Hypothetical,your the coach

[Nug]

I thought it was a good hypothetical! 8)

 

[eloquentEEL]

In honour of the Parra Eels transit lounge:

1.Brett Hodgson (Tigers)
2.Scott Donald (Sea Eagles)
3.Willie Tonga (Bulldogs)
4.David Kidwell (Storm)
5.Joven Clarke (Rabbitohs)
6.Steve Witt (Knights)
7.Casey McGuire (Broncos)
8.Jason Cayless (Roosters)
9.PJ Marsh (Warriors)
10.Joel Clinton (Panthers)
11.Nathan Hindmarsh (Eels)
12.Ian Hindmarsh (Raiders)
13.Willie Leyshon (Dragons)

14.Mitchell Sargent (Cowboys)
15.Roy Friend (Sharks)

#-o

 

[Dragons_#1]

1.clinton-canberra
2.slater-melbourne
3.gaz-st george
4.tongha-canterbury
5.rooney-penrith
6.lockyer-brisbane
7.johns-newcastle
8.skandalis-tigers
9.sully-cronulla
10.rahuhi-nth queensland
11.hindmarsh-parra
12.menzies-manly
13.fitzgibon-sydney city
14.fletch-souths
15.Guttenbeil-new zealand

 

[The Engineers Room]

In honour of the Parra Eels transit lounge:

1.Brett Hodgson (Tigers)
2.Scott Donald (Sea Eagles)
3.Willie Tonga (Bulldogs)
4.David Kidwell (Storm)
5.Joven Clarke (Rabbitohs)
6.Steve Witt (Knights)
7.Casey McGuire (Broncos)
8.Jason Cayless (Roosters)
9.PJ Marsh (Warriors)
10.Joel Clinton (Panthers)
11.Nathan Hindmarsh (Eels)
12.Ian Hindmarsh (Raiders)
13.Willie Leyshon (Dragons)

14.Mitchell Sargent (Cowboys)
15.Roy Friend (Sharks)

#-o

What about Clinton Schifcofske??

 

[wogdog]

1. Brett Hodgson
2. Anthony Minichiello
3. Nigek Vagana
4. Timana Tahu
5. Francis meli
6. Darren Lockyer
7. matt orford
8. Steve Price
9. luke priddis
10. Ruben wikki
11. Nathan Hindmarsh
12. Glenn Morrison
13. Shaun timmins
BENCH: Ashley Harrison , steve menzies

 

[Steven Gerrard]

What about Clinton Schifcofske??

Schifcofske is clearly a better fullback that Hodgson.

 

[miccle]

1. Slater
2. Minichiello
3. Cooper
4. Tonga
5. Roberts
6. Lockyer (c)
7. Prince
8. Rauhihi
9. Marsh (when fit)
10. Fletcher
11. N Hindmarsh
12. Wiki
13. Menzies

Reserves: Wing, Kennedy

 

[851]

why didnt you just call this thread "who is the best player at each position" instead of coming up with the most ridiculous hypothetical ive ever heard? :|

Because it is not who is the best player at each position. It's about making the best team out of taking 1 player from each NRL team. If it was simply taking the best player at each position my team would have been dominated by Broncos, Dragons and Roosters etc.

Thanks champ that was my point it is not easy when teams are chock full of good players which one do you pick.Thanks also to Nuq for his kind words.

 

[swing_low]

1. Brett Stewart
2. Joel Monaghan
3. Mark Gasnier
4. Nigel Vagana
5. Matthew Sing
6. Darren Lockyer
7. Matthew Orford
8. Mark O'Meley
9. Daniel Buderus
10. John Skandalis
11. Nathan Hindmarsh
12. Adrian Morley
13. Ashley Harrison

14. Preston Cambell
15. Lautiti....um paleaseena

 

[Big Mick]

1. Billy Slater (Melbourne)
2. Amos Roberts (Panthers)
3. Joel Monoghan (Raiders)
4. Mark Gasnier (Saints)
5. Francis Meli (Warriors)
6. Darren Lockyer (Bronco's)
7. Brett Kimmorley (Sharks)
8. John Skandalis (Tigers)
9. Danny Buderus (Newcastle)
10. Steve Price (Bulldogs)
11. Adrian Morley (Roosters)
12. Nathan Hindmarsh (Parramatta)
13. Ashley Harrison (Souths)

Reserves:
14. Sam Harris (Manly)
15. Paul Rahuhi (Cowboys)

 

[raiders_lover_18]

1. Brett Stewart (Man)
2. Bowen (NthQld)
3. Cooper (Drag)
4. Marshall (WT)
5. El Masri (Bull) GK
6. Lockyer (Bris)
7. Johns (Newc) (C)
8. Clinton (Pen)
9. Wing (Syd)
10. Stevens (Cron)
11. Wiki (Canb)
12. Hindmarsh (Parra)
13. Hill (Melb)

14. Harrison (Sths)
15. Faumina (NZ)