Discipline Let Us Down: Raper

[millersnose]

What exactly did Peachey do to be binned? He was in the ruck area but did he intentionally trip up the dogs player? It's pretty hard to tell. He does bump him with his leg but it may not have been intentional.

your kidding.....................right?

 

[millersnose]

Don't confuse offside for play the ball infringements.

i am not

 

[Jimbo]

I thought I heard somewhere that he was sent off for dissent. Anyone?

 

[Macca]

What exactly did Peachey do to be binned? He was in the ruck area but did he intentionally trip up the dogs player? It's pretty hard to tell. He does bump him with his leg but it may not have been intentional.

your kidding.....................right?

No I am not. I have watched it 4 times. He just gives him a nudge. It doesn't look intentional. That doesn't mean it wasn't but the ref over reacted IMO.

 

[millersnose]

fair enough mcsharkie

he may have "accidently" got in the way for 5 seconds when the dogs were in a try scoring position

riggghhht :|

 

[blacktip-reefy]

I think it was completely intentional by Peach.
& he was right to do so.
There was one penalty against the dogs (play the ball).
The rest was offside & stripping.

 

[Macca]

5 seconds is a gross exaggeration. He was there for just over a second and the guy took a dive. He probaly was niggling but it wasn't a binnable offence. If it was then there is 20 a week that go unnoticed.

 

[millersnose]

ok then :?