What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

DT: Eels Send SOS to Smith

benoir91

Juniors
Messages
1,584
TIM Smith is almost certain of a return to Parramatta's first-grade side on Friday night after Michael Hagan's Eels stumbled to their first loss of the season against the Warriors yesterday. While Parramatta managed 28 unanswered points in the second half against the Bulldogs in round one, they failed to stem a three-try black tide after the break at Mt Smart Stadium with enigmatic Warriors winger Manu Vatuvei finishing with a brace in their 30-16 win.

After a stint in rehab and shoulder surgery, Smith has been biding his time with feeder team Wentworthville over the past two weeks.
"We've said we wanted to give him a couple of games to give him his confidence and some match fitness - he's done that now," Hagan told The Daily Telegraph last night at the Auckland Crowne Plaza Hotel.
"We'll reassess how he is physically and assess everyone this week with Newcastle in mind.
Related Links





"He'll certainly be in the frame this week. We've got some quality players to come back in, in the next couple of weeks."
Smith and second-rower Nathan Hindmarsh (illness) are both set to return for Friday's clash with Hagan's former club Newcastle at Parramatta Stadium. Five-eighth Feleti Mateo is tipped to go back into the forwards with Brett Finch partnering Smith in the halves.
Hagan admitted it was not ideal that Jarryd Hayne, Weller Hauraki and Junior Paulo were playing their first comp games of the year yesterday after being stood down because of the infamous pre-season shooting incident.
The Eels took an early lead with Luke Burt's penalty goal and winger Eric Grothe's try when he dashed past the unique Vatuvei, who had a woeful start to the afternoon.
But not long afterwards, Vatuvei got one back when he beat Hayne and Grothe to the line and there were signs of the effervescent Warriors of old with hot-potato passing and daring raids.
Halfback Grant Rovelli kicked ahead and then took the inside pass from Jerome Ropati for the 27th-minute try that set up the six-point halftime lead.
After the break there was at least the embryo of another epic Eels revival. After yet another Vatuvei fumble, Hayne made a long incision and, on the last tackle, winger Joel Reddy crossed unopposed on the left.
Perhaps the turning point of the game came when Vatuvei actually took a bomb and ran 15 metres. After a Joe Galuvao fumble, the giant winger scored off Michael Witt's grubber; he looked to close his eyes and pray as he attempted to dot down without error.
"There was a period where we were put under some pressure, made some bad errors and they scored a couple of quick tries," Hagan reflected.
"There can be no questioning the effort but execution wasn't great at times. There's a lot to look forward to still. Some blokes haven't played a lot of football yet. We'll have to get better in the next couple of weeks and I'm sure that will happen."
WARRIORS 30 (M Vatuvei 2, G Rovelli, B Tate, E Tuimavave tries; M Witt 5 goals) PARRAMATTA 16 (E Grothe, J Reddy, L Burt tries; L Burt 2 goals) at Mt Smart Stadium. Referee: S Hayne. Crowd: 15,250.

http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/sport/nrl/story/0,26799,23420616-5006066,00.html
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
155,415
Smith is hardly a consistent match winner.

I dont see him helping us that much, he's too inconsistent.

We let a lot of points in the second half, we needed a defence not a half back.

Hindy is the one that should receive an SOS.
 

Hellsy

Immortal
Messages
30,754
I watched Tim throw about 6 forward passes at Wenty yesterday........ while he did set-up alot of plays it seems he hasnt quite cut the forward pass issue from his game
 

FUIFUI_MOIMOI

Juniors
Messages
2,448
Johns influences the flat passes and i think timmy is trying slighly too much to impress and its not paying off. I have no doubt he will get it right though, hes a talent.
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
Hellsy said:
I watched Tim throw about 6 forward passes at Wenty yesterday........ while he did set-up alot of plays it seems he hasnt quite cut the forward pass issue from his game
He always seemed to do that a lot more at the start of each season though didn't he? Got more accurate as the year went on...
 

big boppa eel

Juniors
Messages
1,967
Twizzle said:
Smith is hardly a consistent match winner.

I dont see him helping us that much, he's too inconsistent.

We let a lot of points in the second half, we needed a defence not a half back.

Hindy is the one that should receive an SOS.
Ditto.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
156,856
He will definatley be needed for the rest of the season IMO, Mateo looked a one man band in attack yesterday.
 

hindmarsh4pm

Juniors
Messages
1,913
Tim is to good to be playing for wenty. He is one of the best halfbacks n the nrl when his game is on. We need him playing 1st grade if we want that premiership
 

HevyDevy

Coach
Messages
17,146
Hellsy said:
I watched Tim throw about 6 forward passes at Wenty yesterday........ while he did set-up alot of plays it seems he hasnt quite cut the forward pass issue from his game

I watched Matt Keating throw 4 in a row.

I watched most of the Parramatta team get pulled up for forward passes, dropped balls and stupid, stupid errors.

Oh and I saw Joel Reddy embarrassed by Rovelli and Tate.
 

Glenn

First Grade
Messages
7,436
AlexTheEel said:
Tim Smith is the best half back we have. A bit of support would be nice people.

Until he struggles in his first game back, then watch the knives come out. ;-)
 

Kornstar

Coach
Messages
15,578
Hellsy said:
I watched Tim throw about 6 forward passes at Wenty yesterday........ while he did set-up alot of plays it seems he hasnt quite cut the forward pass issue from his game

Problem is that Hookers throw 12 forward passes a game and 1 might get picked up......no-one whinges because the refs are too inept to pick them up.

Matt Keating threw atleast 3 forward passes yesterday, Anthony Mitchell threw about 5 and got away with all of them, i was pi$$ed off because they simply shouldn't be throwing any at all.....
 

parra pete

Referee
Messages
20,710
AlexTheEel said:
Tim Smith is the best half back we have. A bit of support would be nice people.

I think you should preface that statement with ....
"In MY opinion , Tim Smith etc etc"


I don't agree with your opinion..He is good, but he, in MY opinion, is not the best.
 

Kornstar

Coach
Messages
15,578
parra pete said:
I think you should preface that statement with ....
"In MY opinion , Tim Smith etc etc"


I don't agree with your opinion..He is good, but he, in MY opinion, is not the best.

Maybe our best halfback did his knee and is out for the season, is that what you are getting at Pete?
 

AlexTheEel

Juniors
Messages
1,762
Thats besides the point anyway. Does he need to be our best to get suport? If u wanna pile the s*it up on him be my guest. Just think u should give him a chance before writting him off.
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
Kornstar said:
Maybe our best halfback did his knee and is out for the season, is that what you are getting at Pete?
I don't see how that would qualify as the best we 'have' then
 

Latest posts

Top