Golden try

[Pooftamus Maximus]

If Big bad Kenny Sio got up after the golden try whooping it up high fiving I reckon they would have give it. Id put the house on it it was a try anyway.

 

[Parra Pride]

If that was only 5 minutes into the game they would have given a try.

#Guaranteed

 

[Fifty Metre Line]

Close enough for benefit of the doubt in my opinion.
I reckon if it happened when the scores were still 6-6 they would have given it.
Video ref didn't want to decide the game with such a close call.

 

[ethan tremblay]

if ben barbas try last year was a try so was this one! we should of won it right there and would of been dirty if we lost it after that!.

 

[jono]

I kept thinking that when a team is as low in confidence etc as Parra , the 50-50s always seem to go against you...And yes I thought BOD at least

 

[Eelogical]

No try......beyond the shadow of doubt.

 

[Pooftamus Maximus]

No try......beyond the shadow of doubt.

But it is benefit not beyond the shadow.

 

[Eelogical]

Lighting shadow suggests it wasn't a try. At best it was 50/50, unless they took into account that blade of grass that may or may not have had been line-marked. If I was a Panfer supporter there would no doubt about it.........no try and a penalty to Penrith for dew on the grass.

 

[Kornstar]

We also got lucky with that forward pass to Fui.

Hindy also did a dangerous tackle in the first half that we got away with.....

Although it could have been BOD, we had enough luck in the game!

 

[strider]

i have no problem with that not being a try .... tho someone was correct in saying the one they gave Barba last year was the same - guess it depends on game situation

but lets face it if they gave it to the opposition we'd be pissed

 

[hineyrulz]

i have no problem with that not being a try .... tho someone was correct in saying the one they gave Barba last year was the same - guess it depends on game situation

but lets face it if they gave it to the opposition we'd be pissed

And thats the problem, if it was against us if would have been given.

 

[Grail]

If that was only 5 minutes into the game they would have given a try.

This.
I don't think it was a try, but I think that if it had been in the early stages of the game, they'd have definitely given it. The ref's consistency is terrible right now, and I don't think they know what's going on either.

 

[munge]

under the laws of the game it was a try i said to my mate andrew at the time they have to give this but then they didnt

 

[Twizzle]

Try for mine given the Cowboys try last night, more doubt in their's than Sio's

 

[Strangenuts]

It was a try. Oh and if you thought there was some doubt then BOD.

 

[strider]

under the laws of the game it was a try i said to my mate andrew at the time they have to give this but then they didnt

and what did andrew think of it? .... I am keen to hear andrew's opinion too - and if he disagreed, did you sort andrew out?

 

[Stagger eel]

We also got lucky with that forward pass to Fui.

Hindy also did a dangerous tackle in the first half that we got away with.....

Although it could have been BOD, we had enough luck in the game!

and that luck was well over due...well well over due, whilst we're more than happy to hang the coach and players after a loss, we never talked about the lack of luck and 50/50 calls we didnt recieve during those losses..I'd prefer to celebrate the win more than focus on the luck which we've lacked for a very long time.

 

[Kornstar]

and that luck was well over due...well well over due, whilst we're more than happy to hang the coach and players after a loss, we never talked about the lack of luck and 50/50 calls we didnt recieve during those losses..I'd prefer to celebrate the win more than focus on the luck which we've lacked for a very long time.

I don't disagree about the luck thing.......I am just happy we won, don't care how we got there right now

 

[Stagger eel]

I don't disagree about the luck thing.......I am just happy we won, don't care how we got there right now

yeah same...but after a loss we tend to over emphasise, over scutenise and maybe even exagerate a little and that gradually got worse with every loss as we got more emotional..

 

[mickdo]

BOD at best but when I first saw the replay I didn't think it was a try