What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Madge Contract status

Rsag85

Bench
Messages
3,923
It's all pretty easy.

We DON'T want or need FARAH or LEWIS.

They are both well & truly past their best.

I thought Sths were supposed to be looking to the future.

It will be a poor future if we start signing 34 yr old players!!

I agree with you Doyen 1 million %
 

DiegoNT

First Grade
Messages
9,378
Lewis is still one of the best second rowers in the game. It's a position we are desperately short in. Not going to find a better 2nd rower available then Lewis.
But definitely a big fat no to Farah
 

rabbitohs95

Bench
Messages
4,711
Keeping Cam at 9 is a triple step even more backwards.
Don't you mean three steps backward? Lol

Seriously though, just give Cam some time. Just because he hasn't lit the world on fire doesn't mean he's a bad player. Don't forget who scores the two tries to help us win against Manly at Brookie.
 

Dogmatix

Juniors
Messages
547
Lewis agreed to join Souths years ago and he would have been an excellent signing at the time. But Lewis then backed out on the deal as Souths were a rabble at the time

No way Souths should be signing him now that he is looking for a superannuation lump sum
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,695
Don't you mean three steps backward? Lol

Seriously though, just give Cam some time. Just because he hasn't lit the world on fire doesn't mean he's a bad player. Don't forget who scores the two tries to help us win against Manly at Brookie.
That was a fluke.
 

souths_reborn

Juniors
Messages
471
The Farah move is an interesting one.

It could work into our favour having a hefty amount of his contract shaved off. Let's not forget this guy is a leader and is the NSW hooker. Sure, his form of late hasn't been crash hot but really we just need an experienced head to guide around the young/inexperienced hookers. A new environment could spur him to improve his game, plus with his brother by his side it could be a great thing for both himself and the club.

On the other hand, it could be Glenn Stewart 2.0. He can be quite selfish with the ball and as a 'Tiger for life' his heart might not be in it. Just like Stewart practically sabotaged our season last year, Farah could do the same and do what he has done with the Tigers.

While i'm not the biggest Farah fan, if we do sign him up i'd welcome him, just like I will with every player that puts on the red and green of our club. Hopefully for both parties things work out should the move eventuate.
Signing Robbie Farah will either work spectacularly well or condemn us to wooden spoon contention; there is no middle ground. In terms of the potential contribution that he could make, Farah's excellent ball handling skills could take a lot of pressure off Adam Reynolds and offer us another attacking dimension. In saying that, he will still need to do a lot of dummy half running in order for us to be an effective unit and to bring the Burgess brothers into play. Given that Farah is no spring chicken, I really doubt that he will be able to offer this sort of game for 80 minutes, meaning that we will need to play a hooker off the bench.

Signing Farah could also work to our detriment in that he is up to 3 coaches now who have had problems with him. Given that Madge is under extreme pressure to get results, having a player like Farah undermine him through acting like a loose cannon could completely destabilise the team and cost us in games. Moreover, I'd also have massive question marks over his passion and commitment levels for the club. How can he possibly feel any sentiment towards a team, when he has played over 250 games for a rival? We've seen what happened with Glenn Stewart and we can't afford to have that happen again!

My overall view on the situation, given what happened in the game against the Storm, is that we should wait at until the end of the season. Cook had a really good game and if he continues to show the same sort of form that he did last night then we should stick with him. However, if his form is patchy then we can look into signing him. Under normal circumstances, I wouldn't advocate taking a risk on someone of Farah's nature but there aren't too many good hookers out there who are available so we need to be shrewd in the way we go about things. In any case, we are going to need Cook so any discussion about getting rid of him is moot.
 

hurricane57

Juniors
Messages
561
Don't you mean three steps backward? Lol

Seriously though, just give Cam some time. Just because he hasn't lit the world on fire doesn't mean he's a bad player. Don't forget who scores the two tries to help us win against Manly at Brookie.


McInnes struggles to be mediocre, he had opportunity after opportunity, the guy just doesn't have it.Time to look elsewhere
Maguire may have to swallow his pride and admit leting the other three guys go was a mistake.

I,ve always stated I rather Isaac Luke stayed and Maguire went - do you think we could get Maguire to take McInnes with him, that would be great.
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,695
I have said Farah would add creativity which would be good for us.

He can be good at helping get repeat sets too which helps take the pressure off Adam.

Farah is good at running catching markers offside too.

He is a very experienced head which is more of what SOUTHS need with all our young guys.

Farah has a quick passing game too.

He would be a back up halfback too.


Here you go Rsag.

I told you I'd already posted about it in another thread.

Add to those points yes Cam is not up to it.
 

Woofy7

Juniors
Messages
193
Can't believe people don't want Farrah, he is an excellent hooker and trust he would have a point to prove. Not to mention we look more attractive to other potential signings if we have more rep players within our squad.!!!!
 

doyen

Bench
Messages
3,760
Can't believe people don't want Farrah, he is an excellent hooker and trust he would have a point to prove. Not to mention we look more attractive to other potential signings if we have more rep players within our squad.!!!!


Trouble is--Robbie is so smelly to his beloved,lifelong club that even they won't have a bar of him.

In fact,the Tigers are achieving much better without him.
 

alien

Referee
Messages
20,279
Can't believe people don't want Farrah, he is an excellent hooker and trust he would have a point to prove. Not to mention we look more attractive to other potential signings if we have more rep players within our squad.!!!!

he's not as good as he used to be though. if we sign him, it should only be for 1 year because his contract with wests tigers finishes at the end of the 2017 season, so we would only be able to get him cheap for next season. it's reported he is on $950,000 for next year, but i wouldn't pay more than $400,000 for him for next year, which means wests tigers would have to be willing to pay $550,000 of that contract for farah to play at souths. maybe they would agree to that, just so they can move on, and because Jason Taylor doesn't want him anywhere near wests tigers. after the 2017 season, farah could play in the English super league. he is a big Liverpool fan in the English soccer, so he'd probably enjoy being over there for a while
 

DiegoNT

First Grade
Messages
9,378
When has robbie had a good game over the last 2 seasons? He has been picked in origin on reputation alone, Tigers have been better without him. He isn't the player he was 5 years ago. Wobbie ball, where he only gives the ball after he can't be the hero, only works with a half like Benji, when benii was still young and agile enough to improvise.
 
Top