player ratings v dragqueens

[millersnose]

1. Brett Kearney 5 - ordinary
2. Misi Taulapapa 5 ordinary
3. Ben Pomeroy 4 worst game i seen him play
4. David Simmons 6
5. Luke Covell 5
6. Brett Seymour 6
7. Brett Kimmorley 7
8. Ben Ross 7
9. Isaac De Gois 7
10. Luke Douglas 7
11. Paul Gallen 8
12. Fraser Anderson 7
13. Greg Bird7
14. Danny Nutley 6
15. Kade Snowden 7 - a great effort
16. Adam Peek 6

a big difference is emerging between the class in our backs vs the forwards

 

[Frenzy.]

1. Morris - 7
2. Nightingale - 6
3. Stanley - 6
4. Cooper - 8
5. Morris - 7
6. Soward - 7
7. Hornby - 6
8. Poore - 7
9. Young - 7
15. Hunt - 6
11. Scott - 5
12. Saffey - 7
13. Webb - 7
14. Prior - 6
16. Setu - 7
18. Woolford - 6
21. Thorby - 5

 

[millersnose]

its amazing when you look at ratings when you have no prejudice

i would agree with that ratings completely frenzy but i thought poore was the best on the field bar gallen

 

[Frenzy.]

its amazing when you look at ratings when you have no prejudice

i would agree with that ratings completely frenzy but i thought poore was the best on the field bar gallen

Poore was very good. I didn't 8 rate him because my old memory recalls he gave away a penalty or maybe 2 when they didn't need it.

 

[Genius Freak]

3. Ben Pomeroy 4 worst game i seen him play


No way. Bulldogs game this year, everyone ran through him. Could have put my Grandma through the holes he left.

 

[Master Baiter]

halves were well below par, just not good enough if we are going to do anything this year, bird show promising signs of whats to come with limited opportunites and i thought gallen was great once again and snowden was very impressive. oh dougie and de gois were also very good. everyone else needs to lift their game

 

[Squae]

1. Brett Kearney 5/6 - Doesnt seem to be receiving the offloads for 2nd phase play anymore for some reason?
2. Misi Taulapapa 5 - average
3. Ben Pomeroy - 3 absolutely crap
4. David Simmons - 5 average
5. Luke Covell - 5 to slow but can catch
6. Brett Seymour - 6 good game apart from the kicking
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5 good defense, offense was crap
8. Ben Ross - 7 definately coming good
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson 7
13. Craig Millington - 7 this guy looks like the goods, secure him i reckon he would sign for not much probably
14. Danny Nutley 5
15. Kade Snowden 7 - a great effort
16. Adam Peek - 6

Totally agree massive difference between the quality of the forwards in comparison to backs

 

[imasharkie]

1. Brett Kearney - 4: He gets smashed every time he brings the ball back. Not confident under the high ball.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5: average
3. Ben Pomeroy - 3: too big, too slow and too much of a ball hog. we desperately need speedy outside backs who can defend.He was over the line when he tried to bump Soward off. FFS.
4. David Simmons - 6: Whats happened to him. He's running the ball with purpose and defending reasonably well.
5. Luke Covell - 6: Had a much better game this week.
6. Brett Seymour - 6: Beautiful ball for the Covell try.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5: Kicking game was woeful.
8. Ben Ross - 6: went ok. Defended well but not enough grunt in most of his runs.
9. Isaac De Gois - 5: Seemed to be running round in circles and looked lost. Had a couple of good runs and defensive hits but mostly average.
10. Luke Douglas - 7: Very good game again by the big man.
11. Paul Gallen - 8: our mom, he was in every thing.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7: tackles non stop.
13. Greg Bird - 6: a slow game by Birdie, needs fitnes and he'll be up there with Gals.
14. Danny Nutley - 5: didn't do a lot, but held onto the ball and didn't give away any penalties. looked to get injurred in the first tackle he made.
15. Kade Snowden - 6: He runs the ball powerfully and tackles with vigour. Getting more game time and deserves it.
16. Adam Peek - 6: Good game from the old fella.
18. Grant Millington - 7: excellent game. hope he stays in the 17.

 

[carcharias]

I thought Pom was heavily marked .

That missed tackle was weird ...it happened right in front of me.

The Dragons played beyond themselves in defence.
It has got me fugged how we won.

I have never heard so many people giggling at the end of a footy match.

 

[Russell Crowe's Band]

1. Kearney. didn't do much - 5
2. Misi. a couple of dummy half runs...4
3. Pomeroy. butchered a try and then let one in. 0
4. Simmo. fire up. you cat. 3
5. Covell. 5.
6. seymour. 5. very quiet. pretty ordinary kicking
7. Gimp. 70 minutes of rubbish but 10 minutes of arse gets you in the papers. 2
8. Ben Ross - 6. played pretty good.
9. Isaac De Gois. runs werent zippy at all. 4
10. Luke Douglas - 8. played well.
11. Paul Gallen - 8: Workhorse.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7: tackles non stop.
13. Greg Bird - 5. didnt do much. looks underdone.
14. Danny Nutley - 6. solid nuts.
15. Kade Snowden. 7. he played very well i thought
16. Adam Peek. more solid peek. 6
18. Grant Millington. was pretty good actually. 7

 

[carinashark]

Get rid of Gall . The fire has gone out , I mean , no face jobs , no scrumm boil ups, no back chat , no slaps , no niggle !!!!! Geez just hit ups ,off loads , meters gained and some tackling. The guy has lost it big time, how he ever made the world cup side !

