southsport
First Grade
- Messages
- 9,556
What I meant by Tass not being ready is that he's recently back from injury.H
He isn’t ready yet either
.
What I meant by Tass not being ready is that he's recently back from injury.H
He isn’t ready yet either
I cant see why not,in times of need you use what youve got,rorters used walker at 19, parra are tying up that 20year old centre we maybe should have poached last year, cowboys using young winger etc karapani hasnt had much game time ok,but tass has been playing qld cup,i say bite the F bullet,we should not have left gagai go,even on 1 foot he was man of the match.H
He isn’t ready yet either
Cody looked frustrated and depressedIMO Cody and Cook really need to lift after last week, they are the senior players who are needed to steer these young blokes around. Keep the silly errors (incorrect play the ball, knock ons from scrum etc) and get our 5th tackle kicks away and that’ll go along way.
If there is actual effort from each player, there is no reason we can’t take it to the storm, forget the 50-0 flogging, they only got us by 8 points in that first game last year. Let’s break that idea that we can’t beat them!
This is his time to shine, not get all frustrated. Clean up his errors and the little aspects of his game. If Cody is firing, the squad is aswell. Hopefully it was just an off night for him.Cody looked frustrated and depressed
What's wrong with putting Karapani in there?? Demetriou sticking stubbionly with Paulo as a centre is doomed, it reminds me of how Maguire sunk himself for 6 straight games in 2017 playing Tuggboat Talakai as a centre when everyone could see he is purely a barging, metre getting back rower. This helped cost Maguire credibility as a HC and eventually cost him his position. Yet when he finally dumped Talakai it were too late the squad was used to heroic defeats.What I meant by Tass not being ready is that he's recently back from injury.
.
Cannot agree! We have Walker, Cook, Murray and Mitchell. Four of THE best the NRL can offer. This is NOT rebuilding!! Its up to Demetriou to prove he can coach successfully. Blooding guys like Karapani is exactly what is needed yet Demetriou seems allergic to doing it. Paulo is not a centre yet Demetriou persists. Taaffe too could be an option in the halves he seems far too light to continually play FB. Taaffe from memory did play 5/8 or half in a winning JFlegg program. Wrong choices and inability as a coach to develop new players leads to a short life for coaches.It was always going to be a rebuilding season so there's no point in focussing on early season form, we just need to enjoy the ride no matter what.
.
JD probably wants to have a look at Paulo with Mitchell at fullback and AJ on the left wing.What's wrong with putting Karapani in there?? Demetriou sticking stubbionly with Paulo as a centre is doomed, it reminds me of how Maguire sunk himself for 6 straight games in 2017 playing Tuggboat Talakai as a centre when everyone could see he is purely a barging, metre getting back rower. This helped cost Maguire credibility as a HC and eventually cost him his position. Yet when he finally dumped Talakai it were too late the squad was used to heroic defeats.
The Paulo/"Demetriou knows best" process now playing is eerily similar to what happened with Maguire. Eventually and rather ironically this led to us importing yes... Gagai! Isn't this ironic?
Overall, showing Reynolds Gagai etc the door all at once because of the fear of quote "being put in Sam Burgess/GI type situations with injured veterans on large contracts". This is really immature and novice like behaviour by the hierachy running the squad. Surely the prerequisite should have been "do we currently have better or equal options to these veterans via the youth teams?" The answer appears obvious. Further, most of these teams could not play last season hence the question: how do these officials expect "emerging" younger highly inexperienced players with very little recent game time at any level to fill the important breaches left by immature recruitment policies??
There has been a lot of talk about the energing crop of good young talent. Yet Kalo Kalo, Karapani are ignored for a position of dire need and Moale does not look anywhere near the hype surrounding him. Nothing even close to it! Ilias may be good its obvious he needs more playing time and a clearly defined role.
Two things we definitely know. One, Bennett never played Paulo as a centre nor did he ever suggest he would, even with players absent. Two, should the side fall badly and continue at say 7-10 ppg Demetriou will be sacked.
I think we lost our first 3 matches in 2012 when Reyno replaced Sandow, early days yet, let's not start slashing our wrists after one loss, there's still a lot of water to go under the bridge in season 2022.Cannot agree! We have Walker, Cook, Murray and Mitchell. Four of THE best the NRL can offer. This is NOT rebuilding!! Its up to Demetriou to prove he can coach successfully. Blooding guys like Karapani is exactly what is needed yet Demetriou seems allergic to doing it. Paulo is not a centre yet Demetriou persists. Taaffe too could be an option in the halves he seems far too light to continually play FB. Taaffe from memory did play 5/8 or half in a winning JFlegg program. Wrong choices and inability as a coach to develop new players leads to a short life for coaches.
