What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Parramatta Eels CEO Paul Osborne concerned over ageing list of 2011 recruits

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
79,959
Parramatta Eels CEO Paul Osborne concerned over ageing list of 2011 recruits







043794-eels-main-event.gif

Source: The Daily Telegraph



PARRAMATTA CEO Paul Osborne has admitted to harbouring private concerns over the club's ageing list of 2011 recruits, which yesterday fell victim to a third mid-season retirement in veteran prop Carl Webb.

And Eels chairman Roy Spagnolo revealed the club would soon launch a Brisbane Broncos-style youth academy to help remedy a disappointing season that plunged to new depths after Monday night's 50-point thrashing by South Sydney.
The record flogging has Parramatta firmly in contention for their first wooden spoon in four decades, and exposed club bosses to scrutiny over their recruitment policy and sacking of previous coach Daniel Anderson.
One of four off-season buys on the wrong side of 30, Webb yesterday followed veterans Chris Walker, 31, and Paul Whatuira, 30, into premature retirement after just a handful of NRL appearances with their new club.
It is understood Walker was the only player purchased by new coach Stephen Kearney, who was caught short out wide after the departures of Timana Tahu and Eric Grothe, on top of Joel Reddy's long-term shoulder injury.
With a weakened roster at his disposal, Kearney has been spared pressure that is usually applied to coaches who have won just five games. But after a string of spirited defeats, Monday night's debacle turned up the heat on Osborne and Spagnolo to speak out.
Both expressed unequivocal support for Kearney, and declared the older players were purchased out of necessity after suffering so many unexpected backline losses.
Asked if he was concerned by the number of older players being recruited, Osborne replied: "Of course I was. But they were as good as we could get at the time. The biggest thing for us was Timana walking out, Eric retiring and Joel's shoulder injury.
"Three quarters of our starting backline was gone before the season started and we had to get what was available.
"Whether it be Daniel (Anderson) or Steve (Kearney), the coach gets the players they want."
Anderson was sacked after the Eels finished 13th last year, although they were in finals contention at this stage 12 months ago. Osborne and Spagnolo, however, have no regrets over punting Anderson a year early and installing rookie Kearney.
"We needed a major overhaul, right from the juniors up," Osborne said.
"We needed a complete overhaul in the way we did things. For too long we've made a grand final one year then finished 13th the next. There has been an inconsistency. It was never going to be a quick or easy to fix.
"But I've seen enough behind closed doors to be 110 per cent behind Steve Kearney."
Spagnolo added: "I think at the end of the day psychologically it (the run of close losses) got to them ... it was an unusual performance. The coach is building a good culture and with our recruits next year (Chris Sandow, Ben Roberts and Willie Tonga), we're on the right track.
"Everyone has to be patient."
Parramatta's long-term overhaul will begin in November, when the Eels Junior Academy is launched. As part of a major football department restructure that has already claimed assistant coach Peter Sharp and recruitment manager Rod Reddy, Toyota Cup coach Matt Cameron will be placed in charge of the club's best young recruits.
The retirement of Webb, who was contracted for a further season, clears space under the Eels' 2012 salary cap to sign Tonga on a three-year deal expected to be announced this week.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/n...of-2011-recruits/story-e6frfgbo-1226111997567
 

koal4e

Juniors
Messages
196
Too true and this doesnt include the likes of Willie Tonga - if/when he signs there is another older player in the pot....wheres all the Juniors!
 

Tony Bongo

Bench
Messages
3,006
So we are firing Casey McGuire ? So we should too, he has been one of our weakest links for weeks now.
 
Last edited:

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
12,075
Too true and this doesnt include the likes of Willie Tonga - if/when he signs there is another older player in the pot....wheres all the Juniors!

Not sure if you kept up with current affairs, but rod Reddy was in charge of junior retention the last few years, which culminated in us coming LAST in 2010 in the U20s. (we won 3 games... oh dear).

If you're hoping those juniors are going to turn the club around, you're more than a little bit out of the loop!

Tonga might be in his late 20s, but he's a seasoned NRL campaigner who is a CURRENT origin rep.
That's more than a little bit different to a bunch of old guys from superleague, starring Chris Hicks (had a good season back in 2007) and Whats (won a GF back in 2005 and has some serious psych issues in between then and now).
Totally different story.
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
My guess is he means that Casey has been firing, form-wise, this year.

Some of our existing players that will be turning 30 or over come next year: Hindmarsh (32), Moimoi (32), Burt (31), Maitua (30), Shackleton (30).

I think Tonga is only 28 next year, so younger than Atkins?
 

Tony Bongo

Bench
Messages
3,006
My guess is he means that Casey has been firing, form-wise, this year.

Some of our existing players that will be turning 30 or over come next year: Hindmarsh (32), Moimoi (32), Burt (31), Maitua (30), Shackleton (30).

I think Tonga is only 28 next year, so younger than Atkins?

I was being sarcastic and optimistic at the same time. ;-)
For mine Casey seems to have made the decision to retire weeks ago but hasn't told the club yet. It could just be his age showing and he's struggling at the back end of the season, or that he has an incentive based contract on how many games he plays, but either way he hasn't put the effort in lately and I would have replaced him with Humble or Morts weeks ago.
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
Over the whole season Maguire has done ok I reckon. He gave us something we didn't have at hooker, and since the demise of Morts and Robson's injuries he's stepped in the best he can in the halves. Sure he's struggling with being picked out wide in the defensive line for 80 mins, but we really couldn't have asked for much more.

I agree though, while an offer was reportedly put on the table for Maguire, I'm not sure why he hasn't re-signed. Maybe he's struggling physically/playing through injury, and wants to see how he pulls up before committing to what would be a bench role for one last season? Humble must really be on the outer not to have had a taste of first grade this season...
 

I bleed blue & gold

First Grade
Messages
8,868
My guess is he means that Casey has been firing, form-wise, this year.

Some of our existing players that will be turning 30 or over come next year: Hindmarsh (32), Moimoi (32), Burt (31), Maitua (30), Shackleton (30).

I think Tonga is only 28 next year, so younger than Atkins?

Willie turned 28 a couple of days ago.
 

PB

Bench
Messages
3,311
I like how Paul Osborne appears to be taking no responsibility for the recruitment process and performance of the club to this point, however he is spruking that he is making these changes so that he can take the plaudits should the club turn its fortunes around.

If the club does get its act together, then he can take some credit, but he also needs to say, "we stuffed up by signing dad's army and not retaining some good quality players that we had in our nursery and I have some responsibility in that"
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
155,398
Casey firing ?

ummm............................no

not in my opinion, he's just keeping a spot warm for whom ever takes it next season
 

Maroubra Eel

Coach
Messages
19,044
Great news the Academy opens in November. I was wondering about that.

Great news that SK has the full support of the board and CEO.
 

DeanPay98

Juniors
Messages
1,116
Maguire has been asked to play for longer in games than he can really manage. A uality 40 minutes from him as the second hooker or back-up half would be fantastic. 80 minutes from him at halfback isn't good. Luckily Keating's form at hooker has completely stepped up.
 

Maroubra Eel

Coach
Messages
19,044
Maguire has been asked to play for longer in games than he can really manage. A uality 40 minutes from him as the second hooker or back-up half would be fantastic. 80 minutes from him at halfback isn't good. Luckily Keating's form at hooker has completely stepped up.
I agree. He was much better when better utilised earlier in the season.
 

Latest posts

Top