Rate the NSW players

[cleary89]

Minichello - 1 - Should retire after that. Someone make sure he isn't found hanging in his room tomorrow, or do, what ever he deserves it.
Morris - 6 - Early dropped ball, few cruical tackles and made some good metres
Gaz - 6 - Same as Morris, his best game of the series though
Hayne - 6 - Standard game, played pretty well, threatened with ball in hand, but didn't go looking for it, didn't defend overly well, but for first run in the centres a decent performance
Uate - 7.5 - Didn't put a foot wrong, will be there next year
Soward - 6.5 - The only half that looked threatening, defended well. Needs more involvement but had a good game
Pearce - 5 - f**k him off
Gallen - 8 - Huge work load, put his hand up
Ennis - 4 - Shit kick, shit human
Mannah - 6.5 - I thought he went well, big involvement early on
Stewart - 7 - Replaced Beau Scott, stood up, showed he he should have been there all along
Creagh - 6.5 - Standard game, went alright
Bird - 6 - Threatened early, wasn't highly involved

Gidley - 5 - Had high hopes after game 2, back to his regular game of being a spastic
Galloway - 5 - Did he only make one run?
Watmough - 6.5 - Apart from the try he let in, really stood up
Lewis - 6.5 - No nonsense game, went alright.

To be dropped - Mini (for hayne), Jennings back in, possibly f**k Morris off, Maybe pearce, Ennis has had his time. Rest goes alright.

 

[Squae]

Mini - 0, far out thanks buddy AWESOME!!!

 

[hineyrulz]

How many mins did the Mannah and Galloway get??? Don't know why Sticky picks frontrowers at all.

 

[hugzy]

ur ratings pretty spot on

i think lineup we had for game 2 we'll go with

oh i dunno i just feel sick... we got our faces SPAT UPON AGAIN

 

[j0nesy]

I agree with cleary's ratings. With the exception of Gidley - 2, Pearce - 3, Mini - 3. They were god awful tonight.

 

[andrew057]

Soward had a good game? lolz.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Mini - 2. Good player had a shocker.
Morris - 3. Just not an origin standard player.
Gasnier - 6. Reliable, but histime has passed.
Hayne - 4. Felt for him, played out of position.
Uate - 7. Proved he's the up to this standard ++
Soward - 5. Wasn't helped by having a spastic at halfback.
Pearce - 2. Wish he was dead.

Gallen - 8. Standout blues player 2011, well done skipper.
Ennis - 2. Injured early but surely the myth is busted.
Mannah - 5. Outplayed by his opposites but he'll be back.
Stewart - 5. Put in but not a long term solution.
Creagh - 6. Usual 6/10 performance. Nuff sed.
Bird - 4. The next Wally Lewis. :lol:

Lewis - 7. Should start next year surely.
Galloway - 1. Hope he keeps his jersey in a very safe spot coz he won't get another one.
Watmough - 5. A poor man's gallen.
Gidley - 2. Ring Gids and tell him to get f**ked.

 

[El Diablo]

Soward had a good game? lolz.

agreed

he was woeful

should never be picked again

 

[IFR33K]

Minichello - 1 - Should retire after that. Someone make sure he isn't found hanging in his room tomorrow, or do, what ever he deserves it.
Morris - 6 - Early dropped ball, few cruical tackles and made some good metres
Gaz - 6 - Same as Morris, his best game of the series though
Hayne - 6 - Standard game, played pretty well, threatened with ball in hand, but didn't go looking for it, didn't defend overly well, but for first run in the centres a decent performance
Uate - 7.5 - Didn't put a foot wrong, will be there next year
Soward - 6.5 - The only half that looked threatening, defended well. Needs more involvement but had a good game
Pearce - 5 - f**k him off
Gallen - 8 - Huge work load, put his hand up
Ennis - 4 - Shit kick, shit human
Mannah - 6.5 - I thought he went well, big involvement early on
Stewart - 7 - Replaced Beau Scott, stood up, showed he he should have been there all along
Creagh - 6.5 - Standard game, went alright
Bird - 6 - Threatened early, wasn't highly involved

Gidley - 5 - Had high hopes after game 2, back to his regular game of being a spastic
Galloway - 5 - Did he only make one run?
Watmough - 6.5 - Apart from the try he let in, really stood up
Lewis - 6.5 - No nonsense game, went alright.

To be dropped - Mini (for hayne), Jennings back in, possibly f**k Morris off, Maybe pearce, Ennis has had his time. Rest goes alright.

Did we watch the same game.

 

[andrew057]

Morris - 6 - Early dropped ball, few cruical tackles and made some good metres
Gaz - 6 - Same as Morris, his best game of the series though
Soward - 6.5 - The only half that looked threatening, defended well. Needs more involvement but had a good game
Creagh - 6.5 - Standard game, went alright

:lol::lol::lol:

Good one. Who do you support again?

