The Silverdale Phantom
Coach
- Messages
- 17,203
the simple undeniable fact is that we finished 15th & 12th the past two years. Players like JP, Merrin, Dufty, Williame & McInnes are all off contract. These players are rightly or wrongly associated with the sub par results. I doubt if any of the off contract players will be retained. Hook wants his own men not McGuber’s throwbacks.
I’m still a McInness fan. All through the dark days, he slogged his guts out and made a massive impact. But more broadly speaking, I have to agree. The build is on. Vaughn can go too.
Hook has sent some big names packing in the past and yet he still has a good success rate. He’s tough.
When Hook arrived, all he promised was effort. He has set the bar low in people’s mind at this stage during formative de-maryfication. I think that’s the right pr message. Not the team he wants. No coach gets the team they want.
But If he can get the side pumping and playing well, even if they miss the 8, it will be seen as an achievement of sorts.
Under Mary you’d sit and wait for a player of beauty like Frizz to drop the ball at a critical time. He’d find a way. It was tragic. But “hooking” up with the knights, ffs, their season is over now anyway. He can’t take a trick. If he wanted a fresh start he should have stayed. He didn’t know, but the pressure was building at the time. We all saw it.
Gus Gould called him the best coach in the game-before the public falling out. Even if he didn’t like Hook, I think Gus went too far criticising Hook and Gus’s assistance to McGregors review was laughable. The club was a laughing stock. Took some pressure off us!
The Tigers, we now have giant forwards, Packer is the runt of the pack in terms of size, some backage, but no proper fullback or rake. Shallow depth. 3 spots and a little cash as I understand it. We’d love a McInnes yesterday, despite the wrongful lack of enthusiasm on lu. I don’t think the lads here understand.
One clubs trash is another’s treasure sometimes.
Last edited: