What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Lou Dibella Letter to Mundine

Atilla

Juniors
Messages
105
Its stunning that people who have previously mocked Mundine for making comments that aren't worth taking seriously, are suddenly falling over themselves to highlight the "seriousness" of his comments...

Mundines comments, in relation to the US attacks, were of a far more noticeable & significantnature than anything he's ever said before. What I'm trying to say is that the seriousness of his comments were taken seriously because he chose to respond to a serious issue. Nobody was playing Russian roulette with him at the time. He chose to respond to the question, instead could have quite easily have told the interviewer that it was a subject he didn't wish to discuss. Given the importance of the topic, and the emotions and tension still in the air,how can you honestly expect people to not take his comments seriously? The vast majority of the people who eventually found out about his comments around the world, haven't even heard of him.If you honestly do not believe that Mundine's comments should not have been taken seriously by the world's public and media, then I believe you are missing the point.


At any rate, the comments of a boxer shouldn't shake the world to its foundations, as anyone who enters a profession that involves taking repeated punches to the head is not going to be a social commentator of immense intellectual rigour!

Then those very people should at the very least possess the basic intelligence of choosing their words carefully, or when not to comment. It really isn't that difficult.It says a lot about Mundine.

Ali is considered a Saint these days, but I can remember the crap that he used to go on with in his halcyon days.

I don't know of anbody who has called Ali a Saint. Not then, not now. The admiration that people display for Ali at present is more due to 'feeling sorry' for a champion who has succumb to a horrible and crippling (in its own way) desease (Parkinsons), rather than a man of innocence or a Saint as you incorrectly refer to it. The crap he use to go on with in his halcyon days, as you refer to it, is known by just about all as 'self promotion.' No sporting figure, then or now,promoted themselves to the extent that Ali did in his prime. If you elect to refer to it as crap, then that's your given right. I just think it's incorrect defition on your behalf.

I find the recent attempts by the boxing fraternity to put him forward as their contemporary social poster boy insulting in the extreme.
I may be missinterpreting this comment of yours, but I'll address it the way I understand it. Please be so kind as to name particular instances where that has happened. I honestly cannot remember the last time (within the last few years)that Boxing used Ali to promote, advertise, sell, endorse or flogg off any thing. Boxing has a huge following globally. The sport itself, and the fighters themselves (that currently fight) sell the product not ex-champions.
He's indeed a tragic figure as he shuffles before the cameras and mumbles (barely intelligibly) to the microphones
Parkinsons is indeed a tragic disease. But somehow that is not the way I'm interpreting your post. If his mumbling at a barely intelligible rate, and his shuffling (due to Parkinsons), then it certainly is a tragic sight.But somehow I get the feeling you're mocking him. To say he's a tragic figure now, through no direct fault of his (there isn't enough information about the disease to label his illness the direct result of his boxing days - contrary to popular belief), is correct if the statement is used to describe a champion who has sadly deteriorated. But if the statement is used to point the finger and laugh, then that's cruelty at it's best (worst).
If he's a poster boy for anything, then he should be a poster boy for calls to end this joke of a sport.

Merely you opinion, which you have the right to express.


Its become a breeding ground for lowlife sharks and shonky gambling types

Are you talking about Cricket?

it has little aesthetic charm
It was never intended to be a sport of 'beauty.' and spits men out as degraded wrecks at the end of their sorry careers.
Degraded wrecks is an over exagerration. But if one was to use that definition, I ask you,how many other sports persons would also fall under the same catagory at the conclusion of their careers?


Cheers CyberKev2002 - Atilla



 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
109,862
Yeah sorry Ozbash, that's the best word I could come up with at the time. I appreciate that it is a sensitive issue to many people.
Happy to move on as well...

 

CyberKev2002

Juniors
Messages
39
Atilla

Liked your post, which made some good points. I'd like to reply now, but haven't the time to do so in depth alas... Will try and do so during the week...
Suffice to say that I wasn't making fun of Ali...

CyberKev
 

Atilla

Juniors
Messages
105
Thankyou CK2002, as I'm a big fan of Ali. I didn't think you were making a joke out of him, but because I'm new to the community here, I'm still getting to know how people post.
I look forward to your reply sometime during the week. It's a topic (Boxing) that's close to my heart and I enjoy putting my opinions across at any opportunity I find.
Cheers all - Atilla


 
M

mud n blood

Guest
No mocking Ali here, either.

He really is one of possibly five who can lay claim to being the greatest .... unlike Mundane's ridiculous claims.

