broncos would have offered him abit more...

We planned accordingly :lol: