Player Rating v Saint George

[imasharkie]

1. D.Peachey - 5: had an average game
2. D.Simmons - 4: an improved game from him but still PL standard.
3. N.Vagana - 7: nige was all over the place and made some great tackles
4. P.Mellor - 5: he made some good runs and defended ok
5. L.Covell - 2: disgraceful performance in defence.lost us the game.
6. A.Dykes - 6: kept us in the game with some great offloads
7. B.Kimmorley- 7: BK was one of our best was like a tiger in defence
8. K.Galloway - 4: Goodbye and enjoy PL at the tigers
9. K.Kingston - 8: our best on the field so pleased we signed him
10. D.Nuttley - 7: runs hard but not making a lot of metres per run
11. P.Lealeua - 7: hits it up hard and puts some mongrel in his defence
12. P.Bailey - 4: ordinary in attack but puts in the defence
13. P.Gallen - 7: runs hard and tackles all day
14. C.Maunau - 6: give him some game time tried hard each time he was on
15. M.Hilder - 6: for his size he tries hard and should be a permanant
16. R.Williams- 7: smashed 1st tackle but tried hard all night
17. B.Scott - 7: terrorised the backs with his strong defence.Gas was scared

 

[PHaTMaN]

1. D.Peachey - 5: had an average game
2. D.Simmons - 6: not a bad game
3. N.Vagana - 9: best game in sharks colours
4. P.Mellor - 6: Didnt stand out
5. L.Covell - 5: made one poor miss on Best.
6. A.Dykes - 3: We looked better when he was on the bench
7. B.Kimmorley- 8: gave his all, good game
8. K.Galloway - 2: Goodbye and enjoy PL at the tigers
9. K.Kingston - 7.5: Good service from dummy half and good defense
10. D.Nuttley - 7.5: Got thru a mountain of work
11. P.Lealeua - 6: hits it up hard
12. P.Bailey - 5: good defense, went missing in attack.
13. P.Gallen - 7: runs hard and tackles all day
14. C.Maunau - 5: Ran hard, lazy in defense
15. M.Hilder - 6: nothing special
16. R.Williams- 6: got smashed but kept going
17. B.Scott - 6: missed a few tackles, but hits and runs hard

 

[Mr Angry]

1. D.Peachey - 6: Not outstanding but far from a disgrace.
2. D.Simmons - 6: Played OK, I would kick to him also about as threatening as a sponge.
3. N.Vagana - 9: Great game.
4. P.Mellor - 6: Why oh why did we keep him on, did what was ask, then was asked to much.
5. L.Covell - 6: Not a winger.
6. A.Dykes - 6: Dangerous when on fresh, should have started the 2nd half.
7. B.Kimmorley- 9: Best kicking game all year
8. K.Galloway - -1: A J.King type performance, a disgrace to every no. 8 in the game. Hit up is what your supposed to do - fuggen cat.
9. K.Kingston - 8: A real hooker, delivery to BK spot on.
10. D.Nutley - 7: Tried and tried and finally got a breather.
11. P.Leuleua - 8: Great game, would have been even better if he did not have to make all the yards the big carrot cat wouldn't.
12. P.Bailey - 6: good defence, too many minutes.
13. P.Gallen - 7: runs hard and tackles all day.
14. C.Maunau - 5: Used incorrectly - is a wide running forward.
15. M.Hilder - 6: Hopefully his shoulder will be better next year - grave concerns over his future.
16. R.Williams- 6: Soild enough, but concerns me, perhaps a prop seems pretty dumb footy wise.
17. B.Scott - 6: will make a great winger one day.

Raper: 6

Started well, then used his bench badly as usual.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

5. L.Covell - 2: disgraceful performance in defence.lost us the game.

17. B.Scott - 7: terrorised the backs with his strong defence.Gas was scared

biggest load of shiitt you ever written uncle.
Scott was caught out by Gaz at least 3 times. if gaz was scared it was bout how far he was going to have to run.

Scott has poor defence.
Lucky your boy mezz wasnt out there outside scoot or we might have seen a new record by a winger for missed tackles.

 

[amzz]

peach-4 far from good
simmo-6.5 played well wish ppl would get off this blokes back
mellor-6 done very little
scott-7.5 we have found the person to fix our centre problem,gaz scared sh*tless
covell-7 good game,although tries were scored down his side wasnt his fualt problem came from closer in.
nige-8.5 great game,put on some good hits
noddy-9 in top form,wish it came sooner
nuts-7 a true nuttly game
kinga-9 the future looks bright for the shire,with this bloke
red-4 enjoy pl!!!
looloo-7.5 top game,this bloke was pumped
bails-6.5 went well in defense
gallen-7 tiredless
manua-7 strong when on
williams-7.5 a top player,gets hit and jus shrugs it off and goes again
hilder-7 played well,size doesnt matter
dykes-7 injected himself well

 

[da_sharks]

6. A.Dykes - 3: We looked better when he was on the bench

are you kidding?

biggest load of shiitt you ever written uncle.
Scott was caught out by Gaz at least 3 times. if gaz was scared it was bout how far he was going to have to run.

