For Phil's benefit

[westie]

it was on the official forum as you well know

and you know as well as I do that you said it - it resulted in a 3 page argument between you and myself that I am willing to bet innsaneink remembers too as he was laughing at how fired up I got.

Doesn't honestly bother me if you admit it though, I have more interesting things to do with my time than argue with a 14 year old]

Phil doesn't :lol:

Brook, are you going to sit there and say that I said this: Dene Halatau is crap, and will never make it in the NRL??? . You know quite well I said nothing of the sort.

The only time I have commented in any way negatively on Halatau was earlier this year to suggest that his defense would suggest he is better suited to the 2nd row. Good call, no?

 

[Eddie.]

Doesn't honestly bother me if you admit it though, I have more interesting things to do with my time than argue with a 14 year old

:lol:

GO THE HALATAU!!

 

[Anonymous]

I swear I saw it on here. Either way, that is definately what was said.

 

[westie]

I swear I saw it on here. Either way, that is definately what was said.

Been sniffing the glue buddy?

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Westie the funny thing is you still fail to realise that I wasn't the one who brought the subject up in the first place :roll:

Max, I was simply asking Phil to prove an unfounded accusation he made against me, he was unable to do so and thus I feel an apology is due.

Apology yeah right for you being wrong ??? I can't help the fact that you started this thread and it ended up proving to everyone my point exactly :roll:

The people who you call liars are the ones that YOU should apologies too but hey its Westie we are dealing with so we all know that won't happen :roll:

Unfounded yeah right :roll: Especially given that at least 4 people have agreed with me including 1 who started this issue (which wasn't me) but hey I guess that would mean all 5 of us are liars then is that correct ?????

Ink, you appear to have misunderstood the point of the post. This was a topic where people could come in and testify that I said "Dene Halatau is crap, and will never make it in the NRL which according to Phil is a statement I made sometime last year. As nobody has come in to say that this is this case I will assume he was once again bullshitting every one.

Its clear you have a case of selective reading or maybe its a case of needing to read things twice so I will give you the benifit of the doubt and re post what some people have posted

It was pretty much that

Westie everyone knows you dont or didnt rate the guy,i'm not surprised that your not man enough to admit,hide behind this find the impossible to find quote thing all you like,people like myself know the truth

the exact quote was along the lines of 'wouldn't play first grade for any other club in the nrl'
I'm not suprised you're still trying to distance yourself from it

["Balmain_Boy"]Yeh that's exactly what I remember on leagueunlimited. But there's been many other instances as well.[/quote]

Brook, as I have already said, no one would say that a player couldn't make an NRL side. We regularly see park footballers lining up for NRL clubs. It is completely ridiculous to think any player wouldn't be capable of playing FG.

Thats the funniest backflip if I have ever seen one whats your thoughts on Simon Greally then :lol: :lol:

Wrighty, I have no idea what you were thinking when you wrote that. What made you think I would ask you to find a post to support Phil's ridiculous argument.

Ready above would indicate there is no argument as what do they say on the net

"WESTIE IS OWNED"

Have a good night Westie and I hope those wet dreams don't keep you up too much ;-)

 

[innsaneink]

it was on the official forum as you well know

and you know as well as I do that you said it - it resulted in a 3 page argument between you and myself that I am willing to bet innsaneink remembers too as he was laughing at how fired up I got.

Doesn't honestly bother me if you admit it though, I have more interesting things to do with my time than argue with a 14 year old

Now you mention it, I do recall that stoush......surprised at the passion and conviction in your posts Brook (justified too if I recall correctly)....I sorta saw the fiery side of ya I think...well ur postings anyhow.

 

[Suzie]

it was on the official forum as you well know

and you know as well as I do that you said it - it resulted in a 3 page argument between you and myself that I am willing to bet innsaneink remembers too as he was laughing at how fired up I got.

Doesn't honestly bother me if you admit it though, I have more interesting things to do with my time than argue with a 14 year old

Now you mention it, I do recall that stoush......surprised at the passion and conviction in your posts Brook (justified too if I recall correctly)....I sorta saw the fiery side of ya I think...well ur postings anyhow.

I remember that too. Brook you got quite heated about it. Guess you can add me to the lot of idiots and liars :lol: :lol:

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Now you mention it, I do recall that stoush......surprised at the passion and conviction in your posts Brook (justified too if I recall correctly)....I sorta saw the fiery side of ya I think...well ur postings anyhow.

