KOTW: Round 13 vs Bulldogs

[thuganomics]

Scores after Round 12

Danny Buderus: 325
Andrew Johns: 283
Steve Simpson: 227
Craig Smith: 155
Matthew Gidley: 148
Milton Thaiday: 130
Brian Carney: 122
Kurt Gidley: 110
Anthony Quinn: 105
Josh Perry: 68
Clint Newton: 54
Kirk Reynoldson: 40
Jarrod Mullen: 33
George Carmont: 28
Riley Brown: 24
David Seage: 21
Todd Lowrie: 20
Luke Davico: 13
Adam Woolnough: 7
Reegan Tanner: 6
Brad Tighe: 5
Daniel Tolar: 2
Daniel Abraham: 1
Chris Bailey: 1

No votes till after the game please.

 

[Stranger]

3. Carney
1. Johns

There about the only 2 players who stuck to it. And Joey was... average at that.

Buderus was just to quiet.

 

[Ben]

3. Buderus
2. Johns
1. Carney

 

[Misanthrope]

Christ, I wish we could dock points. Reynoldson and Kurt Gidley would lose any they'd managed to amass.

3 - Brian Carney. The only decent winger in the club, and we'd better be buying somebody to replace him.
2 - Andrew Johns. Stood up when the rest of the team seemed content with mediocrity
1 - Clint Newton. The only forward worth mentioning.

Hall of Shame
Kirk Reynoldson - Hold the f**king ball
Kurt Gidley - Not a fullback and barely a five eighth
Reegan Tanner - Not a first grader
Riley Brown - Not present

 

[Doctor]

Given the following players made crucial mistakes: Kurt Gidley, Brian Carney, George Carmont, Quinn, Lowrie, Johns, Smith, Buderus, Woolnough, Simpson, Tanner, Perry, Reynoldson, Brown, Newton, etc etc -- not sure how we can award many points.

Mine are:

3. Simpson -- made metres everytime he had the ball, and made a couple of line breaks. Makes his tackles, and doesn't stuff up like his colleagues. His only error was a very dodgy ball to Johns from dummy-half. I won't hold that against him.

2. Johns -- was ok, but his listing here is a reflection of how poorly the other blokes played. Johns off his game still out-performs most of the team.

1. Buderus -- still one of our best, even though he gave away a stupid penalty. He is frustrated.


Quinn misses out because he let in three tries. Carmont dropped the ball and let in tries. Newton had a good game but bombed a try by not holding the ball when arriving at the try line. Reynoldson bombed a try too -- he had men on his left but chose to go to ground with the ball and lost it.

 

[Jono078]

3 - Simpson
2 - Davico
1 - Woolnough

 

[Bring it home Knights]

3. Smith
2. Davico
1. Buderus

 

[Big Tim]

1. Simpson
1. Smith
1. Carney
1. Quinn
1. Newton
1. Buderus

 

[northey]

2 - carney
2 - smith
2 - quinn

 

[chinorocks]

3. Newton - Our best by a mile. If you didn't see it, watch the replay because you weren't watching....

2. Buderus - Saved trys, ran, tackled typical Buderus game.

1. Carney - Scored one, only contributed to one oposition try...a big improvement.

Unlucky: Smith, Simmo

Lucky to EVER play first grade again: Tanner, Brown, Carmont, Reynoldson (worst buy of all time)

 

[RABK]

2. Simpson
2. Newton
2. Carney

 

[IanG]

3 - Brian carney
2 - Danny Buderus
1 - Steve Simpson

 

[Jobdog]

2 - Simmo
2 - Newton
2 - Carney

 

[The_Joey_Show]

3 - Simpson. Outstanding all night, the boys were lost in defence without him on the field.

2 - Newton. Reminded us all of how much we missed him when he was out with a typical whole-hearted display.

1 - Carney. Looked dangerous with limited opportunities.

I was going to give three 2's as JD and RABK did, but on second consideration I really thought Simmo deserved 3 points. In fact, he probably deserved more.

 

[knights9]

2. Buderus
2. Simpson
1. Quinn
1. Carney

 

[Kazaf]

3 - Craig Smith
2 - Steve Simpson
1 - Anthony Quinn

 

[roopy]

3 - simmo
2 - bedsy
1 - johns

 

[thuganomics]

3 - Johns
2 - Simpson
1 - Newton

 

[KniGhTs BaTTLeR]

Simpson- 3
Carney- 2
Reynoldson- 1

 

[thuganomics]

Current Scores

Steve Simpson: 27
Brian Carney: 22
Danny Buderus: 14
Clint Newton: 12
Andrew Johns: 11
Craig Smith: 9
Anthony Quinn: 5
Luke Davico: 4
Adam Woolnough: 1
Kirk Reynoldson: 1