What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Parramatta Eels 2014 Season Review Thread

Joely01

Bench
Messages
4,553
The first of many.

http://www.nrl.com/eels-2014-season-review-/tabid/10874/newsid/81706/default.aspx?cid=NRL_HP_Latest

After back-to-back wooden spoons, pretty much anything would have been an improvement for the Eels – and improvement is what they got.

They didn't quite scrape into the finals but to be in with a chance of that scenario heading into the final round of the regular season, you'd have to call 2014's eventual 10th-place finish a positive result – which in itself pretty much sums up how poor the previous two seasons have been for the blue and gold faithful.

Still, it must be said their finish to the season was a disappointment – precariously placed with three rounds to go, a stunning second half against then-ladder-leaders Manly meant they needed just one win against either the lowly Knights or even-more-lowly Raiders to cement a spot in the eight.

At Newcastle in Round 25 they produced their worst 40 minutes of the season after taking a below-par four-point lead into halftime to go down 42-12 following a 34-0 avalanche of points against them, then backed it up with an almost-as-dire opening 40 in Canberra to fall behind 32-6 before briefly threatening a comeback.

Still, that Manly win, and a strong 14-12 win over the Roosters back in Round 6 that was packed with character coming, as it did, just a month after they were lapped 56-4 by the same opponents, were among the season's highlights.

The vintage form of star fullback Jarryd Hayne had everyone talking and the fact Hayne was getting good support from his halves in Corey Norman and Chris Sandow, and from hookers Nathan Peats and later Isaac De Gois, was most encouraging.

Peats himself was looking like being one of the buys of the year until an unfortunate knee injury ended his season early; impressive back-rower Manu Ma'u was in Rookie of the Year calculations before a broken arm ended his season early, and Hayne himself was in Dally M consideration right throughout.

Then there's rookie coach Brad Arthur – a local junior who understands the club and the area, but who cut his teeth as a coach in highly professional Melbourne and Manly outfits. A no-nonsense operator, a man of few words, and just what the doctor ordered for a disjointed club needing some direction.

There were also hugely encouraging signs from some talented young forwards – the likes of Pauli Pauli, Junior Paulo, Peni Terepo, Kenny Edwards and the youngest of the lot in Tepai Moeroa will be a force for years to come.

English Test prop Lee Mossop was barely sighted due to injury but will almost certainly be an asset to the club next year, the Peats/De Gois/Kaysa Pritchard hooking rotation is the strongest the club has had in recent memory, and Will Hopoate will be better with a full season and second pre-season under his belt back after two years out.

The Eels very much look like a club on the rise, and after four years in the doldrums since 2009 that, more than anything, will be music to the ears of long-suffering fans.

Where They Excelled: When the Eels were hot, they were smokin'. Some of their point-scoring sprees were ultra-impressive and once they learn how to cut out their poor patches they will truly be a force, based on what we saw in 2014.

Three tries in six minutes in that Round 26 loss to Canberra, and three tries in 10 minutes in the Round 24 win over Manly, are two quick-fire bursts still fresh in the memory. Their Round 1 win over the Warriors featured two tries in the space of four minutes twice in the game – a feat they repeated when they machine-gunned tries past Cronulla in Round 9.

The Eels remain very much a momentum side but it is the occasions, like against the Roosters in Round 6, where they figured out how to graft a win, that provide encouragement ahead of next year.

Stats-wise the Eels finished up, unsurprisingly, fairly middle-of-the-pack in most categories but the fact they were fourth-best when it came to breaking tackles spoke to a dangerous running game, largely off the back of Hayne, with 720 busts for the year.

Where They Struggled: Defence, and handling. The Eels finished equal eighth on competition points, but 196 points worth of differential behind the actual eighth-placed finishing Broncos. Their eventual -103 differential (Brisbane +93) was threatening to keep them out of the finals a long time before it did eventually keep them out of the finals and aside from the above-mentioned debacles in the final two rounds and the 56-4 Round 2 battering at the hands of the Roosters, there was a 42-14 loss in Townsville, 38-12 loss at Penrith and woeful 48-0 hammering in New Zealand. They finished 10th on the ladder but were down in 13th defensively, better than only the beleaguered trio of Cronulla, Canberra and Wests Tigers. It was like once their morale was defeated the heads went down and floodgates opened. They need to work out how to keep their heads in the game even when things aren't going their way to avoid having their for-and-against knocking them down the end-of-year ladder.

