Misanthropes Distraction Mafia Game Thread

[Drew-Sta]

Unless the town investigator is a nub he is going to stay quiet. The investigation power he has is useless and i refuse to believe soc would even have it in the game at all. Wp is blowing smoke up our ass.

If I was town investigator I wouldn't raise my head unless I had something useful (btw I'm not an investigator, I'm so vanilla I make vanilla seem exciting).

My only oversight is why so early? Given they have an RB, it makes WP sus.

He gets one investigation then gets screwed. Which is an odd decision.

Meh, why not. Let's do it KTF style.

Vote WarriorPoet

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

What jumping to conclusions?

WP has directly led to a town death. At this stage he's done more than anyone to hurt us. Nobody else has any better leads. If someone does, feel free to come forward.

You jumped on me as "number one suspect" because I lynched PP, and you jump on WP because his Drew like info got a townie lynched.

Does the phrase "cat chasing it's own tail" mean anything? Anybody who does anything to get a townie lynches then dies next or becomes "number one suspect". Completely pointless. There's no analysis, logical reasoning, just tit for tat townie on townie violence.

Complete nub logic.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Drew, that's a hell of a flip flop in the space of a few posts. You should know how that sets of suspicion, you were lucky it didn't get you lynched last time.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Drew, that's a hell of a flip flop in the space of a few posts. You should know how that sets of suspicion, you were lucky it didn't get you lynched last time.

I'm trying to think through the possibilities to be honest. What Ozzy and CJ say makes sense. Also, why would you reveal you found a mafia if you're only to get role blocked the next few nights?

Change Vote: No Vote

You're right though, its a flip flop. I'm going to back away.

Seriously though, 9701 made himself a target with his 'no vote' straight out :lol: soc must be laughing given he didn't pursue it and it ended badly, wheras someone pursued it on my behalf and got our town vig killed :lol:

 

[Jason Maher]

WarriorPoet (aka Dutchymang) explained why he got the false result he did. For my part, I believe him. For the time being.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

I'm trying to think through the possibilities to be honest. What Ozzy and CJ say makes sense. Also, why would you reveal you found a mafia if you're only to get role blocked the next few nights?

Change Vote: No Vote

You're right though, its a flip flop. I'm going to back away.

Seriously though, 9701 made himself a target with his 'no vote' straight out :lol: soc must be laughing given he didn't pursue it and it ended badly, wheras someone pursued it on my behalf and got our town vig killed :lol:

Might get role blocked, more likely killed. As to why he would reveal he found mafia, well, because they're mafia, that's the one time you do reveal.

At this point I'm sure our actual investigator will/has/plans to check out WP but even if WP comes up town there's no point saying anything unless he actually finds mafia.

I see what you're saying in regards to "why do it" but think about that for a second, unless they already know who the investigator us (highly unlikely) then WP making this play doesn't make sense because it outs him right under the investigation microscope. WP had a 50/50 shot, and in a game where there's only 4 mafia, taking one out early is a killer blow. The play makes way less sense if he's mafia.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Its a risky play to be sure.

Anyway, I'm not willing to lynch the Hop yet nor anyone else really. We're stabbing a bit too much in the dark. I'd like to see who brings forward an argument.

 

[whall15]

A census has been called

These are all night actions for both Town & Mafia combined.

Silence
Investigate x 2
Protect x 2
Even Night Kill x 2
Odd Night Kill
Kill
Roleblock x 2
One off full night Role Block

I'm not real sure what to do here considering we've got Micky, BM being a little sus and Drew's flip flop but I think it's important to remember what possible roles there are.

 

[soc123_au]

Edit

 

[Drew-Sta]

I'm not real sure what to do here considering we've got Micky, BM being a little sus and Drew's flip flop but I think it's important to remember what possible roles there are.

I was fleshing out an idea but got a little carried away. I don't intend to be a pair of haviana's in this game.

To be honest, we can only deduce that WP is telling the truth or lying, and the only way to discover this is to lynch him. I've got mixed feelings on the value of doing that.

BM's doing nothing different to what he did in Classic mafia really. Silly, on his behaf, but he's at least got convictions.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Hoppity at the moment is comparable to a cricket captain who moves fielders to the place where the ball last went. Considering his vast knowledge of the subject this is quite odd. :sarcasm:

 

[soc123_au]

Vote tally Day 3

Warriorpoet 3 Cjrankin, Hoppity, Hoggmaster

Hoppity 2 HowHigh, Warriorpoet

8 more to lynch the Cuzzy Bro.

 

[Drew-Sta]

So HH is meta'ing, WP is probably doing an OMGUS vote.

cj's silicone breast are unseasonably ruffled, Hoggy was sneaky in his attempt to suggest the lynch was a dud and that WP should go as a result of micky's death and BM is like a bloke who needs a nasal spray.

I'd say Hoggy deserves a look at, if I was a betting man.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

It's certainly not meta as Hogg and CJ have never played with WarriorPoet before.......

 

[Drew-Sta]

I'd say cj knows its Dutchy. Hogg possibly too. CJ's seemed fairly meta like. Hogg's was a cleverly worded posting though. cj didn't break character, really. At least, thats how I read it.

Hoggy seemed to absolve himself of responsbility.

 

[WarriorPoet]

I'm not Dutchy you racist twat.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Dutchy isn't playing this game, he said so himself in the sign up thread.

 

[Hoggmaster]

So HH is meta'ing, WP is probably doing an OMGUS vote.

cj's silicone breast are unseasonably ruffled, Hoggy was sneaky in his attempt to suggest the lynch was a dud and that WP should go as a result of micky's death and BM is like a bloke who needs a nasal spray.

I'd say Hoggy deserves a look at, if I was a betting man.

I'm not sure where the logic is falling down here. WP said definitively that 9701 was mafia so we lynched 9701. The info turned out to be false so WP says something which I feel to be a weak excuse.
I present 2 scenarios
1) WP has a useless power and convinced to kill a townie
2) WP is scum and purposely got us to kill a townie

In my post I suggested that WP could be telling the truth (as it cant be discounted completely) but in no way suggested I believed that was the case.

I'm not sure why you keep asserting that i'm trying to call a dud lynch when I did not.

 

[HowHigh]

Leave my bru WP alone

 

[Drew-Sta]

I'm not sure where the logic is falling down here. WP said definitively that 9701 was mafia so we lynched 9701. The info turned out to be false so WP says something which I feel to be a weak excuse.
I present 2 scenarios
1) WP has a useless power and convinced to kill a townie
2) WP is scum and purposely got us to kill a townie

In my post I suggested that WP could be telling the truth (as it cant be discounted completely) but in no way suggested I believed that was the case.

I'm not sure why you keep asserting that i'm trying to call a dud lynch when I did not.

9701 eh?

Also, WP presented before the lynch the conundrum with his investigation.

I'm suggesting your reasons for your vote are the seed for a lynch train (and an easy one) based on WP's info being wrong.

You're either ignorant (in which you'll laugh it off and expect us to go 'nub') or you're trying to change history to suit your proposition.