Butter fingers Brett was terrible again, offers nothing.

Gaz, was he even playing?

Soward, the king of the precision kick....down Slaters throat.

Creagh? Went alright? You shouldve stopped after the 10th schooner mate.

 

[Masoe_eats_babies]

~How the f**k can you give Watmough a 5? He had a very strong game.

And I also need to apologise for slamming Stewart yesterday, I thought he went surprisingly well. Of course I'm drunk and must review when sober but thought he had a good game.

I thought Hayne went good too. Atleast a 6. But I am still drunk

 

[MacDougall]

Mannah got 20 mins, Galloway 10. Should have had extra attack players in the side instead of them. Play Creagh at prop, start with Lewis, throw Farah and Idris on the bench. He would have found far more use out of them.

 

[Raiders_Premiers]

Mini for Hayne :lol: :lol: :lol:

just what we need, another overrated spastic at fullback

 

[oval]

Mini - shithouse (3)
Morris - surely NSW have better wingers (5)
Gasnier - not bad, better than the other games (6.5)
Hayne - thought he did alright (6)
Uate - a keeper (7)
Soward - not bad, tried his little heart out (6)
Pearce - poop - that pass near the end was fvcken geniused (4)
Gallen - played alright, annoyed me with his post-match whinge about the refs (7)
Ennis - anus (5)
Mannah - OK (6)
Stewart - solid game (7.5)
Creagh - vanilla (6)
Bird - nothing jumps out about his game (6)
Gidley - total mong (3)
Galloway - invisible (5)
Watmough - had a crack (6.5)
Lewis - f**k me dead another player who was nothing more than "alright" (6)

Least enjoyable game of the series. So many head slapping moments.

 

[LatK7]

People are trashing Soward? Jesus, how could he have done much better with the crap most of the others dished up? Seriously...

 

[cleary89]

:lol::lol::lol:

Good one. Who do you support again?

Butter fingers Brett was terrible again, offers nothing.

Gaz, was he even playing?

Soward, the king of the precision kick....down Slaters throat.

Creagh? Went alright? You shouldve stopped after the 10th schooner mate.

Brett dropped one, made a couple of good takes, a couple of good tackles, set up the big hayne run. He made one mistake, how is a 6 a biased score?

Gaz clearly had his best game, set up two tries, made a couple of half breaks. Was not a bad game from him.

Soward was easily our best half. And creagh was solid as most people will agree.

 

[Wally21]

Mini for Hayne :lol: :lol: :lol:

just what we need, another overrated spastic at fullback

You would know spastics wouldn't you, Mr Dugan's Fluffer...

Raiders Premiers and credibility are mutually exclusive.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

1. Minichello - 4 - Terrible. Just would not have a go at anything on the ground.
2. Morris - 6 - Solid game. Formed a good combination with Hayne at the end there.
3. Gasnier - 6 - Best game of the series for him but that's not saying much. Needed to link with Uate more.
4. Hayne - 7 - More involved tonight with some great touches and didn't pack it in at the end. As said before, formed a good combo with Morris.
5. Uate - 7 - Another good performance. One of the few who you can guarantee a spot next year.
6. Soward - 7 - Thought he had a solid game. Was getting some good ball out wide at times. I know having players out of position is taboo but might do well to chuck him in the 7 and team him up with someone like Carney or Campese.
7. Pearce - 4 - Deadset ordinary. That kick out on the full in the first half pretty much buried us. Played panic football from then on.
8. Gallen - 9 - Player of the series for mine. Another huge effort.
9. Ennis - 4 - I don't know if he was told to kick on the 3rd of the first set but helped put NSW on the backfoot early. That said, wished he was there instead of Gidley.
10. Mannah - 6 - Was good while on but should have had more game time.
11. Stewart - 8 - Good game. Was dangerous out wide and worked hard.
12. Creagh - 7 - Also good out wide but needed more involvement.
13. Bird - 7 - Toiled hard and gave it his all as always.

14. Gidley - 2 - WTF?
15. Galloway - 5 - Under utilised
16. Watmough - 7 - Another good showing. Handy player to have.
17. Lewis - 7 - Good game from Lewis both defensively and in attack.

Players in key positions let us down tonight. I thought Soward was solid but the 1, 7 and 9 (I refer to Gidley here) were atrocious. All contributing to having us pinned in our own half for most of the first half.

Forwards were good IMO. But were just too stuffed after the first half to break the game open for NSW.

 

[rabbits1]

Pearce-0
Minichello-0
I wish they played for Queensland should never be selected again for the blues

 

[DOGS AND EELS!!!]

Hayne was one of NSW best, out played Hodges no doubt. I dunno why Stuart picked props how long were Galloway and Mannah on for??? they were solid for their duration tho. stewart i think hoged the ball a bit to much, he kinda starved Gaz and more importantly Uate