What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Fitzy's league Sledge

Messages
13,584
Peter%20Fitzsimons%20OOH%20(1)-thumb-400x601-271234.jpg

“Ah yes, hello. Can I please order another Frenchman to punch 2 dozen more holes into this bald lummox’s dopey, smug head again please? Thank you.”
 

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,401
I love the way a Fitzsimons book appears on the shelves each Christmas on such obscure Australian history topics such as Kokoda, Eureka Rebellion and this years Burke and Wills.

Who knew of these subjects before cumhead decided to plow into the archives to research these previously unheard-of moments in history?
 

DIOGENES

Juniors
Messages
1,696
I have a little to do with academic historians who hate this guy with a passion.
They spend their lives getting the qualifications and doing the research to write something new and are lucky to sell 300 copies.
With no qualifications and little effort this guy regurgitates stuff dragged up by an honours student and gets a Xmas best seller
I once posted a comment on SMH challenging his credentials and it was moderated out for being disrespectful
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
I have a little to do with academic historians who hate this guy with a passion.
They spend their lives getting the qualifications and doing the research to write something new and are lucky to sell 300 copies.
With no qualifications and little effort this guy regurgitates stuff dragged up by an honours student and gets a Xmas best seller
I once posted a comment on SMH challenging his credentials and it was moderated out for being disrespectful
so is he a plagiarist?
 

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,401
I have a little to do with academic historians who hate this guy with a passion.
They spend their lives getting the qualifications and doing the research to write something new and are lucky to sell 300 copies.
With no qualifications and little effort this guy regurgitates stuff dragged up by an honours student and gets a Xmas best seller
I once posted a comment on SMH challenging his credentials and it was moderated out for being disrespectful

They should just get a job working for him. By all accounts they are effectively ghost written.
 

DIOGENES

Juniors
Messages
1,696
Not a plagarist as such but the story is that he has young Masters and PhD students do "his" research and they get a minor mention in the credits. Its all pretty poor stuff from an academic history pov in any case
 

DIOGENES

Juniors
Messages
1,696
Indeed that is what happens. I don't know what they are paid but when I called him out on a fairly commonly argued current theme about Gallipoli it drew a blank response and it was moderated out.
 

Dodgy

Juniors
Messages
733
That is incredible insight. It's actually disappointing to know. I suppose he feigns his passion for Australian history so well.
 

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
50,459
Lol, bumpity, bumpity bump.

I have read one of his books, on Nancy Wake, and he made an interesting and important story read like an Enid Blyton book. The bloke has the writing skills of a ten year old.
 

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,401
Backed by a team of astute researchers and editors, FitzSimons is a well-oiled publishing machine, averaging almost a book a year. The brand is well established; as Manning Clark wore his Stetson, so FitzSimons, the Cheshire-grinning republican nationalist (“and proud of it!”), dons his red bandanna. It comes as no surprise that the subtitle of Eureka is “the unfinished revolution”.

FitzSimons’ connection with the gold diggers’ rebellion began at primary school, where he dressed up as a redcoat in a Eureka re-enactment. Determined to atone for this miscasting, he leaves us in no doubt that he has changed sides. Burning with “passion”, and “poring” over documents in his “obsession” with the story, FitzSimons proclaims his epiphany:

The action! The characters! The fact – and this was perhaps the key – that this was a real Australian story … I felt I was getting to the very foundation stones of what it is to be an Australian – from multiculturalism to mateship, from our broad mistrust of the elites who would seek to rule over us, to our wide embrace of egalitarianism and insistence on a ‘fair go, mate’, to the very use of the word ‘mate’.

Such is the Fitz style: attention-grabbing (“Oh dear!” “Devastating!”); reliably entertaining and narrative-driven (he ventriloquises primary sources in order to create the effect of a novel); occasionally heavy-handed (exclamation marks and italics abound); conversational in that familiar, blokey manner (“Fare thee well, Raffaello [Carboni]. You were a beaut.”); humorous (he quotes Jerry Seinfeld during his visit to Australia in 2000: “I love your flag – Great Britain at night.”); and entirely unapologetic in his gung-ho nationalism. FitzSimons gives the impression that he would lead the boys over the top if given half a chance, his red bandanna lighting the way for the rebels marching behind him. In his hands, the Eureka rebellion becomes a victory for the ordinary Australian over the English elite: “and when we become a republic – as we surely some day must – what better flag to choose than the Eureka flag? Say it loud. Say it proud. Exactly!”

In nearly all his books (including Eureka, even if it is not strictly military history), this is FitzSimons’ mission: to exalt the Australian spirit and nation, to raise the country from its slumber and through the power of its ‘stories’ of military endeavour and heroic struggle, urge it onwards to republican independence. Yet perhaps it’s precisely the glaring absence of the stirring foundational narrative for which FitzSimons pines that has seen Australia embrace blood sacrifice in an imperial war as the bedrock of its national consciousness.

https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2012/december/1363672450/mark-mckenna/lest-we-inflate
 

magpie_man

Juniors
Messages
1,973
I find it ironic that a guy who, on one page, will wax lyrical about the virtues of the Australian spirit with such well-worn stereotypes like "our broad mistrust of the elites who would seek to rule over us, to our wide embrace of egalitarianism and insistence on a ‘fair go, mate'"
will, on the next page, sneer condescendingly at the sport who's very genesis was one fundamentally based on egalitarianism and giving the players (see workers) a fair go, mate. All while he fawns over a sport that is largely confined to the milieu of the elites who would seek to rule over us.
 

Pedge1971

First Grade
Messages
5,898
I find it ironic that a guy who, on one page, will wax lyrical about the virtues of the Australian spirit with such well-worn stereotypes like "our broad mistrust of the elites who would seek to rule over us, to our wide embrace of egalitarianism and insistence on a ‘fair go, mate'"
will, on the next page, sneer condescendingly at the sport who's very genesis was one fundamentally based on egalitarianism and giving the players (see workers) a fair go, mate. All while he fawns over a sport that is largely confined to the milieu of the elites who would seek to rule over us.

Maybe thats cause he is a condescending merkin?
 

taipan

Referee
Messages
22,500
Maybe thats cause he is a condescending merkin?


When someone is so arrogantly full off themselves,it is impossible to get a grip on the real life that exists in the burbs.
Waxes lyrical about Union in France,ignores (despite being a WW2 History buff)the realities of that code's involvement in Vichy and rugby league's demise as a result of that collusion.
 

Latest posts

Top