Nathan Cayless Vs Jason Cayless

[lucablight]

I know the Roosters and Eels supporters are going to be biased but who do most people believe is currently the better player and why?

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Nathan for sure.

 

[innsaneink]

The Parra guy, whichever that one is,by a country mile, the others just a big hairy *edit*

 

[choisir]

Jason for mine

 

[Magpie Nick]

Jason.

 

[ByRd]

JASON

 

[fillapop]

jason

 

[simon says]

This is a tricky one.....a year or two ago I would have said Nathan by a fair bit.But Jason has really improved over the last year or two.

Jason by a thread......both very good players though.

 

[Tommy Smith]

The question was currently, so on that basis it's like comparing Andrew Johns to Brad Drew. Jason easily and has been since 2002.

 

[Jamesy]

Jason for sure.

 

[Sterling]

Nathan has had nearly 2 whole seasons out of the game ... how can you compare???
when both were fit and injury free nathan was the better of the 2 .......

hence jason going to the roosters as he couldnt crack a FG spot at parra 2000/2001

this qn should be asked at the end of the year ... hopefully nathan wont break his arm again!

 

[gregstar]

jason

 

[stubbsie]

Nathan gets my vote

 

[Stagger eel]

current form Jason!

both at their peak, Nathen, but in all honesty not much between them.

 

[Jono078]

Jason for me, I think he is improving each and every game... And I rather him than our prop :lol: .

 

[ozzie]

Jason - a hard work horse and its not becuase of my biase...I have watched him develop since he came to the Roosters from a second grader or bench player to be what he is today.

the only thing I could critise about his game is his lateral movement in defence - but don't run straight at him

 

[eelsta]

nathan because i am biased :lol:

 

[Glen]

Both at their best - not much in it, but Nathan. Unfortunately Jason is way ahead at the moment simply because of Nathan's terrible run with injuries

 

[bozza tgg]

At their best there is no question it is Nathan Cayless.

However on form it has to be Jason as Nathan has not graced the park often enough

 

[Freak]

If you are talking about current form you would have to say Nathan
He was a standout in the tri nations for the Kiwi's.

Nathan Cayless is not only the better Cayless "injury free" he is one of the best forwards in the game!!