Kidwell is a liability

[coach]

I am not sure that David Kidwell warrants a position in our team. For me he is a liability in two areas.

Kidwell misses too many tackles, especially ones that end up in tries being scored by the opposition. Last night he missed 5 tackles and he was involved in poor defense on at least two occassions when the Sharks scored.

Kidwell gives away too many penalties with his niggling tactics when tackling an opposing player. He likes to either have his hand all over the ball trying to force it out or he lays all over the tackles player. The referees know what he is up to and penalise him.

 

[Aaron_sfas]

kidwell out greenfield in.

DK has been terrible since his return from that big injury

 

[Ike E Bear]

I like Kidwell's aggression, but that's seemingly all he's got and it's just not enough.

Pettybourne matches the aggression and brings genuine impact with him.

I agree that the referees are well onto DK's shenanigans and he will NEVER get away with any of the stuff that he seemingly just can't help himself but do.

Right now it's an easy swap for DK and Greenfield ... still not a fan of Jaiman Lowe, but he's going better than he ever has. Shrug.

 

[Dave Q]

JLo's been having a go this year. Id love to see him 100% fit.

DK is still a big match player, great team player and has still has some tricks and experience.

 

[Fibro_Panther]

David Tyrell is'nt too far away from getting a call up into first grade IMHO.

 

[Dave Q]

David Tyrell is'nt too far away from getting a call up into first grade IMHO.

We discussed that at the members bar last night. A few of the First Grade players are living on borrowed time atm.

 

[Fibro_Panther]

We discussed that at the members bar last night. A few of the First Grade players are living on borrowed time atm.

Who do you think is gone Dave?I have'nt seen too many norths games but I remember seeing Tyrell play in the Charity Shield and he looked the goods for mine.

 

[Dave Q]

Who do you think is gone Dave?I have'nt seen too many norths games but I remember seeing Tyrell play in the Charity Shield and he looked the goods for mine.

Up until Friday, Frog was seen as not as not pulling his weight. Closely followed by JLO, McPherson and Aso himself wasnt going as hard as we wanted.

Tyrell and Greenfeild were highly thought of.

 

[Stagger eel]

lol..we can do with someone like Kidwell, infact we'll take anyone on offer...lol

 

[Skinner]

Kidwell is too much the hot head.

 

[Dave Q]

Kidwell is too much the hot head.

Hes just honest.

Beware the "good guys" who smile along and everything as they are the ones who will rip your throat out.