Holden Cup team 2014

[junior fan]

Don't blame the coach ??? I am a manly fan and want to watch good footy with the other grades as well but You know shit all. You don't watch too many games obviously. The game plan is shit, hardly any ball gets out. Compared to all the others . The other teams watch the videos of manly and just focus on smashing the middle as they know manly don't pass and then Manly's forwards are so stuffed as they are doing all the work and they are shit in the second half. Thats why the opposition teams always come back and win. Mate Your joking aren't you... You know nothing and really can't be bothered dealing with idiots but shows you how much you know... Taylor played in NSW Cup the other week the youngest in the team, scored a great try and set up another try, I was told he had no prior training with the cup team beforehand but was told to play on the day. His defensive play was spot on playing with guys and against guys who have 1st grade experience and are much older and some huge Polynesian players as well to defend. Put Taylor up against Gutho anytime and see who comes out on top with any test. Small piss off ! He is over 6ft and weighs close to 93 kilos and is only still 18. He is solid, tough as and athletic / fast. Made Australian schoolboys last year, was the best player in NSWCIS team remarkable coming from a winger and just coming back from a broken jaw. NSW twice for rugby and was a National sprint champion. Australian u20s rugby I hear are after him including the Waratahs and other clubs. He is a absolute flyer in attack and as a specialised winger he can also play anywhere from outside backs, left and right side of field to back row if needed. Not too many players can match that. He needs to be playing in a strong team wasted here. My mail is he will be taking the Wolfmans spot on the wing in 1sts. I hope I get to see you out there playing mate, or maybe playing chess ?

Footy Mad aka Mr/s Taylor. You need to give the blind pushing of your son a rest. I thought a forum was a place to give opinions. Seems when they don't match yours you fling the personal insults. I acknowledged he plays with heart and decent although that's where it ends though, there are still deficiencies as acknowledged by other posters. No need to carry on and insult people.

We have heard your rhetoric as have people in the parra NYC thread and NSW 20s thread where every second post is you saying how great Charlie Taylor is just look back at your posts.
You like to divulge the personal info fans wouldn't be aware of by saying I have heard, it isn't convincing. No one takes the amount of notice or attention to an indivivpdual player and gets so offended when his/her opinion is at odds with theirs unless there is a relationship.

You slammed boys promoted to NSW Cup earlier in this thread then used it to somehow show that Charlie is destined for the top.

Simple facts

He is a good player, not great.
He has not been identified in any of the rugby league talented athlete pathways. Outside of school.
He doesn't match the prototype of today's winger 6"2' 100+kg who serves as an extra forward.

 

[Footy Mad]

I am not related at all Mate wrong on that as well but as a Manly supporter I am promoting a local junior kid who I know well and this is a Holden Cup forum and wanted to bring it up. Maybe they could do a bit of a write up on all the boys in Holden Cup. I am not interested in your stupid opinions. The kid has only left school. He is already over 6 ft and your definition for a winger is wrong. Speed is the main factor. Can't reason with Boof Heads. Not biting anymore to your crap.

 

[Harold Bishop]

Footy Mad, you say that he has been told he will be the Winger in place of Wolfman, now why would he be so desperate to leave?
From what I have seen he is a strong quick winger, who may make a good winger. I don't think he is your Hayne or Inglis type superstar, or even Mamo for that matter. If he wants to go so badly, dont let the door hit you on the way out, there are plenty of kids who would love to play on the end of a backline with DCE, Foran, Matai Lyon etc. Want to talk about being frustrated? Go play for the Sharks, Raiders etc. He wont be knocking off players from the top sides thats for sure.

 

[mal12]

Footy Mad aka Mr/s Taylor. You need to give the blind pushing of your son a rest. I thought a forum was a place to give opinions. Seems when they don't match yours you fling the personal insults. I acknowledged he plays with heart and decent although that's where it ends though, there are still deficiencies as acknowledged by other posters. No need to carry on and insult people.

We have heard your rhetoric as have people in the parra NYC thread and NSW 20s thread where every second post is you saying how great Charlie Taylor is just look back at your posts.
You like to divulge the personal info fans wouldn't be aware of by saying I have heard, it isn't convincing. No one takes the amount of notice or attention to an indivivpdual player and gets so offended when his/her opinion is at odds with theirs unless there is a relationship.

You slammed boys promoted to NSW Cup earlier in this thread then used it to somehow show that Charlie is destined for the top.

Simple facts

He is a good player, not great.
He has not been identified in any of the rugby league talented athlete pathways. Outside of school.
He doesn't match the prototype of today's winger 6"2' 100+kg who serves as an extra forward.

Thankfully somebody has hopefully put the Charlie fan to bed for a little while .I read these posts for some insight into our teams not to constantly read about how crap other players are and poor Charlie.The funny part is he may make it but there is a lot of good players that never do and sometimes that's pure luck so please let's let this one sleep please

 

[Dutchy]

Taylor was dominated by his opposition winger tonight.

Tom T was the real standout.

 

[mave]

Tom T was untouchable last night, especially in the second half.

 

[winnyason]

Geez we have some decent outside back talent, tom t, Gutho but geez Charlie Taylor looks a star.

 

[Patorick]

Geez we have some decent outside back talent, tom t, Gutho but geez Charlie Taylor looks a star.

Off to Easts.

Or Parra.

Pick one.