bluesbreaker said:
How you can say T is ten years too late and in the same paragraph rate Withers better is beyond my meagre comprehension Raidey my son. I reckon you've got your hookers crossed. Withers is a much better defender (though he don't seem to smash people like he used to for the Saints nearly as often anymore)
T is an ok player. Got a huge heart and a lot of zip out of dummy half, something that Withers and Hinchy definately do not have. A guy 'in the know' with the Knights on our forum reckons T is our best all around pass from dummy half. Fair wrap with Bedsy in the team.
But he must have f**k all between the boundaries of that enormous skull of his. it's like an orange on a toothpick.
base that solely from what i see mate
Withers is nippy as all f**k from hooker, when the markers are lazy he can pinch 10 everytime.
withers only downfall is his ability to drop a ball cold or throw a forward pass, and he does it 2-3 times a game.
Ive not see SeuSeu do anything remotely dangerous in attack from hooker, tackles his heart out, gives good service to his halves and forwards, thats about it.
We've got someone almost identical to that (although imo not as good) in Hinchcliffe and he's pedestrian too.
If its a choice between Withers and SeuSeu, withers all day, better player and a canberra lad to boot... that said ill take Flannagan over both any day of the year