And here's a telling stat – the Eels completed the fewest sets in 2014. Their 604 completed sets in 24 games was below Wests Tigers (612) and the Sharks (613).

Missing In Action: The Eels were hanging around in the top four for a fair stretch at the start of the year, but from there, there were two very big absences that hurt their chances. The major one was hooker Nathan Peats, whose recruitment from South Sydney ahead of the 2014 season proved a masterstroke. His ruptured ACL in Round 12 was a crushing blow for Parra's season, and as impressive as emergency replacement Isaac De Gois was, they never quite recovered. A broken arm ended late-blooming rookie Manu Ma'u's season in Round 14 and combined with Jarryd Hayne's absence during the Origin period, the Eels slipped from third to 11th in a horror two months and never quite recovered. Added to that, high-profile recruit Lee Mossop played just three games due to an ongoing shoulder problem. Retiring veteran Ben Smith played just 10 games, largely due to an early-season hand injury, and at one stage late in the season there were four outside backs unavailable for a short period. Their 30 players was at the higher end and only three players – Semi Radradra, Corey Norman and Joe Paulo – played every game of 2014.

Turning Point: Round 12. The Eels had had a solid two months since their Round 2 battering by the Roosters, climbing back to third, with only one loss of over four points (42-14 to the Cowboys) and five wins, three losses and one bye overall. They also broke an away duck that was well over a year long. But a 38-12 hammering at the hands of a side they had disposed of easily just eight weeks prior and losing key man Nathan Peats for the season, headed into a representative season where their best player was going to be unavailable more often than not, was a blow from which the side couldn't fully recover.

Best Games: It's tough to split their two best efforts. While their biggest by margin – 36-0 against a rabble of a Dragons side in Benji Marshall's first game back in the NRL – came against a poor opposition, their equal smallest by margin – 14-12 against the Roosters in Round 6 – was absolutely brimming with character. They'd been walloped by the defending premiers a month earlier 56-4 at Allianz but produced arguably their best defensive game of the year (a huge try-saver from Hayne on Sonny Bill Williams the highlight).

Worst Games: Plenty of ashes to sift through here. The 54-6 grilling in Round 2 took the wind out of their sails after a good first-up win and it was their equal biggest loss along with a 48-0 effort over in New Zealand.

But surely their most disappointing effort, against a team that had been terrible the week before and with a spot on the finals beckoning, was the 42-12 capitulation at Newcastle in Round 25. After failing to capitalise on the howling gale at their backs in the opening half, leading by 12-8 at the turn, the blue-and-golds conceded 34 unanswered points to effectively kiss a promising season goodbye.

Hold Your Head High: Plenty of candidates here, actually. Brad Arthur deserves massive credit for what he was able to instil in the team in a short amount of time. Halfback Chris Sandow – who finished the year with easily the most 40/20s (seven, next best three) to go with his 15 try assists, deserves praise for how he's been able to turn himself around after being relegated to park footy in 2013. Nathan Peats was immense, with 380 stinging tackles and providing lots of spark in his 10 games before being injured and young Semi Radradra on the wing, with only a handful of NRL games under his belt as season's start, was the year's second-top try scorer with 19. But for massive efforts we can't go past the rejuvenated Jarryd Hayne – the year's top try scorer with 20, as well as most line breaks (23), second for tackle breaks (138), as well as 14 try assists and 16 line break assists – Hayne was simply immense in 2014 and any team with him in it will always be a threat.

Conclusion: A tough finish to an overall positive season, with plenty of promising signs that things could be on the improve. Consistency is still an issue, but if they can bring their worst efforts up somewhere closer to their best efforts the way clubs like Melbourne and Manly do, they could be a serious title threat in the next year or two.

