What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

General Roosters chatter

horrie hastings

First Grade
Messages
8,882
Well don't I have some egg on my face. First game after Walker's available and he is starting, Savala's at five eight and Sandon Smith to the bench :oops:

Shouldn't be any egg on your face Captain Apollo, Walker should at least have been given another game in the NSW Cup before getting back in to first grade.
I think they would have picked Savala over Sandon because of his over all better long kicking game, Sandons goal kicking will be missed but i can't really see Walker playing a full game so Sandon will come on at some time but i'm not expecting Walker to be doing much kicking either and Savala is a handy goal kicker if Sandon isn't on the field.
I would have given Walker another week in NSW Cup to gain a bit more match fitness.
 
Messages
16,534
Shouldn't be any egg on your face Captain Apollo, Walker should at least have been given another game in the NSW Cup before getting back in to first grade.
I think they would have picked Savala over Sandon because of his over all better long kicking game, Sandons goal kicking will be missed but i can't really see Walker playing a full game so Sandon will come on at some time but i'm not expecting Walker to be doing much kicking either and Savala is a handy goal kicker if Sandon isn't on the field.
I would have given Walker another week in NSW Cup to gain a bit more match fitness.

Also I suppose, everyone's talked about Savala having a great long kicking game, which may have mitigated in his favour to stay in the starting side too.
 

Murishido

Juniors
Messages
183
Smith's only really strength as a half has been accelration and using that running game on a retreating or staggered line, which Sam does better anyway due to the added ball playing and football iq.

I think the kicking is the obvious part for Savala where Sam has a gap, and takes some contact away from Sam. Plus a bigger bodied half stops the issues of previous seasons needing to give cover to both sides of the ruck.

Smith can definitely be the back up 9 questionis more long term fitting him and Watson (who play extremely similar).

On goal kicking Sam kicked at the same clip as Nathan Cleary last year on conversions and only 2% below sandon.
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
19,944
Walker/Savala is definitely the best combo with Watson at hooker and Sandon to the bench. Next season Robson obviously comes in at hooker pushing Watson to the bench or lock.

Sandon might get a bench spot or he might not. Losing him is nowhere near as big an issue as the media and opposition fans are claiming. He is a first grader but he wouldn't be starting at a lot of other clubs and in the biggest moments against the likes of the dogs and Raiders he has been a dear in headlights.
 

Murishido

Juniors
Messages
183
Sandon might get a bench spot or he might not. Losing him is nowhere near as big an issue as the media and opposition fans are claiming. He is a first grader but he wouldn't be starting at a lot of other clubs and in the biggest moments against the likes of the dogs and Raiders he has been a dear in headlights.
If he's a lot cheaper than Watson it might be worth keeping him over Connor but he'll probably get fringe half money elsewhere and need to fail properly to then transition into the utility role over time like Watson.

Hey Newcastle seem in need of a half...
 
Messages
16,534
Sandon was offered a contract extension last season but knocked it back as he wanted to put himself in the "shop window" according to media reports. As such he will probably leave to play elsewhere. The Cowboys apparently are interested in him.
 

Murishido

Juniors
Messages
183
Hey it's the cowboys money, they can spend it however they want 😀

But yep unless we get him cheaper than Watson he doesn't have a role IMO.

They can use him as a hooker which he could be great at.
 

morley101

Juniors
Messages
1,034
We have a few spaces to fill before June 30. I assume the Roosters would try to upgrade Savala and maybe Ethan King as he has been 18th Man more times than not. This leaves 1 more spot..
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
19,944
Sandon was offered a contract extension last season but knocked it back as he wanted to put himself in the "shop window" according to media reports. As such he will probably leave to play elsewhere. The Cowboys apparently are interested in him.
A conveniently forgotten fact when the media and neutrals go on about losing him.
 
Messages
16,534
The following is from the Sydney Morning Herald (source: https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/ca...already-been-run-and-won-20250624-p5m9tr.html) -

Call off the Dally Ms ... the race has already been run and won​

Christian Nicolussi

By Christian Nicolussi

June 24, 2025 — 7.45pm

It is only June, but we should call off the Dally M race already and just hand rugby league’s top gong to James Tedesco.

Voting for the NRL player of the year award went behind closed doors after round 12, with Warriors playmaker Luke Metcalf leading the pack on 31 points, followed by Cronulla’s Will Kennedy on 29 and Roosters skipper Tedesco on 28 points.

Wests Tigers prop Terrell May (27), and Dolphins playmaker Isaiya Katoa and Broncos prop Payne Haas, both on 23, rounded out the leading group.

If you look at performances since then, you can almost put a line through Kennedy, whose form the past month has dipped. Cronulla have dropped two of their past three games, Kennedy remains without a deal, and some will argue he could yet lose his No.1 jersey to Nicho Hynes.

May burst out of the blocks but, while his form has remained consistent, he has also struggled to poll points in a Tigers side that has now lost five straight games.

Metcalf was outstanding against the Sharks, when he would have polled a full six points, but was hampered by a corked quad in the weekend loss to Penrith. The leg issue remains a worry moving forward, starting with Saturday’s trip to Suncorp Stadium where a revitalised Broncos await.

Tedesco, meanwhile, is enjoying one of his best seasons in years. For all the talk about the young talent at Bondi, their 32-year-old leader is the one setting the standards for them.

He is breaking tackles, scoring tries and seems to have finally found the perfect balance of when to call for the ball and when to have faith in those around him.

Not having to shoulder the physical and mental burdens of State of Origin has also been a blessing for Tedesco, who was brilliant against the Cowboys on Sunday, outstanding in a gritty game against the Knights last weekend and one of the standouts in a beaten side against the Raiders.

The first thing Perth Bears coach Mal Meninga should do is pick up the phone to his World Cup-winning captain and persuade him to sign with the NRL’s new franchise. Tedesco is off contract at the end of next season, and the kind of player you need for an NRL start-up.

Roosters coach Trent Robinson and chairman Nick Politis would be loath to lose Tedesco, but there would be nothing stopping him playing a few years in Perth then returning to the Chooks in an ambassadorial role.

Tom Trbojevic, good friends with Tedesco from their representative days together, summed up what made the Roosters star such an effective player. “He’s always on the ball, he breaks a lot of tackles, pushes up well and uses his outside people,” Trbojevic said.

Tedesco will freshen up with the bye this weekend, then return for games against the Tigers, Dragons and Sharks – three matches the Roosters will be expected to win.

When you look for potential contenders from teams sitting on top of the ladder, few stand out.

Canterbury are leading the competition, but their success has been built on their team rather than on the back of one individual in outstanding form. The Raiders fall into the same category, while Storm players – including last year’s winner Jahrome Hughes – often pinch points off each other.

Ryan Papenhuyzen may have kicked the winning field goal in golden point against Souths, but his first half last Saturday was also one of his worst in recent memory.

Hughes was expected to romp in last year, but guests inside the Winx Room at Royal Randwick were treated to a barnstorming finish from Tedesco, who rattled home to fall short by one vote.

This year, it’s a one-horse race. In fact, let’s just call it off now.
 

Latest posts

Top