KOTW vs Bulldogs

[Matt23]

Based on the 2nd half effort, I'm abstaining from voting, but vote away

 

[doggone]

Based on the 2nd half effort, I'm abstaining from voting, but vote away
__________________
dotto

 

[Medievalknight]

Based on the 2nd half effort, I'm abstaining from voting, but vote away

 

[KempoKnight]

Based on the 2nd half effort, I'm abstaining from voting, but vote away

 

[Spot On]

I'll give a point to Tui. A point to Nev. Maybe Gids should get one too for the punch he threw? That would be it though.

 

[Alex28]

Nope. Not rewarding that effort.

 

[NoSchitSherlock]

I'd refuse on the basis that those I could give pts to based on the 1st half performance I'd need to deduct for the 2nd half performance. So, instead I'm basing it on those who didn't completely fall apart and were reasonably consistent.

2. McManus - one of the only consistent players over both halves.2 missed tackles but high ARM
2. Uate - about same stats as McManus
2. Tuimavave - Same ARM but 0 MT - probably should get 3

 

[Serc]

3 - Tuimavave
2 - Houston
1 - Gidley

 

[Jono078]

2 Houston
2 Tuimavave
2 Costigan

 

[The_Joey_Show]

I'd refuse on the basis that those I could give pts to based on the 1st half performance I'd need to deduct for the 2nd half performance. So, instead I'm basing it on those who didn't completely fall apart and were reasonably consistent.

2. McManus - one of the only consistent players over both halves.2 missed tackles but high ARM
2. Uate - about same stats as McManus
2. Tuimavave - Same ARM but 0 MT - probably should get 3

This.

I commented to my missus last night what a SMART footballer Jimmy Mac is (and always has been). Has an error or two in him like evryone, but never makes a DUMB mistake or a bad decision.

Can't say that about many of our blokes.

 

[RHCP]

I can't even remember the first half, so no points for anyone.