What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

General Discussion Thread

Panther Pete

Juniors
Messages
1,811
So if Dylan Brown can get $1.3 - $1.4 million for 10 years, what do you guys think Nathan could realistically get if he wanted out of Penrith? (I know he isn’t going anywhere but just curious what you think someone would be prepared to pay him).
 

Sime_11

Juniors
Messages
1,740
Rugby Union would have to offer 3million plus as a starting point

Nathan would and should get 2 mil now if he wanted to leave Penrith

im very interested to see what the NRL will rig for PNG to get him there
 

snickers007

Juniors
Messages
1,670
Rugby Union would have to offer 3million plus as a starting point

Nathan would and should get 2 mil now if he wanted to leave Penrith

im very interested to see what the NRL will rig for PNG to get him there

They won't need to rig anything - the Aust government has already said that players going to PNG will get tax exemptions. That doubles their take home salary instantly.

Not to mention that they'll get their accomodation handled too - so they save on rent/mortgage payments.

I suspect PNG will get their pick of young, unattached talent, but they'll have a really high turnover too. 1-2 year contracts all round. Whether they can attract anyone with young kids is the question.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
14,035
The Knights long term deal to Dylan Brown in my opinion will likely become one of the worst recruitment deals in the history of the NRL.

Many, if not most thought the Jason Taumalolo 10 year deal with Cowboys was good business but as we have seen no player is worthy of a 10 year deal.

Five year deals carry significant risks never mind 10 years.
 

WestyLife

First Grade
Messages
7,454
The Knights long term deal to Dylan Brown in my opinion will likely become one of the worst recruitment deals in the history of the NRL.

Many, if not most thought the Jason Taumalolo 10 year deal with Cowboys was good business but as we have seen no player is worthy of a 10 year deal.

Five year deals carry significant risks never mind 10 years.

They've blown their load on a running 5/8 and f**ked their cap for the next 10 years. Now they'll either have to pay an organising 7 a lot as well and be short elsewhere or expect him to do it and he's not that kind of player.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
14,035
They've blown their load on a running 5/8 and f**ked their cap for the next 10 years. Now they'll either have to pay an organising 7 a lot as well and be short elsewhere or expect him to do it and he's not that kind of player.
Surprising decision given there recruitment manager Peter O’Sullivan is so highly regarded.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
14,893
It might be a bad deal in length but I'm sure a new franchise will take Brown on board. We will have the answer in a few years.
 
Messages
4,422
It just doesn’t make any sense.

Even if he performs well, beyond expectations it doesn’t alter the fact the club has basically two players taking up a quarter of there cap.
They are gambling on the cap rising massively in the short term. As I understand it the ratchet in Brown’s contract is capped (if you believe 360).

I see this as a ploy to keep Ponga. So they show Ponga they can make a splash on the player market, get someone who is going to create some space for him (not necessarily due to passing game but by presence), and then hope that the salary cap goes up and that they can unearth a reasonably priced player (Chad Townsend level when the Sharks won) to move them around the park and kick.

If true, is it a risky strategy? Of course. But scratching around the fringe of the 8 isn’t really going to cut it.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
14,035
The Knights have had salary cap difficulties and it resulted in them not being able to retain there most explosive front rower in Leo Thompson as well as allowing one of the Safiti brothers to leave. They brought in Jackson Hastings on a reported $800k a season and he is now out of favour and no longer considered for selection. Obviously Hastings is gone at season end but the solution is to bring an even more expensive half in Dylan Brown. From the outside looking in, it is very messy.
 

Bob

Juniors
Messages
1,471
Talk about dodging a bullet

Ex-Penrith Panthers junior Maurice Trindall bailed over Anzac Day assault charge​

Once on track to be a professional rugby league player, ex-Panthers junior Maurice Trindall now faces serious criminal charges over his alleged involvement in a vicious brawl outside a pub.

Shannon Tonkin


2 min read

March 19, 2025 - 4:25PM
Maurice Trindall in a promotional picture for a NSW Rugby League match between Brothers and Mounties. Picture: Facebook

Maurice Trindall in a promotional picture for a NSW Rugby League match between Brothers and Mounties. Picture: Facebook
A man allegedly bashed unconscious by a one-time Penrith Panthers junior on Anzac Day last year was initially feared dead by those who witnessed the horror assault, a court has heard.
Maurice Trindall, who once had a promising rugby league career having played for Penrith in the SG Ball competition in 2018, is facing charges of causing grievous bodily harm with intent, wounding a person with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and affray over the April 25, 2024 incident outside the Bidwill Hotel in western Sydney.
Trindall and two friends, Alex Lyzwa and Frederick Solo, are accused of bashing the victim unconscious and stomping on his head before leaving him lying passed out in the gutter and bleeding from the ears.
One terrified witness allegedly told police she saw Lyzwa “run towards [the victim] and with both feet, jump in the air and stomp on [his] head”.
The alleged act prompted the woman to yell out “leave him alone, he’s f**king dead, what are you doing?”
Maurice Trindall in a promotional picture for Brothers Penrith Junior Rugby League. Picture: Supplied

Maurice Trindall in a promotional picture for Brothers Penrith Junior Rugby League. Picture: Supplied
Meanwhile, Trindall is alleged to have glassed a female bystander in the face after she tried to assist the injured man.
Full details of how the incident unfolded can be revealed for the first time after Trindall was granted strict bail in the NSW Supreme Court last month.
Media-link
According to documents tendered during the bail application, Trindall, Lyzwa and Solo had gotten into a dispute with the man and his friends outside the pub minutes earlier, which had been broken up by security guards and the parties sent their separate ways — Trindall, Lyżwa and Solo in an Uber and the alleged victim and his mates on foot.
The court heard Lyzwa allegedly told the Uber driver to pull over down the road and the trio hopped out of the car to confront the rival group.
It is alleged the start of the melee was caught on the Uber’s dashcam and shows Trindall throwing the first punch, before an all-in brawl erupts and the group moves out of view of the camera.
The footage is expected to form a vital part of the police case against the trio if their matters proceed to trial.
Trindall and his friends had been at the Bidwill Hotel (pictured) before the alleged attack. Picture: Supplied

Trindall and his friends had been at the Bidwill Hotel (pictured) before the alleged attack. Picture: Supplied
The court heard the man was taken to Westmead Hospital where it was revealed he had a fractured skull, bleeding on the brain and hearing loss.
He remained in hospital for more than a week under the care of a trauma surgery team.
The female was taken to Mt Druitt Hospital where she was treated for cuts to her face and released early the following morning.
The court heard witnesses gave statements to police allegedly identifying Trindall, Lyzwa and Solo as the aggressors in the fight.
The trio was arrested a few months later and remanded in custody.
Maurice Trindall in a promotional picture for Brothers Penrith Junior Rugby League.

Maurice Trindall in a promotional picture for Brothers Penrith Junior Rugby League.
In seeking bail for their client, Trindall’s legal team told the Supreme Court the 24-year-old father-of-two still had dreams of pursuing a professional rugby league career and would agree to abide by strict conditions if granted bail.
Justice Andrew Coleman SC described the bail application as a “finely balanced matter” but ultimately granted Trindall bail, despite objections by prosecutors.
As part of his bail, Trindall must report to police daily, comply with a night-time curfew and live with family in St Marys.
He is also banned from entering the suburb of Bidwill or contacting Solo or Lyzwa, both of whom are facing charges of causing grievous bodily harm with intent and affray.
The cases for all three men will return to court on March 28.
 

Latest posts

Top