Spot on mate !!! But hey we are all liars according to Westie :roll:

 

[Mighty Tiger]

I remember that too. Brook you got quite heated about it. Guess you can add me to the lot of idiots and liars :lol: :lol:

Oh another one Westie by the looks of things you have just made your self look like the biggest goose on the forums - either that or your calling us all Liars :roll:

Just to think you wanted an apology :roll:

We all expect an apology now!!!!!

 

[magpiemax]

I'm sure by now he is frantically looking for the 'HOW DO YOU DELETE A THREAD' section for this one. :lol:

 

[magpiemax]

You see the rule with thread's is when you want to bash some one and start a thread against them.
RULE 1:Make sure they are not more popular than yourself otherwise it is quite easy to be humiliated. :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[innsaneink]

 

[westie]

Phil, lets make this easy. I asked for ONE person to come forward to say that I said Dene Halatau is crap and will never make it in the NRL. Not ONE person has come forward to say that I did. The closest thing to it was Dale suggesting that I didn't put Dene Halatau in an elite Flegg and PL players list.

How long do you need to find a quote Phil? How long will you continue to bullshit in your petty little arguement with a 15 y.o? Not one person has stepped forward to back up your claim. As I said, the closest you came was me started a thread that DIDN'T EVEN CONTAIN DENE'S NAME!

And to add another feather to your bullshitting cap you are now suggesting that I called every one liars? Please, I would have thought you would have learnt not to make shit up on a forum where quotes are easily retrievable. But, I spose I made that quote on a forum that has recently shut down did I?

Still waiting on that apology....

 

[Balmainia]

calm down ppl

this isn't parliament

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Westie your right you have always respected Dene, always though he was a gun, always thought he would play in the NRL, always thought he would wear a Rep jersey, always thought he was good enough to play for another side in the NRL, always thought that he had talent to burn, always thought he was a good junior

What BS and this thread shows that by the fact no one has agreed with you!!!!!!

Phil, lets make this easy. I asked for ONE person to come forward to say that I said Dene Halatau is crap and will never make it in the NRL. Not ONE person has come forward to say that I did. The closest thing to it was Dale suggesting that I didn't put Dene Halatau in an elite Flegg and PL players list.

Its clear you either have a case of selective reading or your can't read English :roll: :roll:

For the 3rd time

It was pretty much that, not word for word however.

Over on the old official forum

Westie everyone knows you dont or didnt rate the guy,i'm not surprised that your not man enough to admit,hide behind this find the impossible to find quote thing all you like,people like myself know the truth :lol:

the exact quote was along the lines of 'wouldn't play first grade for any other club in the nrl'

I'm not suprised you're still trying to distance yourself from it :roll:

I swear I saw it on here. Either way, that is definately what was said.

I remember that too. Brook you got quite heated about it. Guess you can add me to the lot of idiots and liars :lol: :lol:

Pffftttt.
Westie when your man enough to admit that Dene Halatau is one of our elite youngsters you might have the right to give other people a hard time :lol:

Now you mention it, I do recall that stoush......surprised at the passion and conviction in your posts Brook (justified too if I recall correctly)....I sorta saw the fiery side of ya I think...well ur postings anyhow.

Yeah so I guess your right you always rated Dene highly and you never bagged him or thought he was shit :roll: :roll: But hey I guess your way of saying someone is sooo good is by saying they wouldn't make anyother NRL side :roll:

Oh not to mention the 1st person to have raised this topic in the 1st place and yet you have avioded this everytime it has been raised

About time I say.. agree that anyone who doesn't rate Halatau should not be starting threads like this.

How long do you need to find a quote Phil? How long will you continue to bullsh*t in your petty little arguement with a 15 y.o? Not one person has stepped forward to back up your claim. As I said, the closest you came was me started a thread that DIDN'T EVEN CONTAIN DENE'S NAME!

Again a classic case of not being able to read :roll: :roll:

How about you read above maybe 4th time lucky :roll:

The comments you made where on the Wests Tigers official forum not on LU but hey everyone who has agreed with me and everyone who has mentioned it was on the other forum must all be Liars as well since they agree with me :roll:

Its clear that no one has come to your aid in support to say you never said it - however there has been posts that have said you have bagged him but hey your right and I'm wrong :roll:

And to add another feather to your bullshitting cap you are now suggesting that I called every one liars? Please, I would have thought you would have learnt not to make sh*t up on a forum where quotes are easily retrievable. But, I spose I made that quote on a forum that has recently shut down did I?

In avioding what everyone is saying about the fact you have posted on the other forum

In avioding the fact that it wasn't even me who started anything related to you and the fact you don't rate Dene

In avioding the fact that you are calling me a liar when infact no one has come to your defence but instead has agreed with me

I guess your right your not calling anyone but me a liar :roll:

Still waiting on that apology....

