What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mannah Origin???

Snoochies

First Grade
Messages
5,633
Written by Slothfield so I'm guessing this whole article is just his opinion.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...ate-of-origin-ii/story-e6frexnr-1225872266806



Selectors earmark trio to save NSW in State of Origin II

NSW selectors are preparing for a showdown with coach Craig Bellamy by sacking three players from the team he hand-picked for the opening State of Origin game.

The Daily Telegraph understands veteran halfback Brett Kimmorley, centre Matt Cooper and bench forward Brett White will be the first three casualties from Wednesday night's loss to the Maroons at Homebush.

In a revamped 17-man squad for the return bout in Brisbane, sources have revealed:

* KIMMORLEY, Cooper and White are gone;

* CRONULLA star Trent Barrett will come in at five-eighth, his Sharks teammate Paul Gallen at lock and Manly's Jason King on the bench;

* PARRAMATTA superstar Jarryd Hayne will finally be switched to his specialist position at fullback;

* UNDER-siege skipper Kurt Gidley will be picked at halfback;

* MANLY pair Josh Perry and Anthony Watmough will be relegated to the bench to allow Gallen and Tom Learoyd-Lahrs into the starting pack;





* THE selectors will also closely monitor the form of boom Roosters halfback Mitchell Pearce over the next fortnight, as well as Penrith centre Michael Jennings, who has scored six tries in two games; and

* THE only other players who could force their way in as back-up forwards on the bench are Manly's Brent Kite and Parramatta's hard-working Tim Mannah.


The selectors, who are under as much pressure as Bellamy, are likely to retain 14 of the 17 players chosen for game one.

But there will be a number of positional changes with Hayne going to his favourite position at fullback and Jamie Lyon playing right centre - where he has been having a blinder of a season at Manly.

Timana Tahu will switch to left centre, where he is more comfortable.

Jamal Idris will retain his position in the team after a solid debut on Wednesday night and will play on the right side where where the experienced Lyon can babysit him in defence.

The new-look squad for the match at Suncorp Stadium can cover for injuries in any of the positions.

If Gidley gets hurt, Barrett will move to halfback at Luke Lewis to five-eighth. If Michael Ennis gets hurt, Gidley will go to hooker, Barrett to halfback and Lewis to five-eighth.

The selection of Gidley and Barrett in the halves gives the Blues two strong kicking options and also allows Lyon to play in the position he likes best.

Obviously club form over the next fortnight will be closely monitored but if the team was picked today, the side we've nominated would be the one.

My information is that selectors will be taking a much firmer stand with Bellamy in their next phone hook-up to discuss the team's make-up, knowing their own positions are on the line.

In his third season of Origin coaching, Bellamy has always got exactly the squad he and his assistant coach Andrew Johns have wanted. Bellamy has had to accept much of the flak while Johns has escaped any of the harsh criticism.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
76,548
I don't think Tim is ready for origin nor would he bring anything exceptional to table at this stage of his development.

Having said that I would love for him to play origin as he would grow as a player and it would certainly benefit us in the long term.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
152,476
probably not ready but a great pat on the back for a good season so far
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
78,906
Jamal Idris will retain his position in the team after a solid debut on Wednesday night and will play on the right side where where the experienced Lyon can babysit him in defence.
so according to this, Idris will play wing? .... i know he did for the last 10 mins of SOO 1 when the game was done an dusted, but really, I don't want it to happen for a whole game - it could be carnage down that side

if all this were to happen, then we'd end up with ...
hayne
idris
lyon
tahu
morris
barrett
gidley
weyman
ennis
learoyd-lahrs
waterhouse
creagh
gallen

lewis
watmough
perry
king

probably better than game 1, but i'm not convinced about that bench or idris on the wing (or in the side at all - his sideways movement in defence is non existant, qld would have a field day for 80 mins) .... if you are going to piss players off, then surely get rid of perry - and i can't believe they wouldn't at least be considering snowden
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
76,548
Idris on wing ? I thought we were not playing them out of position anymore ? Seriously is he the best option on the wing ? I'd go for Michael Gordon from the Panfers. He's a good player, can kick and has got plenty of mongrel.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
76,548
Idris on wing ? I thought we were not playing them out of position anymore ? Seriously is he the best option on the wing ? I'd go for Michael Gordon from the Panfers. He's a good player, can kick and has got plenty of mongrel.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
152,549
Gidley at 7??? I give up these blokes have less idea than 99.9% of the people on LU. every team someone has picked on LU is light years ahead of the crap these dickheads have been offereing up for the last 5 years.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,733
Blocker was right when he said that the Journos go off their tits at every opportunity, some of them and including sloth need to take a chill pill.

they say you become a better player after experiancing an origin game, if that's the case then I think Mannah can be the best prop in the game once his played origin.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,733
Blocker was right when he said that the Journos go off their tits at every opportunity, some of them and including sloth need to take a chill pill.

they say you become a better player after experiancing an origin game, if that's the case then I think Mannah can be the best prop in the game once his played origin.
 

Mateo Moi Moi

Juniors
Messages
433
I'm a huge fan of Tim. Love is work rate and especially how he always seems to find elbows and knees and get a quick play the ball. I don't think he is ready just yet for origin though. Next year. Let him cement a run on spot for us first.

I don't know how Snowden & Douglas don't get a mention. They are both playing great footy.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
152,549
Blocker was right when he said that the Journos go off their tits at every opportunity, some of them and including sloth need to take a chill pill.

they say you become a better player after experiancing an origin game, if that's the case then I think Mannah can be the best prop in the game once his played origin.
And Kent was also right that we lost, and are looking down the barrel at 5 in a row. Kent is a douche but i thought he was on the money. Blocker is deluding himself if he thought there was only 4 points difference between the sides on a dry track they would have beaten us by 20.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
78,906
And Kent was also right that we lost, and are looking down the barrel at 5 in a row. Kent is a douche but i thought he was on the money. Blocker is deluding himself if he thought there was only 4 points difference between the sides on a dry track they would have beaten us by 20.
yeah but the press will write anything to write a story .... we lost game 1 last year, made changes and lost again and the press went to town because we didn't stick to a side like qld do .... blocker was right - the press will always find an angle

problem is they picked a dud team to start with this year .... i think we just have to be content to lose the series, piss off bellamy and the selectors and start fresh ..... if we lose game 2 this year, then we have to pick a game 3 side that is all about next year and consider a new coach/selectors for game 3 also (1-2, 0-3, who cares, its another series loss)
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
78,906
can you imagine mancans defending on the wing ?
... and whoever said layoff calling him mancans cos that photo's old a few weeks back is off the mark .... they showed him in the pool pre-origin, they're still there :lol:
 

Latest posts

Top