SEASON STATISTICS

Wins: 12
Losses: 12
Position: 10th
Home Record: 8 wins, 4 losses
Away Record: 4 wins, 8 losses
Longest Winning Streak: 3 (Rounds 20-22)
Longest Losing Streak: 4 (Rounds 15-19)
Players Used: 31
Tries Scored (after 26 rounds): 90 (=7th)
Tries Conceded (after 26 rounds): 101 (fifth worst)

*Stats: Champion Data
 

Joely01

Bench
Messages
4,553
I think this is pretty spot on.

There is a lot to be excited about in years to come for this team.
 

crocodile

Bench
Messages
3,509
After our 6th coach in nine seasons and a pair of spoons I think we did pretty well. A lot of inexperience there. Can only get better.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
74,101
Great year. Astounding that we recovered so quickly after the Kearney & Stuart f**k up years Stephen Sharp, Brad Arthur & Daniel Anderson have done an amazing job. The club has turned a corner and is brimming with confidence and the future looks bright.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
Great year. Astounding that we recovered so quickly after the Kearney & Stuart f**k up years

That's because they weren't f**k up years, they were rebuilding years. We now have a solid young squad with massive potential. Plus more great talent filtering through from the 'academy'.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
74,101
That's because they weren't f**k up years, they were rebuilding years. We now have a solid young squad with massive potential. Plus more great talent filtering through from the 'academy'.

Kearney & Stuart were cancer mate. Cancer.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
You're a moron Gronk. We finished mid table because we have a mid table squad. Did Arthur assemble this roster? I like him as a coach but it's naïve to pin a team's finish on the ladder entirely on the coach. What's the point of recruitment and retention of players if all you need to be successful is the best coach? Why not just grab any 17 merkins and throw jerseys on them? The coach will do the rest. :roll:
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
74,101
You're a moron Gronk. We finished mid table because we have a mid table squad. Did Arthur assemble this roster? I like him as a coach but it's naïve to pin a team's finish on the ladder entirely on the coach. What's the point of recruitment and retention of players if all you need to be successful is the best coach? Why not just grab any 17 merkins and throw jerseys on them? The coach will do the rest. :roll:

Nice rant merkin. I now it's hard for you at the moment.

Kearney was cancer.

#keepingitreal
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
By all means, troll. But don't tell f**king lies.

Our squad has massive potential and it's not due to any staff still at the club.

The foundation of any premiership side - including the Roosters, Storm and Manly - is developing the bulk of the squad through your own junior pathways. Simply having the best Harold Matthews side isn't the same thing.
 

eel01s

Bench
Messages
3,269
"And here's a telling stat – the Eels completed the fewest sets in 2014. Their 604 completed sets in 24 games was below Wests Tigers (612) and the Sharks (613)."

This is what really cost us a finals berth in those close losses. Those 10-15min patches where we kept dropping the ball and giving away dumb penalties.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
74,101
By all means, troll. But don't tell f**king lies.

Our squad has massive potential and it's not due to any staff still at the club.

The foundation of any premiership side - including the Roosters, Storm and Manly - is developing the bulk of the squad through your own junior pathways. Simply having the best Harold Matthews side isn't the same thing.

There's no lies in what I say. Kearney was cancer.

Let it go mate. We have a new crew who know how to manage a team. Things are finally looking up.
 

Tony Bongo

Bench
Messages
3,006
That's because they weren't f**k up years, they were rebuilding years. We now have a solid young squad with massive potential. Plus more great talent filtering through from the 'academy'.

That's the way I see it too but I still commend BA on getting the results he did this year.
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
11,407
Pou is the moron on this subject. Total selective assessment. Gives credit to blokes for not recruiting most of the current squad, and gives a pass mark for paying massive overs to reserve graders (who were so crap we paid for them this year despite telling them to piss off)

This all on top of the fact that neither bloke could coach to save his life....at least Ricky was able to leverage his (fast fading) reputation to bring in a few halfway decent players for this year!
Kearney talked it up, but (by his own admission) was way out of his depth, and almost everything he touched turned to crap.
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
11,407
There's no lies in what I say. Kearney was cancer.

Let it go mate. We have a new crew who know how to manage a team. Things are finally looking up.

Exactly . THIS was the first rebuilding year. The previous years were a complete schemozzle (excuse my spelling on that word)
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
There's no lies in what I say. Kearney was cancer.