I know we all waiting for it from you but its something we know we will never get :roll:

Westie where is all your support ???? Where is everyone who is saying you never said it ????? Where is everyone saying you have nothing but praise for Dene ????? :roll:

I guess the main question you need to ask yourself

Why is everyone agreeing that you didn't rate Dene if infact you did rate him and not to mention the fact that no one would know if you never publicly admitted otherwise ;-)

 

[westie]

Westie your right you have always respected Dene, always though he was a gun, always thought he would play in the NRL, always thought he would wear a Rep jersey, always thought he was good enough to play for another side in the NRL, always thought that he had talent to burn, always thought he was a good junior

What BS and this thread shows that by the fact no one has agreed with you!!!!!!

Phil, lets make this easy. I asked for ONE person to come forward to say that I said Dene Halatau is crap and will never make it in the NRL. Not ONE person has come forward to say that I did. The closest thing to it was Dale suggesting that I didn't put Dene Halatau in an elite Flegg and PL players list.

Its clear you either have a case of selective reading or your can't read English :roll: :roll:

For the 3rd time

It was pretty much that, not word for word however.

Over on the old official forum

Westie everyone knows you dont or didnt rate the guy,i'm not surprised that your not man enough to admit,hide behind this find the impossible to find quote thing all you like,people like myself know the truth :lol:

the exact quote was along the lines of 'wouldn't play first grade for any other club in the nrl'

I'm not suprised you're still trying to distance yourself from it :roll:

I swear I saw it on here. Either way, that is definately what was said.

I remember that too. Brook you got quite heated about it. Guess you can add me to the lot of idiots and liars :lol: :lol:

Pffftttt.
Westie when your man enough to admit that Dene Halatau is one of our elite youngsters you might have the right to give other people a hard time :lol:

Now you mention it, I do recall that stoush......surprised at the passion and conviction in your posts Brook (justified too if I recall correctly)....I sorta saw the fiery side of ya I think...well ur postings anyhow.

Yeah so I guess your right you always rated Dene highly and you never bagged him or thought he was sh*t :roll: :roll: But hey I guess your way of saying someone is sooo good is by saying they wouldn't make anyother NRL side :roll:

Oh not to mention the 1st person to have raised this topic in the 1st place and yet you have avioded this everytime it has been raised

About time I say.. agree that anyone who doesn't rate Halatau should not be starting threads like this.

How long do you need to find a quote Phil? How long will you continue to bullsh*t in your petty little arguement with a 15 y.o? Not one person has stepped forward to back up your claim. As I said, the closest you came was me started a thread that DIDN'T EVEN CONTAIN DENE'S NAME!

Again a classic case of not being able to read :roll: :roll:

How about you read above maybe 4th time lucky :roll:

The comments you made where on the Wests Tigers official forum not on LU but hey everyone who has agreed with me and everyone who has mentioned it was on the other forum must all be Liars as well since they agree with me :roll:

Its clear that no one has come to your aid in support to say you never said it - however there has been posts that have said you have bagged him but hey your right and I'm wrong :roll:

And to add another feather to your bullshitting cap you are now suggesting that I called every one liars? Please, I would have thought you would have learnt not to make sh*t up on a forum where quotes are easily retrievable. But, I spose I made that quote on a forum that has recently shut down did I?

In avioding what everyone is saying about the fact you have posted on the other forum

In avioding the fact that it wasn't even me who started anything related to you and the fact you don't rate Dene

In avioding the fact that you are calling me a liar when infact no one has come to your defence but instead has agreed with me

I guess your right your not calling anyone but me a liar :roll:

Still waiting on that apology....

I know we all waiting for it from you but its something we know we will never get :roll:

Westie where is all your support ???? Where is everyone who is saying you never said it ????? Where is everyone saying you have nothing but praise for Dene ????? :roll:

I guess the main question you need to ask yourself

Why is everyone agreeing that you didn't rate Dene if infact you did rate him and not to mention the fact that no one would know if you never publicly admitted otherwise ;-)

NOT ONE OF THOSE POSTS CONTAIN THE QUOTE YOU WERE CRITIZING ME FOR.

You have repeatedly changed your arguement each and every time I have proven you wrong. Will you be man enough to admit that you invented a quote or will you continue to cat it? Some how I doubt it... Thank you for your time, you are an idiot.

