What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Hampton or Finch

gUt

Coach
Messages
16,935
If he's anything, Finch is an organiser. You've got Cronk for that and Smith too, usually. Widdop is nothing but a dangerous individual usually. So it baffles me why your coach would go with Finch in this case.
 
Messages
17,822
If he's anything, Finch is an organiser. You've got Cronk for that and Smith too, usually. Widdop is nothing but a dangerous individual usually. So it baffles me why your coach would go with Finch in this case.

Bellamy went with Finch to give Hampton time to settle in first grade but on last night's performance I think he might bite the bullet and bring him in soon to ensure that he is ready when the finals intensity hits.

Storm were unlucky with a couple of attacking moves that led to Wests tries. My other concern is Justin O'Neill...the guy looks unconfident running the ball up and hardly does the work that Waqa does. Yes he was selected in Qld SOO but I don't know how really...
 

B-Hard

Juniors
Messages
182
I tell you what might be a telling point after watching the highlights again. Finch's lack of effort to make a tackle which led to Ayshford's try. Bellamy wont like that at all and unless he has a couple of MoTM efforts the next couple of weeks I can't see Finch being our 5/8th for the run home.
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
I reckon he might turn to Blair if finch continues to go like a busted
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
No doubt Blair is playing well at center but if Finch can't improve. Blair to 6 and Sau to center gives us a better chance of winning this year then putting Ben at 6.

Another option and one I wouldn't mind seeing is Hampton used how Keary is being brought along at South's. Finch and Blair both have the defensive game to fill in at 13

.
On a night where Cronk and Slater failed massively to spark anything in attack you would expect your 200+ game veteran to actually do something. Take away his pass to put Blair in a hole, I can't remember him doing anything positive for us.

We missed Smith out of dummy half more than anything tonight but getting no attack from our 2nd playmaker didn't help. We need a ball running 5/8th next to Cronk imo and Finch is not that.

Finch at this stage of his career isn't going to get the team going forward if were on the back foot. To expect otherwise isn't realistic.

And Cooper doesn't need a ball runner at 6, just someone who can pass at the line. There's plenty of ball/hole running options on that side in Hoffman, Blair and Slater, who I expect will spend a lot more time on the left edge.
 
Last edited:

B-Hard

Juniors
Messages
182
Sa'u and O'Neil on the edge for us would be terrible defensively and we wont go close to winning anything if Blair is in the halves.

I do like the idea of Hampton being on the bench though, he should be seeing minutes for his inevitable move to the starting 13 next season.
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
Finch starting hit his straps now.

And like I said you don't need to be a ball runner when you can fire a pass like finchy and have runners like Billy and Blair around you
 

B-Hard

Juniors
Messages
182
Was solid Friday night. He is what he is, we know what he'll offer. I just think Benny can bring some more x factor.
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
I got big doubts about him defending in the front line personally, at least for 2013.
 
Messages
17,822
I got big doubts about him defending in the front line personally, at least for 2013.

Are you referring to Hampton...sort of agree...Widdop was the same though when he started and had real defensive weakness.

Hampton looks more solid than Widdop did at his age.
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
Ya reckon.

I think widdop would have had at least 6-7kg and a few cms on Ben when he debuted
 

Latest posts

Top