Eels Game - Mon 12/5

[Ads]

Limped through the mall earlier.

 

[Qld-Sharkie]

Read somewhere Carney could be out for a month or more.

 

[Card Shark]

No chance of Carney... lucky if he is back for round 20.

You're probably right.

 

[Ads]

Who replaces him? Did Penani make them take notice the other night or will they play it safe and go with Holdsworth? Or the smokey Lewis?

 

[Card Shark]

Who replaces him? Did Penani make them take notice the other night?

Can't see them playing him but he deserves another chance given that performance. Confidence will be high.

 

[ghoti]

Lewie's only just got his passing strength back...can't see him in the 6. I reckon in order of likelihood: Graham, Holdsworth, Penani...

 

[Ads]

Lewis named at 6. Should have been Penani.

 

[Frailty]

Sharp does not give a f**k...

Seriously, remember this guys record with Manly/Northern Eagles...

 

[Ausguy]

You're probably right.

I was serious when I said carney can and should sit the season out... get the f**king legs right.

 

[Card Shark]

I was serious when I said carney can and should sit the season out... get the f**king legs right.

Doesn't mean he's gunna be any fitter next year!

Apparently Hayne will play. Our chances nosedive if he does.

 

[RgSharks]

Doesn't mean he's gunna be any fitter next year!

Apparently Hayne will play. Our chances nosedive if he does.

If he plays injured he won't last the game. Hope he plays.

 

[Card Shark]

If he plays injured he won't last the game. Hope he plays.

Well considering he was first diagnosed to be out for 2 to 4 games & hasn't missed any, you might be right.

 

[Snoop Shark]

So looks like we might have some changes on Monday. Apparently holdsworth didn't play nsw cup and Dave Fifita will be playing.

I seriously hope holdsworth was injured today.

Can't wait to have toddy back next week

 

[Card Shark]

Playing Holdsworth is conceding defeat

 

[southland]

1. Gordon
2. Feki
3. Ashyford
4. Leutele
5. Ryan
6. Pennani
7. Robson
8. A. Fifita
9. Morris
10. D. Fifita
11. Wade Graham (vc)
12. Luke Lewis
13. Paul Gallen (c)
*****
14 Leicha
15 Tinirau Arona
16 Heighington
17 Sopoaga
18 Mexico

Pennani played great in the test match. Carney is out. He deserves a go. Dissapointingly we will probably tsee Holdsworth and Degois... Is Lewis confirmed or just a hopeful...? Don't know why he is listed as 5/8

 

[Card Shark]

If Penani isn't rewarded with a first grade spot with Carney out, we are dumb.

Young guys in form should be rewarded, especially if an opportunity arises due to injury.

 

[THE MESSIAH !!!]

If Penani isn't rewarded with a first grade spot with Carney out, we are dumb.

Young guys in form should be rewarded, especially if an opportunity arises due to injury.

Exactly if Penani dosent play he should be able to leave the club before 30th June if he wants as it shows we really do not care about him, and take it that Holdsworth is actually decent.

For that alone if Holdsworth plays tommorrow night and we lose Sharp should step down there and then