What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is the Twenty20 concept about to signal the end of one-day internationals?

Will 20/20 kill ODIs?


  • Total voters
    28

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
By Ron Reed
January 16, 2009 A BIT like an ageing fast bowler who has seen more fiery days, one-day cricket returns to centre stage Friday with an uncertain future.
Many think the 50-overs a side game has become tired and tedious compared with the new kid on the block, Twenty20, and will struggle to survive the challenge.
That line will be harder to refute if, as seems certain, fewer than 50,000 people go to see Australia take on South Africa on a Friday night, recognised by all sports as box-office prime time in Melbourne.
The Melbourne Cricket Club confirmed Thursday it was expecting 45,000, about two-thirds of the 63,000 at Sunday's Twenty20 game.
Last year, only 49,362 watched Australia play India, and two matches against Sri Lanka drew in the mid-20,000s.
The year before England pulled 78,625 in early January but only 38,858 for a final in February.
This is yet more evidence one-dayers have been a declining force in the sports entertainment market in Melbourne and elsewhere for some years, which is why today's game represents not quite a new era, perhaps, but a change of tack.
The long-running three-way contests died unlamented last summer, replaced by two separate five-match contests with South Africa and New Zealand: no more neutral matches between two visitors.
The one-dayers were jazzed up a little, too, with power plays for the batting team - they can call the fielders in for five overs - and a newer ball available after 34 overs.
They are cosmetic changes, but there is no doubt that something needs to be done to make the middle overs less predictable.
Australia captain Ricky Ponting said he had "no concerns" about the 50-over game, but in the same breath he said it or Twenty20 would inevitably take a lesser role in cricket programming.
http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,,24918034-23212,00.html
People vote with their feet.
Been saying it for a while 20/20 will kill the 50 over stuff.
 
Messages
33,280
i think ODI's were dying to a degree anyway with all the rule changes to introduce more 350+ scorelines and make bowling second rate to batting

take the west indies v NZ odi ... west indies in control just before the rain and new zealand have the right to call some bullsh*t powerplay that means within an over they've knocked up the 12 runs required? ... that stinks how the batting team gets so much advantage over the bowling team and let's face it overs 25-40 usually are 3-4 an over single run dominated but i've noticed that's crept into twenty20 cricket

too early to say what will die and what will last ... i think they'll both last but i wouldn't be surprised to see 3 twenty20's and only 3 ODI's in most major series in 5-7 years time
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
I think TV ratings will be a big thing in this.

El can you give us the ratings for 20/20 v the ODI when they list please.
 
Messages
33,280
well the first twenty20 last week rated at 2million didn't it? and one from last year rated in the top 10 for the year aswell

twenty20 also has the advantage of the entire game broadcast in prime time

with the product itself i can see people eventually getting bored of it down the track
 

IanG

Coach
Messages
17,807
So where are there figures coming from? Considering TV is still in its non ratings period.
 

KHunt

Juniors
Messages
843
im sick of the ODI for some reasons Tonearm mentioned.

I never get powerplays, just another stupid rule to favour the batsman.
I wished they would scrap it and bring back the first 15 overs you can only have two outside the circle but they havent.

i hope in the coming years, they have more 20/20 series and less ODI.
 

coach

Guest
Messages
1,431
I have been saying for the past 12 months that the 50 over game is on its last legs. I give this format of the game 10 years max until it disappears from the cricketing calender.
 
Messages
33,280
im sick of the ODI for some reasons Tonearm mentioned.

I never get powerplays, just another stupid rule to favour the batsman.
I wished they would scrap it and bring back the first 15 overs you can only have two outside the circle but they havent.

i hope in the coming years, they have more 20/20 series and less ODI.

introduction of powerplays and super subs are what killed ODI's IMO

1999 world cup was probably one of the best one day tournaments ever and it had everything and wasn't boring at all
 
Messages
33,280
So where are there figures coming from? Considering TV is still in its non ratings period.

09-01-11.JPG
09-01-11.JPG
1 Twenty/20 - Australia V South Africa Nine 2,055,000
2 Seven News Seven 1,298,000

http://televisionrant.blogspot.com/search?updated-max=2009-01-12T16:51:00-08:00&max-results=5

looking at that picture i'm spewin i missed die hard with a vengeance
 

IanG

Coach
Messages
17,807
You gotta remember too that when 50 one day cricket first came about all the doomsdayers were all saying it'd be the death of Test Cricket and it wasn't.
 

Hanscholo

Bench
Messages
4,818
One day cricket has the very same problem 20-20 has, its just that most havent realised it yeat. Field restrictions, and the removal of them, ruin both forms of the game and turn them both into knocking singles to long on for 1/2 the game. Personally, if you fixed that issue, one day cricket wouldnt need 20/20.
 

Geohood

Bench
Messages
3,712
ODI's are probably my favourite to watch because it's more exciting than tests but allow more of a chance for a competitive match than 20/20s which are over in a flash and teams can get blown away pretty easily.
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
So we're going to go from Test match cricket to 20 over cricket and cut out ODI? Very sad that a novelty such as slap and tickle cricket is slowly ruining the game.
 

Ridders

Coach
Messages
10,831
So we're going to go from Test match cricket to 20 over cricket and cut out ODI? Very sad that a novelty such as slap and tickle cricket is slowly ruining the game.

It's all economics baby.

I don't really get into either limited form of the game, Test match cricket is the sh*t for me. I'll be very interested to see the TV ratings comparison between 20/20 and ODI's.
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
It's all economics baby.

I don't really get into either limited form of the game, Test match cricket is the sh*t for me. I'll be very interested to see the TV ratings comparison between 20/20 and ODI's.

That's what I find so sad about it. T20 is a sad little slap and tickle novelty game there to entice those with short attention spans and little knowledge of the game other than "mmm ball fly far, music play, must be good, too distracted to make fire".

Think of some of the great one day innings, especially those against the odds when a team is in deep trouble, something that isn't possible in T20. Some plonk coming out and scoring 20 off 10 balls with a couple of closed eyed swings and a few streaky edges is supposed to be a match winning innings? T20 is watered down cricket at full price, and there are sadly enough suckers out there to support it.
 

Latest posts

Top