Is Scott Logan up to Origin?

[Dazzat]

I've read that Scott Logan is playing well for Canberra of late and don't see too many Raider games on TV. Is the man up to Origin standard and capable of replacing someone like Carl Webb?

 

[Brimmer]

Is Logan a Qld'er?

 

[badav]

Is Logan a Qld'er?

Yes.

I wouldn't mind seeing him in the QLD side either. Hes a tough no nonsense prop to use the cliche.

 

[Mal Meninga]

He's missed the boat IMO. Last season he was in career best form than suffered a couple of injuries which has seen him play rather average late last year/most of this season. Can't quite recall how many minutes he plays but it'll probably be a red mark against him along with ill discipline which could be exploited at SOO level.

 

[Timbo]

Yeah his form this season is well down on last year.

Having said that, his strongest game of the year was the other night, so if he's hitting form, he's picked a good time.

 

[matt]

if henry is doing the MAN management for QLD then NO

He doesn't bring the best out in MEN..

 

[hrundi99]

He's a good solid player but not Origin worthy in my books.

 

[gorilla with a shotgun]

He's a good solid player but not Origin worthy in my books.

better than Costigan

 

[bileduct]

F*ck State of Origin off. I mean, honestly, who cares anymore?

I'd prefer our players didn't participate, to tell you the truth. Look at the luck Neville Costingan has had since his call up last year.

 

[Timbo]

F*ck State of Origin off. I mean, honestly, who cares anymore?

Are you serious?

 

[Mick_63]

Of course he is up to it.
He has had a run of injuries this year,but with the bye this week and a chance to recuperate he could play himself into contention with a big game against Manly.
Queensland SOO selectors can bring in left field players(mogg,schifty)so my guess is he is a real chance.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

F*ck State of Origin off. I mean, honestly, who cares anymore?

Blasphamy!

 

[Chachi]

He couldn't do any worse than Thaiday or Lillyman...but it's not going to happen.

And I agree with bileduct to some extent. I'm a Canberran and I really don't give a toss who wins Origin if there's no Raiders playing. I do enjoy watching them bash the bejesus out of each other though.

Oh, and I did have a giggle about Wallace having a great game too.

 

[dubby]

he would be, but I cant see it happening.

Loges can be baited and niggled too easy and would be put off his game.

 

[MSIH]

hahahahahahah