player ratings v bunny wabbits

[sharks8601]

no i agree on how you said by his own account he had a shocker
but he made a good break which should of resulted in a try and made plenty of yards and tackles
i still think its a 7

 

[millersnose]

lol

this is like an episode of benny hill

i can hear the theme music .......

 

[blacktip-reefy]

no i agree on how you said by his own account he had a shocker
but he made a good break which should of resulted in a try and made plenty of yards and tackles
i still think its a 7

So despite the fact his game was marred significantly by repeated errors & rule infringement, you still gave him a 7?
so lets remove the 5 errors & penalties, what rating would you have given them then?

Can we just make 10 louder?

THIS ONE GOES TO ELEVEN!

 

[sharks8601]

without the errors it would of been by far his best performance all year

 

[spider]

without the errors it would of been by far his best performance all year

statistically yes - but no

 

[carinashark]

Dud (Hey Im talking Kiwi) he drop two balls? One was a punch out ( the first one) and how many penalties dud he give away ? Doug was worth more and Nuts the same? And Fraser? Is Fraser off loading and breaking tackles ( which he should be doing ) Ok he has come good this year compared to previous years but he has to do more. Ross , Peek , Millington and Gall are the ones doing the damage. Bird has to step up soon as well , at the moment he is a passenger ( like Nigel).

 

[Master Baiter]

6.5?
f**k off! What on earth do you want? We lapped them and are coming equal first.

We blew them off the park even with one of the worst penalty counts AGAINST us in history. It was a great team performance and although we didnt do a Canberra or a Melbourne we did more than enough to get the money. Again. Like we do nearly every week.

youre obviously happy with mediocrity if you thought that was a great team performance. blew them off the park??? really? souths were f**king horrible and we could only manage 28 points? youre easily satisfied.

 

[imasharkie]

sun herald ratings:

Brett Kearney - 7
Misi Taulapapa - 6
Ben Pomeroy - 7
David Simmons - 7
Luke Covell - 6
Brett Seymour - 6
Brett Kimmorley - 7
Ben Ross - 7
Isaac De Gois - 6
Luke Douglas - 7
Paul Gallen - 8

Fraser Anderson - 7
Grant Millington - 5
Danny Nutley - 6
Terence Seu Seu - 5
Greg Bird - 5
Adam Peek - 5

Judge: Adrian Proszenko, The Sun Herald

 

[newman]

youre obviously happy with mediocrity if you thought that was a great team performance. blew them off the park??? really? souths were f**king horrible and we could only manage 28 points? youre easily satisfied.

Yeah obviously. You f**king RAT.
Those on here who know their history, know for over 5 years I have been screaming the club down about acceptance of mediocrity. And not just from behind my keyboard into this useless forum. Ive actually, you know, been inside the club, like, talking to management, and that. YOU f**kING RAT. In the words of the great Ian Mackaye "What the f**k have YOU DONE?"

I do think it is about time that some credit was paid. Two years ago everyone wanted us to be competitive, no matter how we did it. One year ago people just wanted us to win, no matter how we did it. Now what do we want? To win every game by 50? Get serious.
Ricky has been very vocal about the fact that our squad, resources and capabilities are far less than that of other clubs, and its true. For us to be performing as well as we are, as consistently as we are is cause for credit to be paid.

And PS. That girl in your sig. Youve got about as much chance as George W getting elected again.

 

[spider]

haha - thats a fair bite newman

i thought his post made sense

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Has Newms turned into a gangster?
You dirtty raaattt. I'll get you , you diirrty raatt!

 

[Master Baiter]

Yeah obviously. You f**king RAT.
Those on here who know their history, know for over 5 years I have been screaming the club down about acceptance of mediocrity. And not just from behind my keyboard into this useless forum. Ive actually, you know, been inside the club, like, talking to management, and that. YOU f**kING RAT. In the words of the great Ian Mackaye "What the f**k have YOU DONE?"

I do think it is about time that some credit was paid. Two years ago everyone wanted us to be competitive, no matter how we did it. One year ago people just wanted us to win, no matter how we did it. Now what do we want? To win every game by 50? Get serious.
Ricky has been very vocal about the fact that our squad, resources and capabilities are far less than that of other clubs, and its true. For us to be performing as well as we are, as consistently as we are is cause for credit to be paid.

And PS. That girl in your sig. Youve got about as much chance as George W getting elected again.

a rat huh? a f**king rat even... youre a bloody genius!! is that really the best you can do?? :lol: well you're a farkin nobody! i pay credit to my team when i think they have played well, but when they put in a mediocre effort like they did against souths than i reserve the right to be critical of their performance. i dont think they should be winning every game by a big margin, just 1 would be nice, but i thought they could have won more comfortably and more convincingly against a very ordinary team that any decent team would have put 50 on. it must be nice living in your own little world with your own little thoughts, now why dont you go dig up a big scoop that you cant let anyone in on ok, theres a good little boy. congratulations on your new man by the way
ps- the girl in my sig, do you know who she is?