there was one time when gaz baited him to the wing and just pushed him out. even the commentators were saying that scott should learn from that. still a young player. plenty of potential

 

[millersnose]

1. D.Peachey - 6.5
2. D.Simmons - 6
3. N.Vagana - 8
4. P.Mellor - 6:
5. L.Covell - 6.5
6. A.Dykes - 5.
7. B.Kimmorley- 8
8. K.Galloway - 6
9. K.Kingston - 6
10. D.Nutley - 7
11. P.Leuleua - 6
12. P.Bailey - 5
13. P.Gallen - 6.5
14. C.Maunau - 5
15. M.Hilder - 5
16. R.Williams- 5
17. B.Scott - 5

Raper: 9 actually had a game plan that nearly worked


barrets dive 9.8

 

[amzz]

1. D.Peachey - 6.5
2. D.Simmons - 6
3. N.Vagana - 8
4. P.Mellor - 6:
5. L.Covell - 6.5
6. A.Dykes - 5.
7. B.Kimmorley- 8
8. K.Galloway - 6
9. K.Kingston - 6
10. D.Nutley - 7
11. P.Leuleua - 6
12. P.Bailey - 5
13. P.Gallen - 6.5
14. C.Maunau - 5
15. M.Hilder - 5
16. R.Williams- 5
17. B.Scott - 5

Raper: 9 actually had a game plan that nearly worked


barrets dive 9.8

were you even watchin the game miller?
these were 3 of our best

 

[amzz]

1. D.Peachey - 6.5
9. K.Kingston - 6
11. P.Leuleua - 6
17. B.Scott - 5

are you telling me that you think peach played better then these 3?
you 1 eyed c**k smoker!

 

[Alan Shore]

1. D.Peachey - 7
2. D.Simmons - 5
3. N.Vagana - 9
4. P.Mellor - 6
5. L.Covell - 6
6. A.Dykes - 5.
7. B.Kimmorley- 8
8. K.Galloway - 0
9. K.Kingston - 7
10. D.Nutley - 8
11. P.Leuluai - 7
12. P.Bailey - 5
13. P.Gallen - 7
14. C.Maunau - 6
15. M.Hilder - 5
16. R.Williams- 6
17. B.Scott - 6

 

[Jo Ryan]

I rate the whole Team a 10 for great effort. Rating each player is a load of crap. Love to see you out there millersnose, youd sh*t you pants with Ryles running at ya.

 

[White Poiner]

1. D.Peachey - 7
2. D.Simmons - 6.5
3. N.Vagana - 9
4. P.Mellor - 5.5
5. L.Covell - 6.5
6. A.Dykes - 4.5
7. B.Kimmorley- 7.5
8. K.Galloway - 3
9. K.Kingston - 7.5
10. D.Nutley - 9
11. P.Leuluai - 8
12. P.Bailey - 6
13. P.Gallen - 7
14. C.Maunau - 6.5
15. M.Hilder - 4
16. R.Williams- 5
17. B.Scott - 5

 

[Jo Ryan]

Stop trying to bait me white pointer I am not going to take the bait.

 

[White Poiner]

Stop trying to bait me white pointer I am not going to take the bait.

Ok then, :?

WTF YOU ON ABOUT

 

[millersnose]

I rate the whole Team a 10 for great effort. Rating each player is a load of crap. Love to see you out there millersnose, youd sh*t you pants with Ryles running at ya.

if you dont like it pal dont participate

who appointed you the judge of the worthiness of threads?

 

[Surely]

biggest load of shiitt you ever written uncle.
Scott was caught out by Gaz at least 3 times. if gaz was scared it was bout how far he was going to have to run.

Scott has poor defence.
Lucky your boy mezz wasnt out there outside scoot or we might have seen a new record by a winger for missed tackles.

I don't think scott was helped much by those inside him on a couple of occasions, but boy did i feel sorry for covell, he was left out there like a shag on a rock

 

[Mr Angry]

if you dont like it pal dont participate

who appointed you the judge of the worthiness of threads?

Yeah What did you do?

I called some cats, you just gave a mark.

I reckon Millers could take him.

 

[Chondricthyes]

1. D.Peachey - 6 not his best but we are going to miss him
2. D.Simmons - 6-OK
3. N.Vagana - 9- out standing
4. P.Mellor - 5.5- best defensive effort this year- won't be missed
5. L.Covell - 6- Comes in too much-KICK YOUR GOALS OR GO
6. A.Dykes - 4.5-not enough to win
7. B.Kimmorley- 8.5- back to best
8. K.Galloway - 3-bye
9. K.Kingston - 8- excellent
10. D.Nutley - 7-tried hard
11. P.Leuluai - 7-best game so far
12. P.Bailey - 6-not good enough
13. P.Gallen - 7-always working
14. C.Maunau - 6.5- thought he should have started the year-will next year
15. M.Hilder - 4- no
16. R.Williams- 6- needs to do more- get fitter
17. B.Scott - 6- OK

Raper- 6 - got the boys up for this or did they do it? Still not enough knowledge when we need it.