The club needs to target Eddie Jones as HC, a true supporter ex-Randwick rugby guy: Jones has won everywhere he has been, has charisma and is similar in stature to Bennett. Did you see Eddie last season in an International Rugby game coaching England? He had a Souths Bunny Cap on!!
From what I see Demetriou is not good. And the squad play no good. That's on him its not like he has no big names!! Keep up the 10 or less ppg, the continual errors and fumbling and he will be toast.
The only thing i dont agree with is sacking JD whats happened here isnt his fault not when youve got Ello,solly and the great pappas making the 30plus decision, gags on 1 leg was man of the match last week and debatebly the biggest loss. Our deadly left edge is no more, cody is a shadow,cookie useless, and why is murray even playing? He had the same op as cleary at the same time,cleary isnt ready how is cam ready? And he played like it as well.What's wrong with putting Karapani in there?? Demetriou sticking stubbionly with Paulo as a centre is doomed, it reminds me of how Maguire sunk himself for 6 straight games in 2017 playing Tuggboat Talakai as a centre when everyone could see he is purely a barging, metre getting back rower. This helped cost Maguire credibility as a HC and eventually cost him his position. Yet when he finally dumped Talakai it were too late the squad was used to heroic defeats.
The Paulo/"Demetriou knows best" process now playing is eerily similar to what happened with Maguire. Eventually and rather ironically this led to us importing yes... Gagai! Isn't this ironic?
Overall, showing Reynolds Gagai etc the door all at once because of the fear of quote "being put in Sam Burgess/GI type situations with injured veterans on large contracts". This is really immature and novice like behaviour by the hierachy running the squad. Surely the prerequisite should have been "do we currently have better or equal options to these veterans via the youth teams?" The answer appears obvious. Further, most of these teams could not play last season hence the question: how do these officials expect "emerging" younger highly inexperienced players with very little recent game time at any level to fill the important breaches left by immature recruitment policies??
There has been a lot of talk about the energing crop of good young talent. Yet Kalo Kalo, Karapani are ignored for a position of dire need and Moale does not look anywhere near the hype surrounding him. Nothing even close to it! Ilias may be good its obvious he needs more playing time and a clearly defined role.
Two things we definitely know. One, Bennett never played Paulo as a centre nor did he ever suggest he would, even with players absent. Two, should the side fall badly and continue at say 7-10 ppg Demetriou will be sacked.
Well I notice Demetriou has mentioned "attack" in refernce to Mitchell's return. I stand firm what I said. If the squad contiue at 4-7 ppg or even less, the coach is toast. And further I note Demetriou has no A Grade experience as a HC and no real charisma. He has had 3-4 months or more to prepare players like Ilias yet the young man seems lost and hesitant. Nor do I understand why you people are not pushing for Taaffe as the #7. He has acceleration, ball handling and kicking skills and he has starting GF experience. Taaffe needs to be used much more his talent is obvious but for some reason the club seems to be restraining it.The only thing i dont agree with is sacking JD whats happened here isnt his fault not when youve got Ello,solly and the great pappas making the 30plus decision, gags on 1 leg was man of the match last week and debatebly the biggest loss. Our deadly left edge is no more, cody is a shadow,cookie useless, and why is murray even playing? He had the same op as cleary at the same time,cleary isnt ready how is cam ready? And he played like it as well.
Yes ive said it before 1 player AR loss was enough,weve compounded it. Everything else youve said is spot on
Taaffe is out injured for a few weeks so Ilias will be our #7.Well I notice Demetriou has mentioned "attack" in refernce to Mitchell's return. I stand firm what I said. If the squad contiue at 4-7 ppg or even less, the coach is toast. And further I note Demetriou has no A Grade experience as a HC and no real charisma. He has had 3-4 months or more to prepare players like Ilias yet the young man seems lost and hesitant. Nor do I understand why you people are not pushing for Taaffe as the #7. He has acceleration, ball handling and kicking skills and he has starting GF experience. Taaffe needs to be used much more his talent is obvious but for some reason the club seems to be restraining it.