What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Extra time - Yay or nay

Extra time in regular season games…

  • Keep it?

    Votes: 10 28.6%
  • Get rid of it?

    Votes: 25 71.4%

  • Total voters
    35

TheVelourFog

First Grade
Messages
5,061
Get rid of it. Extra time is only needed when there needs to be a winner ie. semi finals.
And talking about semi finals bring back the 10 minutes each way for it and scrap GP altogether.

pretty sure they did get rid of golden point in Semis dude

edit: sorry, kind of.....5 minutes each way THEN golden point
 

Wests is Best

Juniors
Messages
816
pretty sure they did get rid of golden point in Semis dude

edit: sorry, kind of.....5 minutes each way THEN golden point

i didnt know that. has it been used yet? must of been implemented last year because thurstons field goal in the 2015 GF was not under those rules (i think??). I might be wrong
 

insert.pause

First Grade
Messages
6,462
Golden try or nothing, field goals are lotteries and the opposition should get a right of reply. Game would lose absolutely nothing by going to golden try.
 

I Bleed Maroon

Referee
Messages
26,141
I am getting fed up with it now. Enthralling contests like this shouldn't be decided by field goal pot luck. And this game once again demonstrated how f**ked the 7 tackle rule is. Milf's kick wasn't all that bad yet a small dribble over the dead ball line costs us the game in the end. As if Halves don't have enough bullshit to contend with already
 

DiegoNT

First Grade
Messages
9,378
I hate when people say field goals are a lottery. It takes a lot of work to get that field goal. And a lot to defend against it. You need to be able to punch it forward when defenders are lifting. Taumololo's runs in the last set was a thing of beauty. You have to deal with a loosening up off the rules. You have to be disciplined. You have to fight for every metre, every inch. The kicker has to weigh up so many options. Do I take it on the 40? Is the risk/reward worth the shot. This is usually done with a defender charging at you. Defence is harder. You have more leeway but you still push the limits. Every metre they gain can be the difference between a win or loss. Do you rush the kicker, and if you do will there be cover if they run it. Golden point brings out the pinnacle in defence. That tackle in the corner in tonight's game is as good as any Milford jinking try. Every mistake is amplified in gp as well.
To say golden point is just a lottery is pretty disrespectful. All the things I love about league, the toughness, the drama, the determination and desperation, the drama, players pushing their limits physically and mentally, the discipline, the tactics, it's all there in gp and its all amplified to the max
 

Pedge1971

First Grade
Messages
5,898
Considering there are more games going to GP/ET each year it's amazing they don't train for it, even if it's 10 minutes of FG practice a week

They prob do but hard to train for the fact the refs put the whistle away in GP time...
 

Pedge1971

First Grade
Messages
5,898
I hate when people say field goals are a lottery. It takes a lot of work to get that field goal. And a lot to defend against it. You need to be able to punch it forward when defenders are lifting. Taumololo's runs in the last set was a thing of beauty. You have to deal with a loosening up off the rules. You have to be disciplined. You have to fight for every metre, every inch. The kicker has to weigh up so many options. Do I take it on the 40? Is the risk/reward worth the shot. This is usually done with a defender charging at you. Defence is harder. You have more leeway but you still push the limits. Every metre they gain can be the difference between a win or loss. Do you rush the kicker, and if you do will there be cover if they run it. Golden point brings out the pinnacle in defence. That tackle in the corner in tonight's game is as good as any Milford jinking try. Every mistake is amplified in gp as well.
To say golden point is just a lottery is pretty disrespectful. All the things I love about league, the toughness, the drama, the determination and desperation, the drama, players pushing their limits physically and mentally, the discipline, the tactics, it's all there in gp and its all amplified to the max


Agree. It is shit lets get rid of it.
 

Pedge1971

First Grade
Messages
5,898
I am getting fed up with it now. Enthralling contests like this shouldn't be decided by field goal pot luck. And this game once again demonstrated how f**ked the 7 tackle rule is. Milf's kick wasn't all that bad yet a small dribble over the dead ball line costs us the game in the end. As if Halves don't have enough bullshit to contend with already

Its just a battle mate. U got dis war though!!
 

some11

Referee
Messages
23,675
http://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/wa...t/news-story/e145896b712270c29f90e2b610e54847

Surprisingly, man of the moment Thurston not only agreed with Bennett — he proposed his own system.

“I think it is a bit unlucky for the team that loses (in extra-time),” he said. “Someone who gets flogged by 40 gets no points and someone who draws after 80 minutes gets no points.

“After 80 minutes and it’s a draw both teams get one point and whoever wins in golden point gets an extra point,” he said.

“I think that would be fairer. That’s just my personal opinion.

“I am just glad we are on the right side of the scoreboard.”
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
Thurston says what dozens of forum members have been saying since GP was introduced.

Will now happen and be given sole credit for such an inspiring and competitive idea.

Also the only way it happens is if all premiership games are worth 3 points each to the winner.
 

Latest posts

Top