What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Knights lineup 2004

keeney

First Grade
Messages
6,637
how do we see the team lining up in 2004, with our new acquisitions, who would go where?
1. O' davis
2. Tahu
3. M. Gidley
4. Hughes
5. Quinn/Hall
6. Kidley/Witt
7. Johns
8. Perry
9. Buderus
10. Parsons
11. Simpson
12. Abraham
13. Kennedy

INTERCHANGE

14. Woolnough
15. Newton
16. Tanner
17. Hall/Quinn/Witt/Price

Is witt, worthy of a first grade berth, bench or otherwise, ro will he be left in premier league, what about selkeld? What has happened with estastheo, and our other perpetually injured benchers?
 

Spike

First Grade
Messages
7,115
1 O'Davis
2 Tahu
3 M.Gidley
4 Hughes
5 Quinn
6 K.Gidley
7 Johns
8 Perry
9 Buderus
10 Parsons
11 Simpson
12 Abraham
13 B.Kennedy

14 Ennis
15 Woolnough
16 Newton
17 M.Kennedy

Reserves

18 Lowrie
19 Price
20 Tanner
21 Hall
22 Witt
23 Tilse
24 Brown
25 Young
26 Worth
27 Mueller
 

roopy

Referee
Messages
27,980
Bailey said:
1 O'Davis
2 Tahu
3 M.Gidley
4 Hughes
5 Quinn
6 K.Gidley
7 Johns
8 Perry
9 Buderus
10 Parsons
11 Simpson
12 Abraham
13 B.Kennedy

14 Ennis
15 Woolnough
16 Newton
17 M.Kennedy

Reserves

18 Lowrie
19 Price
20 Tanner
21 Hall
22 Witt
23 Tilse
24 Brown
25 Young
26 Worth
27 Mueller

I pretty well agree with this squad, except Quigley needs to go in because he is staying for another season and I want to see Henderson, Witt, Salkeld, and also Carmont, Dorn and Richardson if we sign them, in action before I make up my mind on them. Another young forward I'd add is Dan Tolar, who really takes the ball up hard.
I'd also put Blake Mueller a lot higher on my list. Blake is a lot like his brother Brock who played a few games of firstgrade for the Knights in 2000 before dropping back to the real NRL in that he isn't big and is not the world's finest athlete, but he has a giant heart. His workrate was high at the start of the season and just went up and up as the season went on.
I have a mental picture of him coming off the field in the Premier League game against Norths. Blake had scored two tries using his massive fend and had done so many tackles and hit ups the scorer must have run out of room to mark them down, and they decided to give him first go at the showers and pull him off with 4 minutes to go in the game. Blake did the slowest walk down the sideline I've ever seen. It was obvious he barely had the energy to lift his head, but i'm sure he would have made another run or done another tackle if he had to.
I didn't see the Premier League 4-0 win over Canberra in Canberra, but Blake's effort of 65 tackles in gale force winds and driving rain to keep the statisically best attacking side in reserve grade history scoreless should have an epic song written about it - it sounds like one of the trials of hercules or something.
Blake will tackle all day, put his hand up to do a hitup when all are buggered, play dummy half if needed, chase every kick like his life depends on it and probably do a slow walk over hot coals if the team needed him to do it.
 

roopy

Referee
Messages
27,980
keeney said:
he sounds great, wat position does he play, and how old is he?
Blake was captain of Premier League for the last 2/3rds of the season and plays lock or second row. He has just turned 21 I think, which makes him one of our oldest Premier League forwards.
He needs to put on 5-10 kg in this off season. If he doesn't they will probably drop him sometime next season I reckon, because he won't be a regular firstgrader as an under 90kg forward.
 

Spike

First Grade
Messages
7,115
lol that's what happens when you drop off the face of the earth for a few weeks. I wasn't even aware we had re-signed Quigley. Even so, I reckon Ennis will leap-frog Quigley next year for a regular bench spot.

The reserves aren't in any particular order. Also I hope Estatheo makes it back onto the park
 

Terminator

First Grade
Messages
6,300
01. O'Davis
02. Tahu
03. Gidley.M
04. Hughes
05. Quinn
06. Gidley.K
07. Johns (c)
08. Perry
09. Buderus
10. Parsons
11. Simpson
12. Abraham
13. Kennedy.B
___________

14. Woolnough
15. Kennedy.M/Price
16. Newton
17. Quigley/Lowrie
 

Doctor

Bench
Messages
3,612
1 O'Davis
2 Tahu
3 M.Gidley
4 Hughes
5 Quinn
6 K.Gidley
7 Johns
8 Perry
9 Buderus
10 Parsons
11 Simpson
12 Abraham
13 B.Kennedy

14 Quigley
15 Woolnough
16 Newton
17 M.Kennedy

Reserves

Ennis, Young, Price, Lowrie, Tanner, Hall, Witt, Mueller to all get runs - probably Witt and Tilse to be given some time in the top grade.

Any inclusion of the likes of Richardson etc will inflate our backline stocks - I'm not sure we want that many lower-grade backs.
 

keeney

First Grade
Messages
6,637
now with the likely inclusions of richardson, fitzgerald, and possibly dorn, how would you see the lineup?
 