Speaking of which, I'll start a new thread fellas ......
 

imported_Outlaw

Juniors
Messages
511
You make a number of good points Atilla. Good on'ya for sticking up for the sport of Boxing.
emthup.gif

 

El Duque

Bench
Messages
3,845
Boxing also keeps a lot of violence off the streets and puts it in a ring where it's controlled.I can't imagine what some kids would've turned into if it wasn't for boxing.
 
V

Vertigo

Guest
Excellent post Atilla.


El Duque -


Your comments regrding Boxing keeps many men (women in some instances too) off the streets is very true and accurate. Yet, becuase of the mindless anduneducatedcritics, who will always choose to see the violent and controversial side of the sport, that very fact is grossly overlooked and rarely, if ever, mentioned as a positive aspect of Boxing. I'm not implying there are many positives of the sport, in particular as society likes to interpret and link the words 'positives' and 'benefits'to social eventsthese days, but that very fact is an overlooked one which should not be.


Fighters of the calibreand early social status of Tyson, and many, many more others, would have ended up in prison (for a very long time)as possibly as young as intheir teenage years .. if not for the sport of Boxing.

But of course that statement in and around itself, is a matter of personal opinion.

Vertigo.
 

CyberKev2002

Juniors
Messages
39
Atilla

Mundines comments, in relation to the US attacks, were of a far more noticeable & significant nature than anything he's ever said before. What I'm trying to say is that the seriousness of his comments were taken seriously because he chose to respond to a serious issue. Nobody was playing Russian roulette with him at the time. He chose to respond to the question, instead could have quite easily have told the interviewer that it was a subject he didn't wish to discuss. Given the importance of the topic, and the emotions and tension still in the air, how can you honestly expect people to not take his comments seriously? The vast majority of the people who eventually found out about his comments around the world, haven't even heard of him. If you honestly do not believe that Mundine's comments should not have been taken seriously by the world's public and media, then I believe you are missing the point.


Agreed he's probably wishing he'd said nothing in retrospect, but he wouldn't be the first person to regret a comment made in front of the cameras. Mundine's anything but media savvy, and yet I've seen a lot of more experienced media types make some stunning gaffes in similar situations. Being in the media spotlight can in some ways be like being in the middle of a laboratory experiment, and you don't always have time to adequately think through your responses. At any rate, Mundine's out of context response to the attack interests me about as much as Wayne Carey's views on illegal immigration; neither man is a central figure in either scenario and neither carry any real weight or authority on the issues. There's no doubt that there's been a major over-reaction to Mundine's comments, although I could understand this from people somehow implicitly involved in the September 11 tragedy. I can't cop it from this clown Dibella, however, with his drivelly over-the-top letter that smacks of gratuitous game playing and overt self-aggrandisement. Maybe we could fan back through his history and locate some of his choice words for public consumption, but then again its always the job of faceless nobodies to launch these poncey power play exercises rather than be on the receiving end of them isn't it?!

Then those very people should at the very least possess the basic intelligence of choosing their words carefully, or when not to comment. It really isn't that difficult. It says a lot about Mundine.

Its as I said above... And it doesn't necessarily just say something about Mundine. Other boxers (and sportspeople in general) have copped harsh criticism for making candid comments to the press on issues outside their immediate jurisdiction. Ali himself was certainly not immune to the odd unwise comment and copped considerable flack for it.


I don't know of anbody who has called Ali a Saint. Not then, not now. The admiration that people display for Ali at present is more due to 'feeling sorry' for a champion who has succumb to a horrible and crippling (in its own way) desease (Parkinsons), rather than a man of innocence or a Saint as you incorrectly refer to it. The crap he use to go on with in his halcyon days, as you refer to it, is known by just about all as 'self promotion.' No sporting figure, then or now, promoted themselves to the extent that Ali did in his prime. If you elect to refer to it as crap, then that's your given right. I just think it's incorrect defition on your behalf.

Dibella himself was falling over himself to work Ali into his drivel letter, but this is hardly surprising as Ali's health woes have served to further endear him to the masses. He wasn't always received so well, but I didn't necessarily have a problem with his flagrant self promotion and ludicrous comments, as it was just par for the course and he did it colourfully. Nevertheless, the boxing fraternity has always been happy to promote loose lips and it is indeed hypocritical of them to go overboard on Mundine when boxers have been carrying on like dickwacks for countles decades.


I may be missinterpreting this comment of yours, but I'll address it the way I understand it. Please be so kind as to name particular instances where that has happened. I honestly cannot remember the last time (within the last few years) that Boxing used Ali to promote, advertise, sell, endorse or flogg off any thing. Boxing has a huge following globally. The sport itself, and the fighters themselves (that currently fight) sell the product not ex-champions.