 

[Dragon Slayer]

Get rid of Gall . The fire has gone out , I mean , no face jobs , no scrumm boil ups, no back chat , no slaps , no niggle !!!!! Geez just hit ups ,off loads , meters gained and some tackling. The guy has lost it big time, how he ever made the world cup side !

I would swap him for only a couple of other second rowers in the NRL.

But he really sh*ts me when he passes when he shouldn't and doesn't when he does!

 

[DaSuperHero2]

Now for a view thats not so biased.

1. Brett Kearney.7. Very Solid at the back , made one error otherwise played a very solid par with minimul fuss style of game.

2. Missing toiletpaper- 4 - besides a few scoots caught a cold

3. Ben Pomeroy. I hate cronulla but if theres two players I respect this bloke is one of them had a f**king shocker not beating Soward though 3.

4. David Simmons, Did nothing at all. 2

5. Luke Covell. 5

6. Brett Seymour.8 was in absolutely everything without this bloke , total meters gained wouldve been 500

7. Kimmorely , 7 Tried his absolute guts out and payed dividends in the end

8. Ben Ross - Waste of time 2-3 big runs and he was puffed out.5

9. Isaac De Gois.8 Your man of the match, caught us napping more times then a thief.

10. Luke Douglas - 6.5 Solid enough to make his presence felt without setting the world on fire

11. Paul Gallen -8.5 enough said

12. Fraser Anderson - 6.5 Expected more from his runs

13. Greg Bird - 5. Getting back from injury , still played better then lots of the backs put together

14. Danny Nutley - 4 , no one knew he was even playing


15. Kade Snowden. 6 Solid game

16. Adam Peek.6 a simple "peek no fuss " game

18. Grant Millington. 7 played well.

 

[The Dodger]

shintaro was right...

 

[blacktip-reefy]

shintaro was right...

Shintaro has an opinion. I think others on here are much better judges of football than him. & he also doesn't participate in the ratings, just snipes from the side at others giving ratings.
pretty weak.

 

[shintaro]

I don't give a sh!t what you think . I make a measured comment when I feel like it .You look like you're on here all the time talking rubbish or bagging Kimmorley. I'm not sure if any team would appreciate that.
As for wether you think I am a good judge of footy or not....I don't give a sh!t about that either. I find your comments pretty boring

 

[Frenzy.]

Has there been some deletions in here?

 

[blacktip-reefy]

I don't give a sh!t what you think . I make a measured comment when I feel like it .You look like you're on here all the time talking rubbish or bagging Kimmorley. I'm not sure if any team would appreciate that.
As for wether you think I am a good judge of footy or not....I don't give a sh!t about that either. I find your comments pretty boring

I am yet to see any measured comment from you on here about Sharks players. I see measured comments from you about other people on here & where they view the game from(apparently at the ground is superior?)
I bag Kimmorley because as a player he is shyte. Tenacious, courageous, big hearted, yes all those things. But unfortunately, he is complete shyte. & I don't care which team appreciates or doesn't appreciate the reality.
The Dogs are shytting themselves that he is coming.(ps , watch for some big changes there now)
& I think you would find my comments pretty boring. But thanks for letting me know.
But in the meantime, don't let my boring stuff deter you from putting the good info you get up here for the others.

 

[dolph_sharkphin]

1. Brett Kearney - 4: Not his best game.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5: Had some moments where I thought he might do something
3. Ben Pomeroy - 4: Seen better from him for sure.
4. David Simmons - 6: On the improve of late. Whats going on?
5. Luke Covell - 6: If only he had a bit more speed
6. Brett Seymour - 6: Be better if he got more ball than the other one
7. Brett Kimmorley - 4: What the?
8. Ben Ross - 6: Getting better each game.
9. Isaac De Gois - 6: Not as bad as it looked.
10. Luke Douglas - 7: Underated by a mile. Good game.
11. Paul Gallen - 8: Where would we have been without him?
12. Fraser Anderson - 7: Solid.
13. Greg Bird - 5: Obviously needs some games but will be back bigger and betterer
14. Danny Nutley - 5: Not bad.
15. Kade Snowden - 6: I liked his game
16. Adam Peek - 6: I liked his game
18. Grant Millington - 6: I liked his game

 

[shintaro]

But in the meantime, don't let my boring stuff deter you from putting the good info you get up here for the others.
__________________


I'll leave that to you from now on.... By the way ,the team is away in camp preparing for this weeks game. (That's a freeby)