Nathan Hindmarsh

[God-King Dean]

I'm not saying his a bad player, i just think his not living up to what he could be. His attacking game is non-exsistent. I miss the Hindy of 00-02 that would run wide and hit the gap, the great offloads, it's just gone.

I agree. He played this way against Saints at Oki & carved us up.

I've always wanted to know what Hindmarsh gets in a beep test.

 

[Mr Saab]

To be honest i'm kind of over the current Nathan Hindmarsh.

I'm not saying his a bad player, i just think his not living up to what he could be. His attacking game is non-exsistent. I miss the Hindy of 00-02 that would run wide and hit the gap, the great offloads, it's just gone.

I know his a machine and makes a thousand tackles, but defence isn't everything.

It was like watching a clone of Gary Larson/Billy Moore.
A player of his standard should not have to make 59 tackles in any game. Waste of a great player who can attack on the fringes.
Sure, he saved tries (the tackle on Sing, which then resulted in a penalty) but he should not be making 59 of them.

 

[The_Coach]

I agree. He played this way against Saints at Oki & carved us up.

Yeah he had a great game that day, and the try he scored brought back some great memories. It is a real shame he doesn't play that style of game more often.

Maybe Hagan will play him that way next year, we can only hope.

 

[The_Coach]

It was like watching a clone of Gary Larson/Billy Moore.
A player of his standard should not have to make 59 tackles in any game. Waste of a great player who can attack on the fringes.
Sure, he saved tries (the tackle on Sing, which then resulted in a penalty) but he should not be making 59 of them.

So true. When a player makes that many tackles they shouldn't look at him and say what a champion, he played great. They should look at the other 16 guys in the team and say what the hell were you doing all game?

 

[stuke]

he is our new and improved 'Mr Perpetual Motion'.