I didn't mean posterboy in the commercial sense, but rather he will be put forward by boxing officials (as Dibella did in this letter) as boxing's titular figurehead of choice because of the safe public sympathy card. Never mind the fact that boxing heavily contributed to (if not wholly caused) these health problems. I also think its a big call to suggest that boxing has a huge following globally. In effect its a cult, peripheral sport that has some (albeit fast fading) popularity and is clearly outgunned by many other sports in popularity terms.

If he's a poster boy for anything, then he should be a poster boy for calls to end this joke of a sport.

Merely you opinion, which you have the right to express.

I'm yet to see any solid evidence that boxing isn't anything more than overdue residue from the uncivilized days of blood sport. If it were really about skill and technique then we'd have boxers fighting with protective head gear, but then the viewing audiences would diminish by 90%+ wouldn't they? I feel great sympathy for Ali, as I do for other fighter's sporting degenerative injuries as a result of the sport. The average 5 year old would know that the human brain is not built to absorb repeated heavy blows, and until the sport gets serious about protecting against these injuries then I will never afford it the time of day.


Its become a breeding ground for lowlife sharks and shonky gambling types

Are you talking about Cricket?

Nice response and I'll pay it, but it only hides long term debauchery behind a short term dalliance. Cricket has had a nasty 18 months, but it is good for a respected sport to endure this as it serves as a wake-up call to professional sport as a whole. The big difference between cricket and boxing is that officials of the former have attacked the issue head-on, weeding out the offenders and slapping them with life bans from the sport. Shonky goings-on have always been a part of boxing and always will be because the officialdom are mere lapdogs to the seedy types who are effectively running the show. I'll say it again, lets open up the book on Dibella and see how squeaky clean he's been.

it has little aesthetic charm
It was never intended to be a sport of 'beauty.' At least you're honest about it, unlike the countless pretenders who've responded to my derision of boxing as a contemporary bloodsport with -- "Bullshit, its a sport of skill, technique, timing and poise!" Which has taken them longer to say than the average heavyweight bout lasts in toto... and spits men out as degraded wrecks at the end of their sorry careers.
Degraded wrecks is an over exagerration. But if one was to use that definition, I ask you, how many other sports persons would also fall under the same catagory at the conclusion of their careers?

Admittedly some haven't come out to well from sports such as motor racing, but boxing is clearly the worst sport going around for physical degeneration upon (and after) retirement.

That being said I respect your right to support the sport of your choosing and I commend you for debating the issue cleanly and thoughtfully.

CyberKev


 

Atilla

Juniors
Messages
105
<u>CyberKev2002</u>; Thankyou for taking the time to reply to my post. Your reply was a pleasure to read even though I gave the Dictionary a working over. Whilst you made some very sensible and maturecomments, there is the odd one or two points you made thatI'd like to comment on in deatail. Except, I'm currently in Sydney and have been since shortly after my last reply. I'm visiting an ill family member and will most probably be here for another month at the least. Upon my return home to Qld, sometime in the weeks ahead, I will reply in detail to your post. I apologise for taking so long to reply to youbut I haven't used a computer for almost a month now. I'm currently on my brothers pc and only just saw your post.

I'm not trying to start an arguement or a heated confrontation with yourself or anyone else over the topic. I just feel I need to stick up for the sport that has given me so much physical &amp;emotional confidence and well being over the years I was engaged with it.

I'm mature and level headed enough to know and identify its negatives publicly and openly, but it realy does have some positives that many refuse to give it credit for.

I hope we can discuss it sometime soon. If you wish that is.

Thankyou again and cheers to yourself &amp; all -Atilla
 

CyberKev2002

Juniors
Messages
39
Atilla Cheers, Champ! Here's hoping that the family illness isn't too serious and is only of a short term nature. God knows, the pressures of life are already tough enough in this day and age without the body piling on a bit of extra stress for you as well. Sorry about the language from the last post... Too much time in a university environment may be good for the hirability, but it can bugger-up your everyday communication skills at times. Rest assured that I never for one moment thought that you were trying to rile-up some aggro with your posts. You should try exchanging discussions with white nationalists sometime... Let me tell you, even the most rabid posts on this forum can seem tame &amp; enlightened by comparison. Thinking of you and the family and hoping it works out well... CyberKev
 
M

Macca

Guest
Nice reply Kev......

looking forward however to reading Atilla's full reply (if he ever gets a chance to reply)


 

Latest posts

Top