bartman said:
I heavily disputed that conclusion in the above thread at the time.
I glossed over it, and moved on. All I saw was a dispute over a player. None of my business so I decided to leave it until he appeared on a referee's marking. This is what I have done in the past when team lists are incomplete.
Of course it is a misunderstanding. Whoever does the website is merely a servant to the game. I (and in future, NT) don't decide or guess team lists.
Corrections are encouraged, but it makes for extra work when contradictions appear.
Quite clearly, the problem in the Player Movements thread is that it slightly hijacked with a question mark over one player. When it comes to data entry, I don't want to read that. I recall that Pistol asked for the thread to get back on track.
FTR, I used to PM captains asking for clarification and I also used to search through threads trying to work out player movements. I was happy to do that. But nowadays I only have time to look at the Player Movements thread in F7s mgt forum - that being the best and proper protocol for this.