Greastest Wrestler of All Time

[thuganomics]

PWA started one of these a while back but we never got through on finishing it. Gonna start a new one and the way it goes you vote for which every wrestler you want to vote for. You may use any reason what so ever. We will then get the results from each match and the Majority will get it. If a match is a tie then both will go through to the next round.
Starts with 48 wresters, 24 matches. Then down to 12 matches. Then down to 6 matches. Then down to the final which will be a Triple Threat match.

Round 1:

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

Voting Closes Friday 20th May 7:30pm

 

[thuganomics]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[Misanthrope]

Nice! I love things like this.

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

Won't bother with jusitifications just yet, except in the 'controversial' ones. I think Batista is a better worker, but hasn't done some of the things JBL has (as Bradshaw as well). I think Big Show is a far more charismatic worker than Vader. Cena was damn unlucky to be drawn up against one of the favourites.

 

[Eelectrica]

Round 1:

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek - Bret Hart
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash - Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter - Chris Jericho
Randy Savage vs Sting - Randy Savage
The Rock vs Sid - The Rock
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit - Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger - Triple H
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog - Shawn Michaels
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero - Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant - Harley Race
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan - Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin - Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund - Goldberg
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley - Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle - Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall - Scott Steiner
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair - Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane - Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar - Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield - Batista
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett - Jeff Jarret
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T - Ultimate Warrior
Vader vs Big Show - Big Show
Edge vs DDP - Edge

 

[aphelion]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit (That was a tough one)
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[nöyd]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

chriswalkerbush, you have a couple at the top that have no votes or votes for both wrestlers - Jericho vs. Slaughter and Savage vs. Sting...

Great thread BTW

 

[Martli]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley Undecided
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

Man some of those match-ups were dodgey.... You get Batista vs. JBL while you have Owen Hart vs. Mick Foley and Chris Benoit vs. Undertaker...

 

[Mr Saab]

Round 1:

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin....Dynamite is in the top 5 wrestlers in this list. Stone Cold made more $$$, but comes nowhere near Dynamite as a wrestler
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[Raider_69]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[Azkatro]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[thuganomics]

Man some of those match-ups were dodgey.... You get Batista vs. JBL while you have Owen Hart vs. Mick Foley and Chris Benoit vs. Undertaker...

I did a majority of them randomly, luck of the draw

 

[pennywisealfie]

oh man i foirgot about this, good stuff thug

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

ahh man some tough match ups first round i had soooo much trouble not voting for dynamite kid or british bulldog, but they guys they are up against id rate in the top 5 ever. is anyone else finding it hard to believe that Edge is beating DDP, edge is in my top 5 faves, but DDP is a former 3 time, 3 time, 3 time (yes booker t stole it off ddp) WCW heavyweight champion of the world. DDP was NEVER boring and had a few good matches.

 

[ThrashViking]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[-ReyRey-]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[brandell]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[CanadianSteve]

My picks are

Round 1:

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

Voting Closes Friday 20th May 8:00pm

 

[tiburon]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs JBL
Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[Bobby Westling]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs JBL
Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

 

[Gene Krupa]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP

You made it bloody hard to choose between some of thase guys.

 

[Matt23]

Bret Hart vs Iron Shiek
Bruno Sammartino vs Kevin Nash
Chris Jericho vs Sargent Slaughter
Randy Savage vs Sting
The Rock vs Sid
Undertaker vs Chris Benoit
Triple H vs Lex Luger
Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog
Brian Pillman vs Eddie Guerrero
Harley Race vs Andre The Giant
John Cena vs Hulk Hogan
Dynamite Kid vs Steve Austin
Goldberg vs Bob Backlund
Owen Hart vs Mick Foley
Randy Orton vs Kurt Angle
Scott Stenier vs Scott Hall
Rob Van Dam vs Ric Flair
Superstar Billy Graham vs Kane
Yokozuna vs Brock Lesnar
Batista vs John Bradshaw Layfield
Rowdy Roddy Piper vs Jeff Jarrett
Ultimate Warrior vs Booker T
Vader vs Big Show
Edge vs DDP