I preferred Goodes to be honest.
Judd went well, particularly in the first half, but -- as always -- people's fixation on his pace overlook his use of the ball. He's quick, strong and he looks great breaking the lines, but unless he is going short to a target, his disposal isn't overly crisp. In short, not a lot of his possessions went to a team mate and thus were not always damaging.
Goodes was popping-up everywhere and controlling matters.