 

[Suzie]

#-o You asked for a quote from a defunct forum message board westie - no-one can retrieve it, because the forum shut down. #-o Brook has supplied you a very close estimation of what was said something "along the lines of 'wouldn't play first grade in any other club in the nrl' " I thin kyou should just stop now before you end up looking really stupid - but then since I only ever talk about sattler, and obviously I lie, as I remember the thread on the WESTS TIGERS FORUM - now closed down: ie NOT WORKING - unable to have past posts retrieved - I guess you won't read this post or any of the previous ones where people have said where they saw what you wrote #-o Anyway, I'm done with this sh*t - IGNORE BUTTON

 

[Mighty Tiger]

NOT ONE OF THOSE POSTS CONTAIN THE QUOTE YOU WERE CRITIZING ME FOR.

You have repeatedly changed your arguement each and every time I have proven you wrong. Will you be man enough to admit that you invented a quote or will you continue to cat it? Some how I doubt it... Thank you for your time, you are an idiot.

Westie you really need to check my posts again because I haven't changed anything except adding more quotes to show you have f!cked up!!!!!

No one has come to your aid, yet everyone thus far has admitted you did post crap on Dene!!!!!!

I guess that means we all wrong and your right :roll:

But hey since WE CAN ALL REMEMBER IT EXCEPT YOU I guess once again we are the liars where as your the sweat and innocent victim :roll: YEAH Right !!!!!

But hey that along with an apology to everyone who you are insinuating as being Liars given that you never said anything bad about the bloke, and that you always rated him it is something we all know you will never do!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Denial at is best Westie but the funny thing is the whole forum knows what you said and yet you still deny it :roll:

 

[westie]

NOT ONE OF THOSE POSTS CONTAIN THE QUOTE YOU WERE CRITIZING ME FOR.

You have repeatedly changed your arguement each and every time I have proven you wrong. Will you be man enough to admit that you invented a quote or will you continue to cat it? Some how I doubt it... Thank you for your time, you are an idiot.

Westie you really need to check my posts again because I haven't changed anything except adding more quotes to show you have f!cked up!!!!!

No one has come to your aid, yet everyone thus far has admitted you did post crap on Dene!!!!!!

I guess that means we all wrong and your right :roll:

But hey since WE CAN ALL REMEMBER IT EXCEPT YOU I guess once again we are the liars where as your the sweat and innocent victim :roll: YEAH Right !!!!!

But hey that along with an apology to everyone who you are insinuating as being Liars given that you never said anything bad about the bloke, and that you always rated him it is something we all know you will never do!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Denial at is best Westie but the funny thing is the whole forum knows what you said and yet you still deny it :roll:

Phil please try and listen. You accused me of saying Dene Halatau was crap. NOT ONE PERSON HAS TESTIFIED THAT THIS WAS THE CASE. THUS IT IS ASSUMED THAT YOU ARE A LIAR. NOT ANY ONE ELSE, YOU

The closest you have come was somebody remembering that I said Dene would not make our team some time last year. And I was right wasn't I? Dene couldn't make the team. I think I had some pretty strong backers in Sheens and Roycie, wouldn't you say.

You have continually changed your arguement as each point you put forward is proved wrong and a lie. Please be man enough to apologise.

 

[westie]

What comment are you referring to Phil. The original comment you claimed I made was this "Dene Halatau is crap, and will never make the NRL". That is a LIE. You cannot change the quote every time you are proven to be a liar. Will you be man enough to admit you were wrong?

Please point out where I have said that you said "Dene Halatau is Crap"

This appears to be the main post that you seem to be jumping up and down about but hey prove me wrong :roll:

What BS!!!! there was bloody 4 people over here when you started talking your crap about Dene and how he had no class and would never be a first grader - he is only playing because Collis is injured - he isn't in the same class as Collis and the list goes on....

Oh and the link and please note nothing has been edited

http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/v...amp;postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=25

I will be waiting with baited breathe for you to prove me wrong :roll:

I havn't changed my quote once but hey once again your right and we are all wrong :roll:

Face it Westie you F!cked up!!!!

Oh dear, this is a f**k up of monumental proportions.

http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/viewtopic.php?t=34675&start=0

I'm still trying to work out what you you were thinking about when you wrote that. What point are you trying to make?

Well since you said that Dene is crap and would never make it in the NRL, not to mention that Collis is a better player than him :lol: :lol: :lol:

If Dene can pack on a bit of weight he'll be a good player.

He is a good player, but he would be a better player if he did add abit of size to his frame ;-)

I have convinently coloured you quote in for you.

If I was you I'd either never return to these forums for fear of ridicule and shame or grow some balls and apologise.

You lied Phil. Apologise.