Penalty tries

[roboshark]

We have had 2 in 6 games. There have been others in the other games this year as well .Honestly cannot recall a year where I have seen more then 1 or 2 all year

 

[Frenzy.]

You aware the rule has changed?

 

[roboshark]

Yes but still there have been quite a few and only early days don't U think

 

[Frenzy.]

Yes, I think.

 

[roboshark]

No worries

 

[Card Shark]

Chad’s was a good decision.

He was about to catch it & all he had to do then was fall over. His hands were held back causing him to drop it.

As I said elsewhere, if it was Dugan, they wouldn’t have given it as he dropped the simplest of pickups early in the game.

 

[wibble]

Chad’s was a good decision.

He was about to catch it & all he had to do then was fall over. His hands were held back causing him to drop it.

As I said elsewhere, if it was Dugan, they wouldn’t have given it as he dropped the simplest of pickups early in the game.

Yeah, I thought it was an easy decision. Commentators weren't concerned at all in the coverage.

The one we got against Newcastle was obviously controversial, but if that is a standard they'll set I'm good with that. Cynical fouls against players about to score should not be "rewarded" with only a penalty (though you could argue two of them this year have just been unlucky timing from defenders).

 

[Frenzy.]

Those 2 WZ brothers cost the Panthers big time.

 

[Mr Spock!]

I think the interpretation of denying a try scoring opportunity is best.

The old had to be certain of a try being scored was open to all sorts of interpretation.

 

[shaggs]

4 penalty tries his year.
In 41 games.

10% is very high but I expected it.

 

[Frenzy.]

Live long and prosper

 

[Ads]

Some panthers fans think it wasn’t even worthy of a penalty. Lol.

 

[Frenzy.]

Some panthers fans think it wasn’t even worthy of a penalty. Lol.

Luke, Luke, Luke or Luke?

All of them?

 

[Ads]

Luke, Luke, Luke or Luke?

All of them?

Got it in 4.

 

[snout]

I thought it was a penalty try because it was chad.
And if it had been anybody else we definately wouldve scored.


Just jokes CT lovers. Settle.

 

[Frenzy.]

Hahahaha

You cunova thing snout

 

[Cheese sandwich]

Some panthers fans think it wasn’t even worthy of a penalty. Lol.

If i was 23 vb's and 12 cones deep I'd probably have blurred vision too

 

[Frenzy.]

Got it in 4.

f**k me. I ventured out of here to read what the Luke’s had to say.

He’s a whacko

 

[jc155776]

I think cynical tackles (worse than what we saw last night) should be a penalty try AND a 10 min breather as well.

Crack down and deliberate cheating.

I actually thought the players going to the bin last year for deliberate penalties inside the ten was great as well.

 

[Inferno]

You aware the rule has changed?

From what to what? All the ones I've seen given were pretty clear cut in my view.