What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

I agree with Mick Potter on this.

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
Robbie Farah's as good as Cam Smith, says Wests Tigers coach Mick Potter

WESTS Tigers coach Mick Potter reckons Robbie Farah's form in 2013 proves he now rivals Cameron Smith as the game's best hooker.

Backing up from Origin II, Farah was again inspirational as he masterminded the Tigers' upset over Melbourne on Saturday night with a magnificent wet-weather performance just three days after he clocked up 52 tackles for NSW.

All season Potter has been signing the praises of his skipper and this is not the first time the coach has compared Farah to the Australian and Queensland captain.

"He is right up there (with Smith)," Potter said.

"I mean, it all depends on how you look at both players but they both have great attributes and I don't think you can split them.

"I'd hate to be the Australian selector to say who is in and who is out.

"It's good for Australia that they can both play 80 minutes for a team competing in the World Cup.

"To be fair to Robbie, he has been performing like that all year. He has been performing between a nine out of 10 and a 10 out of 10 every week. It is a credit to him how he maintains that standard every week but it is no coincidence when you see how hard he works."

However, Potter woke yesterday to more headlines about his future at the Tigers and speculation Benji Marshall could play Super Rugby for Auckland next year.

Asked if he expected Marshall to be at the Tigers next year, Potter said: "I'd like to think so. Benji loves playing for this club and he'd love nothing more than to stay here. I can't say if he will or he won't, but I'd like to think he'd be more inclined to be staying than going."
 

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,868
Smith is a great player but so is Robbie. I think Robbie is better in that he is more creative and has more positive plays in him. In saying that I think Robbie probably takes the wrong option a little more than Smith does.

It is pretty even.
 

sensesmaybenumbed

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,226
Smith is a great player but so is Robbie. I think Robbie is better in that he is more creative and has more positive plays in him. In saying that I think Robbie probably takes the wrong option a little more than Smith does.

It is pretty even.


Look at the ability of each respective team to stick to the game plan - Smith is in a team that maintains control far more often then the one Farah is in. The end result of this is that Smith is forced to push the pass less often than Farah. Smith doesn't take the 'wrong' option because he's less likely to be put in a position where it is needed.
 
Messages
1,175
Robbie milks penalties. I hate that. It brings the game into disrepute and is a blight on our game.
Apart from that....Robbie a much more complete player than Smith.
Not one player I would swap him for.
 

Latest posts

Top