What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Interesting Article lists BK as most overrated in NRL

Poss

Juniors
Messages
1,525
Full article can be read here

http://www.leagueunlimited.com/article/articletemp.asp?num=6264



This is what is said about Kimmorley. A little harsh I think. We have only won 3 of 8 games played without him since he did his hammy. Hardly a good record.


1. Brett Kimmorley

Sorry Cronulla-Sutherland fans, but it had to be said. This entire article just wouldn’t make sense if he wasn’t here. Out of curiosity why isn’t Kimmorley in the Australian Olympics team competing in javelin? He has the entire ‘step, step and throw something dangerous’ routine so down pact that another gold medal was a bonafide certainty.

Let’s be fair to Kimmorley for a moment though, a lot of the media criticism that Kimmorley attracts had to do with his firm relationship with former club and national coach, Chris Anderson. In fact many locals even consider Kimmorley to be the reason why Preston Campbell, Nick Graham and Dean Triester all left the club within twelve months.

This season, many thought that Cronulla would shatter without Kimmorley in their line-up who sustained injury prior to State of Origin. However, life was anything but dreary for the Cronulla lads who picked up unexpected victories and unearthed two major talents in Michael Sullivan and Jason Kent, in the wake of Kimmorley’s absence. Those same critics will also argue that Kimmorley’s game is fairly one dimensional, and it’s not too difficult to see why.

When on song, Kimmorley’s kicking and passing game is second to none, but considering how much of their salary cap the Sharks dish out to him, you’d expect a stellar performance every game of the season. Unfortunately, until he brings success to Cronulla, he will always be dubbed by opposing fans, as the most overrated player in the NRL.
[/url]
 

cheese

Bench
Messages
4,013
Written by a zero cred hack, posted on a zero cred amateur hack website(with a half decent forum) ...says it all really
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
some hack said:
This season, many thought that Cronulla would shatter without Kimmorley in their line-up who sustained injury prior to State of Origin. However, life was anything but dreary for the Cronulla lads who picked up unexpected victories and unearthed two major talents in Michael Sullivan and Jason Kent, in the wake of Kimmorley’s absence.

obviously written some time back
 

Genius Freak

Juniors
Messages
1,646
His list of overrated players fails to include Karmichael Hunt, Trent Barrett and Mr. Overrated himself, Matt Gidley. How credible can he be?
 
Messages
2,964
That "hack" has an e-mail address:

[email protected]

Anyone recognise that nickname.

And for the record, I do agree the article still has zero cred.

Interestingly, Jardian Ormsby gives an e-mail on LU as:

[email protected]

HOWEVER, do a quick search on the name Jardian Ormsby to see if he is anyone and you find some website named Sharks Wire Version 2K3.

I'd expect him to back up his reasoning here soon enough.

EDIT:: For the less adventurous/investigative of you. Go here.
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
++ Gregos v.4 said:
That "hack" has an e-mail address:

[email protected]

Anyone recognise that nickname.

And for the record, I do agree the article still has zero cred.

Interestingly, Jardian Ormsby gives an e-mail on LU as:

[email protected]

HOWEVER, do a quick search on the name Jardian Ormsby to see if he is anyone and you find some website named Sharks Wire Version 2K3.

I'd expect him to back up his reasoning here soon enough.

EDIT:: For the less adventurous/investigative of you. Go here.


hmmm

good work greggos

i spotted the article weeks ago

ididnt realise it was a traitor in the ranks :lol:
 

Anonymous

Juniors
Messages
46
I don't see a problem with it - good journalism. Stirs up a bit of anger, gets people talking, gets more people reading, and so on.

The results are evidenced by this thread.

Well done El Coco... :clap:
 

Mako

Juniors
Messages
1,060
Quote:

unearthed two major talents in Michael Sullivan



I half agreed until I saw this, no, Sullivan had been performing since Rd 1, so he didnt get 'unearthed' in Kimmorleys absence!!

Who are the two major talents?
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,076
I dont totally disagree with the piece.
I disagree with its headline as "over rated". BK is clearly one of the leading halfs in the game.
I do agree with the stellar perfromance & payment line though.

Does anybody have the figure for the amount of games BK has missed through injury since he has been at the club?
On the surface it seems, more than half of this year & nearly half of last year.??
That would equate to 450k for a guy to sit in the box.
Now, whilst year long injuries are not uncommon, I do think it will be concern if he attains another long term injury next year.
I'm not saying he is shirking faking or dogging or any of that, so please refrain.
However, it would be a relief to start seeing some value for the 1.5 million dollars. Wouldn't it?
 

Macca

Coach
Messages
18,389
BK played 17 games last year and has played 13 so far this year. I expect that to increase to 15.

His injuries were purely unlucky last year so you can't devalue him there.

This year his hammy is a very worrying set back. This could be a recurring injury and it does bother me. If he doesn't recover fully then it will cost us dearly.
 
Top