Hayne "No Try"

[Angry_eel]

Can someone please explain to me why that was a no try?

 

[Y2Eel]

Foul Play before the Try was scored..

As it was a Queensland penalty it gets taken back to when the infringement happened..

 

[Bazal]

Should have been a try...and then send off/sin bin the players in the fight. That had no effect on the play

 

[Parraren]

Yeah I can't understand how the fight had anything to do with the try.

The refereeing was pretty substandard.

 

[Angry_eel]

Y2Eel watch this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXPfsbeTVyY

The only foul play is Price kneeing Hayne. The fight happens but thats in back play with nothing to do with the try.

 

[Perth Red]

Probably the same as the 8 point try that never was. Poor refs again.

 

[Y2Eel]

Y2Eel watch this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXPfsbeTVyY

The only foul play is Price kneeing Hayne. The fight happens but thats in back play with nothing to do with the try.

Yeah i know they rule is sh*t but it happened during the same play so they can bring it back..

 

[broncos70]

it was off the same play you idiots who cares if it was in back play..what happens, nsw try and what qld penalty? dont think so..

 

[Frustrated Fan]

First infringement was the punch from White.

Boy! I would be filthy on White if i had backed NSW 13+ or Jarred Hayne to score a try.

What a wank~!

 

[Big Pete]

Good decision, Hayne didn't get the last laugh.

 

[Hanscholo]

I had to laugh at the time. A clear try disallowed because someone was knocked out by a lucky punch 40m away, a player trying to break the fight gets sent off...keystone cops. Kind of Ironic that the series ended the way it began, a bad ruling on a Hayne try from him skipping down the touchline...

 

[Doggiesfan09]

I had to laugh at the time. A clear try disallowed because someone was knocked out by a lucky punch 40m away, a player trying to break the fight gets sent off...keystone cops. Kind of Ironic that the series ended the way it began, a bad ruling on a Hayne try from him skipping down the touchline...

It was the correct ruling

 

[Parraren]

Let me ask you this;

Would they have dissalllowed it if the series was on the line and that was the deciding play?

We all know the answer to that one and thats why the refs are a running joke and getting worse....

 

[mxlegend99]

The try should have been awarded. The ball had already been played and nothing that happened in the middle of the field had any bearing on Jarryd Jayne scoring that try.

Dallas Johnson is awarded a try where his hands are nowhere near the ball, yet Jarryd Hayne has been disallowed two tries on the sideline for bullsh*t reasons.

 

[Angry_eel]

Kind of Ironic that the series ended the way it began, a bad ruling on a Hayne try from him skipping down the touchline...

Strange. I didn't think of that.

 

[Frustrated Fan]

Anyway. Qld were dudded by Shayne Hayne not going to the video ref' for the Cam Smith no try. If he did it would have been awarded TRY!

 

[WestCoastEel]

First infringement was the punch from White.

Boy! I would be filthy on White if i had backed NSW 13+ or Jarred Hayne to score a try.

What a wank~!

The first infringement was actually Price kneeing White as he was getting up to play the ball, hence why White had a swing at him.

So what should've happen was play on as Price was the instigator. meaning try to Hayne. But, of course, the refs had no clue and made another dud call.

 

[Gaba]

Yeah I can't understand how the fight had anything to do with the try.

The refereeing was pretty substandard.

the fight started before the try was scored, the nsw player threw the first punch before hayne got the ball, thats when the foul play started as soon as the punch was thrown by the team in possession of the ball so no try

 

[Rastus_in_Melbourne]

If you don't want to put the try in jeopardy, don't throw a punch, simple. Correct decision.

 

[TheBourbonBeast]

Anyway. Qld were dudded by Shayne Hayne not going to the video ref' for the Cam Smith no try. If he did it would have been awarded TRY!

And the williams try after a clear knock on. I dont understand why there isnt a bigger blow up? And the 8 point try fiasco as well. And nsw first try in the 2nd half was off a forward pass. But we were never shown a replay from side on to judge it.


Waterhouse comes screaming in as 3rd man and slams a bloke in the back. People think this is somehow OK, because price made a slight bump with his knee. It wasnt a massive 'knee to the head' that nsw merkins are going on about.

The reffing is a joke, very very suspect.

But on topic, buggers me why Haynes wasnt a try. The ref lost it big time.