What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

PLAYERS DRAFT

Generalzod

Immortal
Messages
34,247
I think a player Draft is needed if the likes of Cronulla and other lowly clubs are going to be a a genuine premiership threat.
If the NRL are fair dinkum about the plight of lowly placed clubs then a Players Draft is there only option.
Are you guys in favour?????????
It's better than whats happening now were every player is signed by the Roosters.
 

lockyno1

Post Whore
Messages
53,350
It would not work!!

Although I have no problem with the Roosters putting their players in a draft so that it evens out the comp!!! :clap:
 

Shark

Bench
Messages
3,085
Well mate, he's right.

See, there is a bloke called Terry Hill. And thanks to Tezza, there is now a legal precedent in the NSW Supreme Court that makes a player draft illegal.

Happened about 12 years ago or more. But you were probably still on your way here from Krypton back then.
 

Generalzod

Immortal
Messages
34,247
Shark said:
Well mate, he's right.

See, there is a bloke called Terry Hill. And thanks to Tezza, there is now a legal precedent in the NSW Supreme Court that makes a player draft illegal.

Happened about 12 years ago or more. But you were probably still on your way here from Krypton back then.

A draft works perfectly in the AFL...
For the Good of the game a draft is needed...It would make for a fairer competition.
I knew about Terry and his legal action against the draft....
 

Shark

Bench
Messages
3,085
YES mate, a draft WOULD be good.

And it does work in AFL, although I wouldn't say perfectly.

Problem is, Victoria has not had it's draft tested in Court. VIC and NSW have differences in their precedents and Court structures.

In NSW, the home of the NRL, a draft has been proven ILLEGAL.

If a disgruntled AFL player chose to challenge it, the draft would probably fail there too,
 

dreary

Juniors
Messages
930
I think you will find that one of the clauses for a contract with any AFL club has in it that the player will accept the draft and if not they can go run around in the local comp and it has been there for years

The problem for the NRL is trying to implement this clause now some self interested players will try to stop it from being implemented (see T. Hill)
 

Shark

Bench
Messages
3,085
Exactly, Dreary!

This is from today's SMH:

North Queensland chief executive Denis Keeffe has predicted the Players Association will eventually forgo the right to take a draft to court in exchange for a guaranteed share of the NRL's income.

Speaking after the Cowboys beat Parramatta 28-6 at Dairy Farmers Stadium on Saturday night, Keeffe also said there would be an external draft in place by 2006.

"A draft is inevitable, it must come into our game," he told Townsville radio station 4TO. "The first step has been taken with the CBA [Collective Bargaining Agreement]. [a draft] is legally a restraint of trade and we have to get the players to agree not to contest it."

Interviewed later by the Herald, Keeffe said: "The players have to be given a guaranteed percentage of the turnover of the game. Once we settle on that figure, what they do in return is undertake not to take the draft to court. That is the way every major professional sporting competition in the world is going and it's the one thing we are missing at the moment."

Keeffe said he expected there to be an external draft for players coming into the NRL in two years' time. He said it would "combine an open draft and a territorial draft".

"Each club would be able to nominate five players from their territory which they have first rights on and after that it would be an open draft," he said. "We have two clubs with no development at all - Melbourne and the Roosters. They will have to be given territories."

When Keeffe's comments were put to Gallop in Newcastle yesterday, he said the only proposal currently on the drawing board was the territorial draft.

"There is a panel working on that," he said. "An internal draft is not on the agenda at this time."
 

Latest posts

Top