Game of Thrones Mafia 3

[Rebel]

:lol: The game doesn't fully reflect the series or book. It has to be confirmed in the game.

If the loveable loch ness monster can be bad then anybody can be.

 

[soc123_au]

The Baratheon aligned you're making up you mean?

Ok, I am assuming the 3 "unknown" are Baratheon. You all but admitted about 250 posts ago.

 

[mickyj]

Hopefully the write up gives some useful info. Only one character claimed is 100% town IMO
Some others may be but until we get some solid evidence on groups being town I'm not sure we can be.

 

[Bazal]

Soc has a point BM. If you are town why would you say town should align with you? If you're town then we already are. Nothing you've posted since has convinced me you're town. The doubt always is, of.course, that you're horrible at this game

 

[Pharaohmir]

Confirmed to anybody who knows anything about Game of Thrones. Stannis is the lawful king. Melisandre has done everything in her power to fight in the best interests of the 7k since book 1/season 1.

I find this opinion funny. In the books and the show neither of them has "the best interests of the people" in mind. Stannis wants the law to be upheld at all costs, Melisandre wants to wage the holy war of the Lord of Light who is a two faced deity at best. She's a zealot and charismatic, and burns people to create her magic. She helps/convinces Stannis to kill his own brother. Best interests of the 7K has nothing to do with her plot...

 

[BunniesMan]

Ok, I am assuming the 3 "unknown" are Baratheon. You all but admitted about 250 posts ago.

I've explained that only a geniused person would think that was me admitting anything. I was arguing that the 7k has to align with me as in support me because I am one of them. "align" in the sense that town doesn't know each others allegiance so we start off as loners, we have to move towards each other.

If anybody else had said it nobody would have blinked but because it's me people look for reasons to get rid of me.

And in the census why would the Baratheons be "unknown" but a mob like the Targaryens are known?

Melisandre was 7k in the last game. And anybody who knows the theme would know Melisandre is trying to make people realise the real threat to the 7k. She has done more than almost any character for the 7k. If Jon Snow is 7k (as most people would accept) Melisandre is as well.

 

[Rebel]

By saying town should align with you, means you are not town.

Logic.

 

[mickyj]

That was pointed out at the time. Town should align with stannis and her to get ride of real threat the lannisters. And we were waiting on 9 actions including lannisters and baratheons
All added up to amounts in census and 3 baras of stannis, mel and devo are the main people there

 

[mickyj]

Reason it's ??? Might be its a group outside the normal. It's either bara or tyrell

 

[BunniesMan]

Soc has a point BM. If you are town why would you say town should align with you? If you're town then we already are. Nothing you've posted since has convinced me you're town. The doubt always is, of.course, that you're horrible at this game

No. When we don't know each other's alignment we're not aligned with anybody. Everyone is a potential scum. That is what I was trying to say. I was trying to convince every other 7k player to be on my side and not vote for me.

Is it too much to ask to be investigated before I'm killed?

I find this opinion funny. In the books and the show neither of them has "the best interests of the people" in mind. Stannis wants the law to be upheld at all costs, Melisandre wants to wage the holy war of the Lord of Light who is a two faced deity at best. She's a zealot and charismatic, and burns people to create her magic. She helps/convinces Stannis to kill his own brother. Best interests of the 7K has nothing to do with her plot...

The series is called Ice and Fire. Ice is the evil, Fire is the good. Ice is night. Fire is day. Ice is whitewalker, Fire is everybody that is good. Melisandre is the one getting people to fight the ultimate threat to the 7k.

 

[Bazal]

Reason it's ??? Might be its a group outside the normal. It's either bara or tyrell

The other thing is no way is there three separate unknowns. IMO. BM has come up as question mark aligned, no way are they anything but another faction for mine.

 

[Ozzy]

I've explained that only a geniused person would think that was me admitting anything. I was arguing that the 7k has to align with me as in support me because I am one of them. "align" in the sense that town doesn't know each others allegiance so we start off as loners, we have to move towards each other.

If anybody else had said it nobody would have blinked but because it's me people look for reasons to get rid of me.

And in the census why would the Baratheons be "unknown" but a mob like the Targaryens are known?

Melisandre was 7k in the last game. And anybody who knows the theme would know Melisandre is trying to make people realise the real threat to the 7k. She has done more than almost any character for the 7k. If Jon Snow is 7k (as most people would accept) Melisandre is as well.

You keep bringing up the last game. There is no connection with the exception of the name.

 

[BunniesMan]

You keep bringing up the last game. There is no connection with the exception of the name.

It's relevant because people seem to find it ridiculous to even entertain the idea that Melisandre is 7k. And I'm saying I'm not the only person who thinks that makes sense.

 

[9701]

I've explained that only a geniused person would think that was me admitting anything. I was arguing that the 7k has to align with me as in support me because I am one of them. "align" in the sense that town doesn't know each others allegiance so we start off as loners, we have to move towards each other.

If anybody else had said it nobody would have blinked but because it's me people look for reasons to get rid of me.

And in the census why would the Baratheons be "unknown" but a mob like the Targaryens are known?

Melisandre was 7k in the last game. And anybody who knows the theme would know Melisandre is trying to make people realise the real threat to the 7k. She has done more than almost any character for the 7k. If Jon Snow is 7k (as most people would accept) Melisandre is as well.

In the first GOT game where the saying you got 9701'd came from I was stannis and I was bad and got killed 3 times in 1 night, if you are melisandre it stands to reason you would be bad

 

[mickyj]

I was her game 2 and pretty we're saying I had to be bad then also. Bazal defended me as stannis so he got killed and me not long after.
The other 3 have to be a faction for sure. Only 2 options and she fits in one of them.
The she has to be good does not stand.

 

[Dragon2010]

In the first GOT game where the saying you got 9701'd came from I was stannis and I was bad and got killed 3 times in 1 night, if you are melisandre it stands to reason you would be bad

We've had so many 9701's since then as well. :lol:

 

[Pharaohmir]

It's relevant because people seem to find it ridiculous to even entertain the idea that Melisandre is 7k. And I'm saying I'm not the only person who thinks that makes sense.

Having no opinion on other games since this is the first Mafia game I've ever played, hell, I just got posting figured out today... I'm just going off of what I know of the characters. Mel could be nuetral, more likely is Baratheon, but is definitely not Tyrell. If she's Tyrell, I /ragequit.

 

[mickyj]

No I'm saying the only other option for the 3 unknown factions is tyrells

 

[BunniesMan]

Nobody is saying she's Tyrell...

Obviously Mel is the same faction as Stannis, and they're both 7k. Of course the lawful king of the 7 kingdoms is 7 kingdom aligned. Of course the woman trying to alert the 7 kingdoms to the biggest threat posed to the 7 kingdoms is 7 kingdom aligned.

 

[cjrankin]

Will blow for update