On Saturday I was there to see the Wyong Roos v Canterbury Intrust Super Premiership Cup Qualifying Final. After leading 16-4, the Roos had to go to extra time to get the 34-26 win.
If anyone wants to argue that Johnny Tuivasa-Sheck should be in first grade, refer them to this game. The side had fallen behind 20-16, and late in the second half had managed to get back to 26-20 in front. From the kick-off, which looked like it was going to go out on the full, JTS decided to catch it and then stepped into touch. He had time to put his foot over the touch line before going for the catch, but did the reverse, and it did not look like a stumble. The Bulldogs scored from the resulting scrum to lock the match up and force extra time. I will admit he was not responsible for the other tries conceded, but it was the poor judgement on this one play that was about all he notably did for much of the match until he scored a try in the dying seconds of extra time to blow out the margin.
He is no where near ready for first grade.