Bring it home Knights

First Grade
Messages
7,575
1. O'davis
2. Tahu
3. Gidley
4. Richardson/Hughes
5. Quinn
6. Gidley/Witt
7. Johns
8. Perry
9. Buderus
10. Parsons
11. Simpson
12. Abraham
13. Kennedy

14. Woolnough
15. Estatheo
16. Newton
17. Hall

18. Price
19. Kennedy
20. Lowrie
 
Messages
456
1.kidley
2.tahu
3.gidley
4.hughes
5.odavis
6.dorn
7.johns
8.perry
9.bedsy
10.parson
11.simpson
12.abes
13.kennedy

14.woulnough
15.price
16.newton
17.richardson/hall/tanner
 

Alex28

Coach
Messages
12,271
1. O'Davis/K Gidley
2. Tahu
3. M Gidley
4. Richardson/Hughes
5. Quinn/Hall
6. Dorn
7. Johns
8. Perry
9. Buderus
10. Woolnough
11. Simpson
12. Abraham
13. Kennedy

14. Parsons
15. Fitzgerald
16. Newton
17. Lowrie

Others:

* Quigley
* Tanner
* Witt
* M Kennedy
* Price
* Ennis

Witt needs time to develop - he's still relatively young. I would be in favour of having Kidley spending some time at Fullback this year to give him a chance to make the spot his own for 2005 - thats the year where the club is really going to shine. It's going to be a tough race between Hughes and Richardson for the centre spot.

1997...2001...2005 is looking good already :)
 
Messages
3,818
The forwards pick themselves although i never thought of Parsons as a benchie-Good point Alex
The race is on for backline spots but o davis tahu M gidley[shoulder surgery??????] Dorn if signed and GOD appear certain.I like the look of Richardson in the centres as he has some size to him and could be a superstar running off johns
The rest will have to fight it out
180 days to kick off 2004 :shock:
 

Bring it home Knights

First Grade
Messages
7,575
Alex28 said:
1. O'Davis/K Gidley
2. Tahu
3. M Gidley
4. Richardson/Hughes
5. Quinn/Hall
6. Dorn
7. Johns
8. Perry
9. Buderus
10. Woolnough
11. Simpson
12. Abraham
13. Kennedy

14. Parsons
15. Fitzgerald
16. Newton
17. Lowrie

Others:

* Quigley
* Tanner
* Witt
* M Kennedy
* Price
* Ennis

Witt needs time to develop - he's still relatively young. I would be in favour of having Kidley spending some time at Fullback this year to give him a chance to make the spot his own for 2005 - thats the year where the club is really going to shine. It's going to be a tough race between Hughes and Richardson for the centre spot.

1997...2001...2005 is looking good already :)

2005 you say. You are aware johns comes off contract at the end of 2004. There's no guarentees he'll play for the knights in 2005
 

Alex28

Coach
Messages
12,271
he'll play with us 2005 - i cant see him playing for another NRL club, and he'll be still a little too young to take the england retirement fund yet - remembering Matt's experience he wont do that too early and make the same mistakes...

2006 - he'll be either 30 or 31 - that will be the time in my opinion..
 

Anonymous

Juniors
Messages
46
One thing is for certain we have a major issue with the 3/4 line...We really needed to replace Macdougall with a high quality player, Vigana would have been great. Do we have any good young wingers coming thru, i can never see premiere league.

Quinn has shown that he is developing into a blockbusting centre, and Hall is a handy player. I am just concerned that if Tahu is injured what do we do?

If we get a few injuries in the backs we are in big trouble....
 

Matt23

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
16,495
If there's injury problem's in the outside backs next season, don't be surprised to see Jason Moodie back in the Knights colours.
 

roopy

Referee
Messages
27,980
pando said:
One thing is for certain we have a major issue with the 3/4 line...We really needed to replace Macdougall with a high quality player, Vigana would have been great. Do we have any good young wingers coming thru, i can never see premiere league.

Quinn has shown that he is developing into a blockbusting centre, and Hall is a handy player. I am just concerned that if Tahu is injured what do we do?

If we get a few injuries in the backs we are in big trouble....

Wingers of firstgrade standard are in short supply, but we have a lot of possibilities now with the players we have bought.

Kevin Henderson has been playing centre for Souths Premier League and was bought on the recommendation of David Fairleigh, which probably means he is a rugged type of player. He is a big and strong back and was originally from the Central Coast.

Witt has the speed to play wing, and I can't see why he shouldn't. A fast and elusive player outside the Gidley brothers will have a ball.

Richardson can play wing.

Salkeld and Carmont could both play wing if needed.

The main wingers from Premier League this year were Josh Smith and Michael Fortier. Both are small and not quite up to standard. I expect both to be cut. Michael Young, the Premier League fullback, is faster than a lot of people think.

From Flegg we have Blake Tremain-Cannon, Michael Doggett and Ryan Woo.
Blake is not solid, but he is reasonably tall and fast as they get. I'd say he is the fastest man at the club, and may develop into the fastest in the League. Last season was his first at the club and he learnt heaps. I'd rate him a chance to go all the way to firstgrade next year.
Doggett has a great build and is fast. He is a Mad dog type of winger who never goes easy when tackled, but needs to build a lot of strength before he is in the Mad dog class of course. He does drop the ball a bit as well.
Ryan Woo is a little guy who struggles in every tackle and often makes good yards. He is a mini Matt Utai, but obviously needs to improve 200% to be in the same class.
 

Latest posts

Top