Let it go mate. We have a new crew who know how to manage a team. Things are finally looking up.

I certainly won't let it go. Recent head coaches had their faults, as do most (all?) coaches, but making them the scapegoats doesn't invalidate the fact that they contributed significantly to building the current squad.

If we're going to discuss rugby league here, and especially the future of our team (since it is the off season) we need to come to some consensus on cause and effect in the development of an NRL squad.

By all means disagree, but if your only answer to any genuine analysis is to throw out trollish comments then you're not actually contributing anything. In fact in your haste to shut down debate and maintain a line of propaganda, you are potentially stifling the understanding of others.

I understand it is soothing for you to believe that 'all the shit is behind us' along with the designated scapegoats of those years but we currently have no way of knowing if we are heading into a bright future or have merely hit a low peak between two troughs.

Whatever circumstance that led to our previous low point of player talent might still be with us, and whatever is responsible for giving us this brief glimmer of hope may already be gone. How would you know if you refuse to engage in anything but the most shallow of analysis? ("It's all about the coach!")

If you disagree with the concept of squad trajectory, and believe the fate of any given team is tied to whoever is the head coach that year, then you will believe that we were average this year because of Arthur (and strangely, Anderson). Given they will both be here next year, then what is stopping us from being average again next year? From where do you get your optimism, considering neither BA nor DA have performed better at an NRL club than they did in their first year?

If you have other reasons for hope, what are they? And what are the implications of those other reasons?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
Exactly . THIS was the first rebuilding year. The previous years were a complete schemozzle (excuse my spelling on that word)

Are you just trolling or are you really that thick?

What exactly was built this year? Are you that excited about our new signings? Or is it that we stopped collapsing like a house of cards under pressure?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
That's the way I see it too but I still commend BA on getting the results he did this year.

I think there is some evidence that we improved because of Brad Arthur, considering a couple of players at their peak performed better than in previous years (specifically Sandow and Joe Paulo) but at least one (Lussick) was worse. Then again that's what you expect from an injury-disrupted season; look at Hayne, Tonga and others from previous years.

Otherwise most of our improvement came from young players, but most of them would have improved anyway. There are always exceptions (e.g. Tanginoa this year) but you can hardly blame the coach for that any more than you should credit him for the team's results in his first year.

Ivan Cleary is proving, in his third year at the Panthers, that his previous rebuild of the Warriors was no fluke. But the Panthers were shit in his first year at the club. That was no more his fault than a coach like Stuart, Hagan or Trent Robinson winning a premiership in their first season at a club. It could take years for a team's results to reflect the coach's input. Is Cleary finally a good coach again after being average last year and shite the year before? Does anyone really think Robinson and Toovey are great coaches? Or are they just drinking from a well dug by others?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
Pou is the moron on this subject. Total selective assessment. Gives credit to blokes for not recruiting most of the current squad, and gives a pass mark for paying massive overs to reserve graders (who were so crap we paid for them this year despite telling them to piss off)

That's ok - he paid massive unders for other reserve graders like Manu Ma'u (which enabled us to get rid of the overpaid gingers), so it all comes out in the wash.

The best thing Kearney did was focus on junior recruitment and retention, which has given future coaches more options than were available when he took over the club (i.e. Allgood, Morgan, Loko and Sio).

This all on top of the fact that neither bloke could coach to save his life....at least Ricky was able to leverage his (fast fading) reputation to bring in a few halfway decent players for this year!
Kearney talked it up, but (by his own admission) was way out of his depth, and almost everything he touched turned to crap.

Kearney didn't say what you continually claim he said. This 'out if his depth' is a deliberate misquote, and it's no surprise you don't use the correct quote, given it says more about our club than about Kearney.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
85,144
Obviously ! :roll:

Well then stop talking shit in every thread where it comes up. The fact is you scapegoaters have been embarrassed by the success of our NYC team and our younger NRL players this year. I'm here to call you on your bullshit every time you try to pretend this club's future playing strength was built during 2014.

Brad Arthur is probably a good coach but he inherited a solid squad with massive junior talent on its way through. The last coach to inherit such a squad was Michael Hagan.
 
Top