Seems to be only the dragons who wont bring 19 year old players into first grade, that's how we lost Saab, Robson, Bostock ,Garrick ,AFB and Cook before them
This is really not accurate though,
Saab - Was in first grade, while it was reported it was the travel that caused his decision to leave he also had a very close bond with that Keith Titmuss that passed away, plus a few other players around that age he was close with.
Robson - We chose Mcinnes over him, at the time it made sense but he was still getting time, albeit short cameos for the most part. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
Bostock - Fair enough, probably more to do with the coach then not getting first grade time.
Garrick - He was pretty average in the lower grades and was definitely not the stand out amongst all the other players in that team at the time. No one was really crying over him leaving when it happened.
AFB - It had nothing to do with being in first grade, we sacked him for an off field indiscretion which was warranted.
Cook - He was playing first grade intermittently with both us & dogs mostly at fullback or off the bench. It wasn't until he went to the bunnies that they gave him a proper shot at hooker & rest is history.
The other thing worth thinking about, during the time that all these players have excelled in their careers, would they have excelled under the guidance & leadership that we have had at the Dragons over those same years, I would think probably not.