Josh Morris or Kyle Stanley?

[God-King Dean]

Provided Cooper leaves at the end of 2011, who would you rather take over left centre?

(Tagive may also be in the running, but for now.....)

 

[steela]

morris easy... stanly hasn't done anything yet

 

[Drew-Sta]

Depends on how Stanley develops.

Morris has suffered from lack of ball at times as well, which is difficult to pin on where he is right now.

My guess is we should probably move to a:

1. Boyd
2. Morris
3. Morris
4. Gasnier
5. Stanley

For 2011, if possible. I like Nightingale, but believe Stanley has greater potential.

 

[Drew-Sta]

In saying that, Morris won't come cheap either.

 

[R&WTILLIDIE]

The 2 Morris' together would be unstoppable

 

[Willow]

morris easy... stanly hasn't done anything yet

Last time I checked, J Morris is playing for Canterbury for the next year at least. That will give K Stanley plenty of time to make his mark.

J Morris left us for money elsewhere. Made your bed buddy. Kyle Stanley is the future.

Nah, seriously, I'll have them both.

Just see how it unfolds over the next 12 months.

 

[LOYAL DRAGON]

Both

 

[RedVDave]

I recon the Morris twins would (obviously) be a lethal combination together could read each other's plays before they happen.

I would love to see Josh back but I doubt Canterbury would let him go therefore Stanley is the future.

 

[hellteam]

Accidently voted Morris but I reckon Stanley.

Stanley has probably looked more impressive then Morris this year, plus you've already got one highly paid centre so you're probably better off spending the money that you would have to on Morris elsewhere.

 

[Dragon Dave]

110% Stanley. Josh Morris is a good player, we all know that, but the fact is he left to join Canterbury and is contracted for 2011. Kyle has scored 5 tries in 5 games and is a solid defender.

Kyle is 18 years old and is very versatile.

 

[cleary89]

Stanley

 

[SFVD]

People forget Josh only left because we had Gasnier and Cooper, Morris wanted a starting centre spot and had to walk away.

To answer the question, I'd like to get both but for value for money if we could sign Kyle Stanley for 3+ years before the start of 2011 I'd rather that than 250K a year for Josh Morris. I think Kyle could blossom into something spectacular under Wayne Bennett, especially since he is at an impressionable age.

On a sidenote, isn't Kyles preferred spot 5/8?

 

[dubopov]

People forget Josh only left because we had Gasnier and Cooper, Morris wanted a starting centre spot and had to walk away.

To answer the question, I'd like to get both but for value for money if we could sign Kyle Stanley for 3+ years before the start of 2011 I'd rather that than 250K a year for Josh Morris. I think Kyle could blossom into something spectacular under Wayne Bennett, especially since he is at an impressionable age.

On a sidenote, isn't Kyles preferred spot 5/8?

i would take stanley x 10 ... he is a class above either morris ..

 

[tevoro]

Wouldnt go that far Dub, but still prefer Kyle. Josh wont come cheap.

 

[Wobbygong]

Watched Morris tonight against the sharks he was ordinary again his handling at present is poor I don't recall him ever making the amount of errors he's making at the cheats when he was at the dragons I think he's gone off his game a little personally I suppose if you lay down with dogs you wake up with fleas.

 

[Ray Parlour]

Josh is having a terrible year. You can tell the bloke really doesn't want to be playing for those deadsh*ts and would rather be back at saints.

In relation to the question, i think Stanley must be in the starting squad somewhere. If he develops into a five-eighth then i'd gladly have Josh back in the centres. But if Wayne see's his long term future in the centre's then i cant see any room for Josh until Gaz leaves again.

 

[Benny]

Stanley

Remember Stanley is better suited to 5/8 or FB than centre.

 

[St. Benny]

1. boyd
2. morris
3. morris
4. gasnier
5. nightingale
6. stanley
7. soward

that's what i would like to c

 

[juanfarkall]

Very different players.
The current version of NRL seems to suit a "more robust" back and from what I have seen Stanley seems to be making a good fist of things.
If I had to choose between the two based on what I have seen both players do so far this year I would keep Stanley

 

[saintzrule]

Stanley. Versatile, no fuss and so young. Our first priority must be to what we already have, Morris walked and currently looks dreadful