Dugan Poll

[thebigredv]

Does he play against Bulldogs? A bit of a moral dilemma but an easy one for me.

 

[epDragon62]

I think Duges will determine how this plays out. If he takes it remorsefully I think he will play hard to redeem himself. On the other hand, if he carries on he can farque off to the Gumbies an outcast.

 

[slippery5]

Does he play against Bulldogs? A bit of a moral dilemma but an easy one for me.

Do we not play him in the finals if we make it in ????

 

[ALSGI]

Do we not play him in the finals if we make it in ????

YES we do.
I want him to f**k a dog next week before he goes !!

 

[Old Kogarah Boy 1]

Does he play against Bulldogs? A bit of a moral dilemma but an easy one for me.

I have no morals ................. but l still said, NO!

 

[JohnnoMcJohnno]

YES we do.
I want him to f**k a dog next week before he goes !!

Please don't offer up suggestions.

 

[OzDragon]

He'll play and I reckon he'll rip the dogs a new one. Mary said missing the game was enough punishment.

 

[SEAT 1A]

I think Duges will determine how this plays out. If he takes it remorsefully I think he will play hard to redeem himself. On the other hand, if he carries on he can farque off to the Gumbies an outcast.

Agree, it's up to him he let his mates down and the teams performed without him.

 

[roach_83]

I hope he plays otherwise it'll be Mann to center and mccrone to half back. Like him or not he can be a match winner and he is a good defender. Dugan has been with us for few years now and would like to see him wear the red V at least one more time(cross fingers that they beat the dogs)

 

[j0nesy]

I stuck up for him before the Brisbane game but I saw signs in that game that his head was elsewhere, what's worse was that I thought his attitude was toxic in that game. I've been his biggest critic since the Broncos game. But do you know what? I'd probably play him. I'd pull him aside as coach, look him in the eyes and ask him if he wants to play against Bulldogs. If he wants to play and he convinced me of his commitment then I'd pick him. The guy has earned a chance to redeem himself based his years of mostly passionate performances for our team. I reckon he needed the wake up call this week an could well be our best player next week.

 

[j0nesy]

I think Duges will determine how this plays out. If he takes it remorsefully I think he will play hard to redeem himself. On the other hand, if he carries on he can farque off to the Gumbies an outcast.

spot on mate, my thoughts exactly. I reckon he'll go on to be our best performer next week. This was a wake up he needed.

 

[St Georgio]

I would select him next week, but needs to do something off field to redeem himself!
Also commit with every ounce of his mind, body and soul!

 

[hazzbeen]

I hope he plays otherwise it'll be Mann to center and mccrone to half back. Like him or not he can be a match winner and he is a good defender. Dugan has been with us for few years now and would like to see him wear the red V at least one more time(cross fingers that they beat the dogs)

McCrone will be 7 again whether he plays or not .... thats just what I think Mary will do ....

 

[j0nesy]

McCrone will be 7 again whether he plays or not .... thats just what I think Mary will do ....

f**k, I hope not but I think you're right.

 

[JohnnoMcJohnno]

Our backline is shit anyway. May as well play Duges somewhere.

 

[Old Kogarah Boy 1]

McCrone will be 7 again whether he plays or not .... thats just what I think Mary will do ....

Can't be ................. he's being paged at the airport as we speak!

 

[slippery5]

McCrone will be 7 again whether he plays or not .... thats just what I think Mary will do ....

No he won't, we had nothing in attack compared to the spark Mann has offered & his read on the defence today was appalling which led to Panthers try.
But then again we are talking about McNOIDEA

 

[Blood Shot Eyes]

Can't be ................. he's being paged at the airport as we speak!

Thats me Im on the intercom....posing as a flight steward

 

[Blood Shot Eyes]

I live and die by my morals..........Id pick him .....no brainer

 

[Crush]

Its a really tough one. It would depend on Dugan. If he is remorseful and wants to play and make up for his poor attitude I'd play him. I get the feeling his pride is hurt. Dufty is killing him. Dugan looks silly. Dufty is playing well at fullback.